Update
Hello everyone,
We’re back in South Palm Beach visiting my Mum and daughter and son-in-law. Although a lot of people moved to Florida from other parts of the country in the wake of COVID, it’s still a very seasonal area. And there are far fewer people here than when we were last here in January: Better for shopping, cycling and eating out.
I had the pleasure of joining Dereck Guttierez on his Unity in Identity Podcast. His mission is perfectly aligned with that of my own i.e. empower people with an understanding about how things really work which leads to positive change and greater empathy for your fellow citizens. We had a great chat.
Summary
- Lululemon has not grown comparable store sales in the US for almost two years.
- And we review a scathing attack from the company’s founder.
- Mortgage payments vs. income have increased over the last twenty-five years.
- This, despite much lower mortgage rates.
- Correction, because of much lower mortgage rates.ars.
- This, despite much lower mortgage rates.
- Ski-Doo and Sea-Doo maker BRP has experienced strong sales growth of late.
- But new tariffs whacked the company’s share price.
- Church & Dwight is a well-run consumer products company.
- But even their sales have slowed to a crawl.
- In Financial Ructions:
- A look at average US productivity growth through the decades.
- A look at the jobs situation in Canada.
- And comparing government vs. private worker job growth.
- It’s bad news.
- And comparing government vs. private worker job growth.
- An article in the Financial Times again attempts to blame the high inflation of 2022 on the Russia/Ukraine war.
- No, it was policy-driven.
- Book Review
- Although base money soared in the 1930s due to gold flooding into the U.S.
- The Administration, through the Fed, did its best to limit its impact on the money supply.
- What recovery there was up to 1937 was a result of consumer spending.
- But it was not accompanied by investment and there was no increase in the capital stock.
- PM: In other words, you can’t consume your way to prosperity.
- Although base money soared in the 1930s due to gold flooding into the U.S.
News
Lululemon: Cracks Are Starting To Appear
Lululemon is a Canadian-based athletic apparel company:
- Started in Vancouver in 1998.
- They have 811 stores.
- Up 1.9% from last year.
- Over the last few years the company has started to lose its way.
Comparable sales growth by quarter:
- 4Q/2023: +12%
- 1Q/2024: +7%
- 2Q/2024: +3%
- 3Q/2024: +3%
- 4Q/2024: +4%
- 1Q/2025: +1%
- 2Q/2025: +1%
- 3Q/2025: +2%
- 4Q/2025: +2%
Comparable store sales in the Americas region haven’t grown for almost two years:
- 4Q/2023: +7%
- 1Q/2024: 0%
- 2Q/2024: -2%
- 3Q/2024: -2%
- 4Q/2024: 0%
- 1Q/2025: -1%
- 2Q/2025: -3%
- 3Q/2025: -5%
- 4Q/2025: -2%
Last October, company founder Chip Wilson placed a scathing full-page ad in the Wall Street Journal advocating for change at the Board of Directors. According to Chip:
- The original processes were so simple that a refrigerator could manage them.
- New directors have dismantled that business model.
- And are now focused on finance and operations and lack vision with no finger on the market pulse.
- Innovation and creativity have been compromised.
- Like many businesses in the past, the focus shifts from the product to growing the store base.
- PM: McDonald’s did this many years ago but quickly realised the damage they were doing to their brand and changed course.
- Management who were responsible for Lululemon’s great success eventually leave and are “replaced by Nike executives who import a failed business model.”
- Ouch.
- The company sacrificed product and store quality on the altar of higher profit margins.
- PM: Good in the short-term, terrible in the long-term.
- The Board prioritised hiring CEOs who could “speak Wall Street.”
- The company lost its edge by trying to appease “everyone.”
- Lululemon is losing its soul.
- Bring entrepreneurial ownership back onto the board.
- PM: Yes, entrepreneurial spirit is more about attitude and the customer value proposition rather than size.
- Stop chasing Wall Street at the expense of customers.
- PM: I talk about this in the corporate culture section of my book Capital Offence: Why Some Benefit at Your Expense.
- Growth alone is not a healthy measure of success.
- PM: Correct, and that also goes for an economy when growth is measured by GDP.
- Increased government spending to drive GDP higher is really bad for the economy.
- PM: Correct, and that also goes for an economy when growth is measured by GDP.
- The true measure is innovation and brand reputation.
- PM: In an economy, the true measure is saving, investment, innovation and productivity growth.
- Not growth in final spending.
- PM: In an economy, the true measure is saving, investment, innovation and productivity growth.
- “The world doesn’t need another bland, quarterly-driven apparel company.”
- New directors have dismantled that business model.
The company has recently been taking actions to shake things up.
- Hired a new creative director.
- New products are now arriving in the stores.
- Reconfiguring stores to make them less cluttered.
- Hired a director who used to be CEO of Levi Strauss.
- CEO Calvin McDonald stepped down and the company is searching for a new one.
Share price performance:
- 1-year: -38.8%
- 5-year: -51.0%
US Home Prices Vs. Income
Average monthly mortgage payment on a median home as a percentage of the gross median personal income assuming a 20% downpayment: Calculated from FRED data (median personal income, median home price, average 30-year mortgage rate).
- 1974-1979: 13.9%
- 1980s: 30.8%
- 1990s: 29.3%
- 2000s: 33.4%
- 2010s: 33.7%
- 2020s: 48.0%
- 2024: 57.6%
A couple of notes.
- This would look way worse in Canada and Australia.
- For instance, in Canada in 2024 the monthly mortgage payment was 78-82% of monthly personal gross income (GROK).
- Second, I used personal income rather than household income.
- Policymakers like using household income as it shows better affordability but that’s only because more people in the household have to work than before.
- In fact house prices could get so expensive that you’d need four income earners in the home.
- And government statistics would show an improvement in affordability.
- In fact house prices could get so expensive that you’d need four income earners in the home.
- Policymakers like using household income as it shows better affordability but that’s only because more people in the household have to work than before.
- Third, I used gross income so on a disposable (after-tax) income basis, mortgage payments are a considerably higher burden.
- Although slightly lower income taxes today would help to some degree; at least compared to back in the 1980s.
- We have not seen similar tax rate deductions in Canada.
- Although slightly lower income taxes today would help to some degree; at least compared to back in the 1980s.
- Bottom line, despite considerably higher mortgage rates in the 1980s and 90s, mortgage payments still took up less of one’s income.
- Housing was still more affordable back then for Baby Boomers than it is today for younger people.
- And note how the percentage of one’s income going to mortgage payments started rising in the 2000s coincident with the US Federal Reserve reducing mortgage rates.
- Lower mortgage rates were more than offset by skyrocketing home prices due to increased demand which resulted from the record low interest rates.
Bombs Away
BRP (Bombardier Recreational Products) owns the following brands:
- Ski-DOO: Snowmobiles
- Lynx: Snowmobiles
- CAN-AM:
- Off-road vehicles (ATVs)
- On-road vehicles (motorcycles, three-wheel vehicles)
- SEA-DOO
A look back:
- 1937: In Valcourt, Quebec (120km east of Montreal) J.A. Bombardier developed the first vehicle that can travel on snow.
- 1959: Launches Ski-Doo
- Check-out this ridiculous Ski-Doo ad from the 1970s here
- 1968: Sea-Doo
- 1989: Buys Lynx
- Started in Finland in 1968.
- 1998: Entered all terrain vehicle market
- 2001: Bought Evinrude and Johnson outboard motors.
- 2007: Discontinued the Johnson brand
- 2020: Stopped making outboard motors and retired the Evinrude name.
- Funny old Evinrude ad here
- 2025: Sold their boating/marine division.
Sales growth (reported):
- 2Q/2024: +14.0%
- 3Q/2024: -8.9%
- 4Q/2024: -12.5%
- 1Q/2025: -16.4%
- 2Q/2025: -33.7%
- Inventory destocking at dealers.
- 3Q/2025: -17.5%
- 4Q/2025: -19.7%
- 1Q/2026: -7.7%
- 2Q/2026: +4.3%
- 3Q/2026: +14.0%
- 4Q/2026: +16.0%
- By sector:
- Year-Round Products: +16.8%
- Seasonal Products: +17.5%
- Parts, Accessories, Engines etc.: +9.9 %
The company mentioned that their business will be hit by changes to tariffs in the US.
- Previously, the tariff was 50% charged on the metal content of the vehicles.
- It is now 25% on the value of the entire vehicle.
- Its share price fell 35% on the announcement.
Share price performance:
- 1yr: +76.4%
- 5yr: -37.0%
Church & Dwight
Church & Dwight was founded in 1842 and is based in Ewing, New Jersey.
- Ewing is around 60 miles southwest of New York City.
They own brands such as:
- Arm & Hammer
- Oxi Clean
- Trojan
- Orajel
- Nair
- WATERPIK
- Pepsodent
- Aim Toothpaste
- Close-Up (US rights)
- RUB A535
- Arrid
They have a “balanced portfolio of value and premium products.”
Adjusted sales growth:
- 1Q/2024: +5.2%
- 2Q/2024: +4.7%
- 3Q/2024: +4.3%
- 4Q/2024: +4.2%
- 1Q/2025: -1.2%
- 2Q/2025: +0.1%
- 3Q/2025: +3.4%
- 4Q/2025: +0.7%
- Consumer Domestic: -0.1%
- Household products: -1.5%
- Personal care products: +9.76%
- Consumer International: +3.6%
- Consumer Domestic: -0.1%
We last wrote about Church & Dwight in February 2023: Post 135
- At the time the Chief Marketing Officer of Church & Dwight said “I don’t know if technically, we’re in a recession or not, but our consumer sure feels that we’re in a recession.
Share price performance:
- 1yr: -8.2%
- 5yr: +10%
Financial Ructions
Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…
Productivity Growth
US productivity simple average growth by decade: FRED
- Late 1940s: 3.1%
- 1950s: 2.7%
- 1960s: 2.8%
- Last decade of harder money era
- 1970s: 2.0%
- Fiat currency soft money era begins
- 1980s: 1.5%
- 1990s: 2.3%
- 2000s: 2.8%
- Internet era.
- Note productivity would have been even higher if combined with hard money.
- Internet era.
- 2010s: 1.2%
- QE era
- Slowest productivity growth on record.
- QE era
- 2020s: 2.2%
- AI era?
- Again, would have been higher if not for fiat and QE.
- AI era?
Canada Jobs: Labour Force Survey
- Jul 2025: – 41,000
- Aug 2025: -66,000
- Sep 2025: +66,000
- Oct 2025: +67,000
- Nov 2025: +54,000
- Dec 2025: +8,200
- Jan 2026: -25,000
- Feb 2026: -84,000
- Mar 2026: +14,000
The employment rate: the percentage of those 15 years and older in the workforce.
- Feb 2020: 62.1%
- Jun 2025: 60.9%
- Jul 2025: 60.7%
- Aug 2025: 60.5%
- Sep 2025: 60.6%
- Oct 2025: 60.8%
- Nov 2025: 60.9%
- Dec 2025: 60.9%
- Jan 2026: 60.8%
- Feb 2026: 60.6%
- Mar 2026: 60.6%
Unemployment rate:
- Jul 2025: 6.9%
- Aug 2025: 7.1%
- Sep 2025: 7.1%
- Oct 2025: 6.9%
- Nov 2025: 6.5%
- Dec 2025: 6.8%
- Jan 2026: 6.5%
- Feb 2026: 6.7%
- Mar 2026: 6.7%
Wage growth:
- Jul 2025: +3.3%
- Aug 2025: +3.2%
- Sep 2025: +3.3%
- Oct 2025: +3.5%
- Nov 2025: +3.6%
- Dec 2025: +3.4%
- Jan 2026: +3.3%
- Feb 2026: +3.3%
- Mar 2026: +4.7%
One year growth in employment:
- Private sector: +0.6%
- Public sector (government): +1.2%
Ten-year average annual growth rate in employment:
- Private sector: 1.7%
- Public sector (government): 2.6%
- Cumulative public sector job growth: 29.4%
- Of which:
- Healthcare, Social Assistance and Education: 28.4%
- Healthcare and social assistance: 34.3%
- Education: 19.7%
- Healthcare, Social Assistance and Education: 28.4%
Government employees as a percentage of total employees:
- 2015: 23%
- 2025: 25%
- PM: Note that this number has been in this range going back to the 1970s.
Government spending in Canada as a percentage of GDP (IMF):
- 1970: 36.0%
- 1990: 48.8%
- This was a culmination of three decades of rampant increases in government spending by both sides of the aisle.
- 1995 the Wall Street Journal had a piece called Bankrupt Canada.
- And that it was an “honorary member of the third world.”
- Jean Chretian and Paul Martin did a great job getting our fiscal house in order.
- But only did so when they had no choice.
- Canada’s debt went no bid.
- But only did so when they had no choice.
- 2000: 41.1%
- 2010: 43.1%
- 2024: 44.7%
More Inflation Nonsense
The Financial Times had an article about consumer products companies and the challenge of yet again passing on higher input costs to their customers.
- Specifically, they say the current situation with the war in Iran “has echoes of 2022, when the aftermath of the pandemic and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine sparked inflation in energy and commodities…”
- PM: No, the inflation was not a Putin price hike.
- Inflation in the U.S. was 7.8% before the war even started.
- And six months after the war started inflation was actually lower than before it started.
- The inflation in the U.S. and other countries was caused by a flood of liquidity from central banks printing trillions of dollars.
- And from governments spending like drunken sailors.
- And in terms of commodity prices:
- Before the war even started, the Global Commodities Price Index (FRED) was already up 74% vs pre-COVID levels!
- Apologists for out of control central banks and government deficit spending continue to blame inflation on the Ukraine war and supply chain disruptions.
- While they may have made minor contributions, the prices of all goods cannot have gone up as much as they did if the money supply had not exploded higher.
- Of course, none of this is to imply that if war in the middle east continues and oil supply is disrupted that it won’t impact inflation.
- It will.
Book Review: “False Dawn“
By: George Selgin | 2025
Chapter 14: FDR’s Fed
Despite government actions working against the economy, it did “recover considerably” from 1933 to 1937.
- Unemployment fell from 25% to 11%
- Industrial production more than doubled.
- Nominal spending was up 60%.
The growth in spending was almost entirely due to an increase in the money supply.
- There are two things that lead to growth in the money supply.
- Growth in the stock of base money:
- PM: Today, this is controlled by the Federal Reserve.
- Back then it was anchored to gold.
- There was a minimum requirement of 40% gold to reserves.
- And the base could be increased by the Fed buying commercial paper (bills) and Treasury securities.
- An increase in the base money multiplier.
- The ratio of bank deposits and currency to the base money.
- Growth in the stock of base money:
Through the 30s, the money multiplier consistently fell.
- Meaning that the increase in the money supply was due to an increase in base money.
- And that was almost entirely due to an increase in gold holdings.
The Fed was increasing the monetary base in 1932 via open market operations and this contributed to the recovery.
- President Hoover played a role in this happening.
Starting in 1932 actions were taken that freed up the Fed’s ability to increase the monetary base.
- 1932 Glass Steagall Act that allowed Treasury securities to be used as collateral for Federal Reserve notes.
- The holiday suspension of gold payments.
- PM: Including FDR banning most private citizens from holding gold.
- The US dollar devaluation vs. gold: From $20.67 an ounce to $35.00.
Then, the Banking Act of 1935 effectively subordinated monetary policy to “administration, and particularly Treasury, policy.”
- And was particularly apparent during World War II when the Fed “fully ceded monetary policy to Treasury financing requirements…”
Fed Chair Mariner Eccles was worried about growing reserves in the banking system and that if used by the banks it could lead to inflation.
- And with “evident support” from FDR’s administration, took steps to limit money growth.
- Selgin says that this was partly responsible for the 1937 Roosevelt Recession.
- And that as FDR’s administration had so much control over monetary policy, “…if monetary policy did less than it might have to end the Great Depression, the Roosevelt administration must bear most of the blame.”
Chapter 15: The Recovery So Far
Selgin notes that although parts of the first New Deal had “recovery” aims, that was not so for the Second New Deal.
Between 1933 and 1937 “real GNP in the United States grew at an average rate of over 8 percent per year.” Romer.
National Recover Act (NRA) codes served as an “adverse supply shock.”
- The blanket code mainly raised labor costs.
- Industry-specific codes “often served to enforce monopoly prices and correspondingly reduced output.”
Gold flooding to the US from Europe was caused by:
- The dollar devaluation.
- Unrest in Europe.
The NRA was declared unconstitutional in 1935.
Contributing to an effective supply shock in 1937 was a surge in labor actions inspired by the Supreme Court’s Wagner Act decision which encouraged a wave of aggressive labor actions.
- Particularly damaging was the sit-down strike at General Motors.
The recovery through the 30s was not accompanied by investment.
- There was no increase in the capital stock.
- The recovery was primarily a “consumption goods recovery.”: Leonard Ayres.
As evidence that New Deal policies restrained recovery, Selgin points to France.
- France was one of the few countries to take longer than the US to recover.
- And it was the only country to resort to “…policies closely resembling-indeed inspired by- the New Deal, including NRA-style codes.”
- Between 1936 and 1937 real wages in Paris rose significantly.
The Bank of France devalued the franc in 1935 by 25%
While the lack of gold had been considered a problem in the late 1920s and early 30s, by the mid-30s the problem was considered to be too much gold.
- Between 1933 and 1937, the US monetary gold stock tripled.
In addition to uncertainty in Europe causing gold to flood to the US, there was also a sharp increase in the production of gold, particularly in South Africa and Siberia.
- Yet, US authorities feared that the flood of gold would result in “more bank lending and higher prices.”
- In other words, they feared the very medicine that Keynes was prescribing.
That’s It:
- For Paulitical Economy® Post 363
- Until next time:
- Be free
- And do no harm.
Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy® should not be considered investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information. It is meant for general interest purposes only. Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.