A snapshot of what’s going on in the world’s economy. Financial Ructions and book reviews can be a bit more technical so feel free to skip them. See disclaimer at the end of this note.
Summary
- Run of the mill luxury continues to suffer.
- Burberry imploding.
- Watch sales are also falling.
- And a bit of history on Swatch.
- Used luxury watch prices have come back down to earth.
- Another example of consumers cutting back on discretionary purchases.
- This time Helen of Troy.
- PM: I was trying to come up with a pun for this one but troy as I might…
- Florida has the highest car insurance premiums.
- In Financial Ructions:
- Some feel that soaring federal debt in the US is not a concern as wealth for consumers is growing even faster.
- It’s not.
- The unsaving.
- Some feel that soaring federal debt in the US is not a concern as wealth for consumers is growing even faster.
News
Luxury Implosion
Burberry 1Q/2025 Results
- Comparable store sales: -21%
- By region:
- Americas: -23%
- Europe, Middle East, Africa: -16%
- Asia Pacific: -23%
- China: -21%
- South Asia Pacific: -38%
- South Korea: -26%
- Japan: +6%
- They expect their wholesale revenue (17% of total sales) to fall 30% this year.
- And are on course to lose money this quarter and so have eliminated their dividend.
PM: You can see in my notes below from January 2024 and July 2023 below, that their global sales have gone from strong growth in 2023 to strong deceleration this year. Although sales in the Americas have been falling for a while and accelerating downwards:
- Americas sales:
- 1Q/2024: -8%
- 3Q/2024: -15%
- 1Q/2025: -23%
Burberry is a luxury fashion company founded by Thomas Burberry in Basingstoke, England in 1856. It originally used to design clothing that would protect people from the British weather.
- In 1908 a guy wore Burberry weatherproof clothing called gabardine when flying 1,117 miles in a hot air balloon from England to Russia.
- A raincoat designed by Burberry became popular with soldiers during the trench warfare of the First World War and became known as a trench coat.
They recently announced a sales update for the last three months:
- Adjusted sales: -2%
Comparable store sales by region:
- Asia Pacific: +3%
- Europe, Middle East, India and Africa: -5%
- Americas: -15%
The company expects its sales for 2024 to drop by a high single digit rate.
Here’s my post from July of 2023 showing that the declines in the Americas are accelerating.
They recently announced their latest three-month sales:
- Comparable store sales were up 18%
- Mainland China: +46%
- Re-opening after Covid lockdowns
- Japan: +44%
- Europe, Middle East, Africa: +17%
- Americas: -8%
Watch Out
Swatch is a Swiss watch manufacturer.
- The name is a combination of Swiss and Watch.
- 1983: Founded by a merger of two failing Swiss watch companies.
- The industry had been in trouble since Japanese company Seiko came up with their quartz watches (see my comments below).
- ASUAG
- Founded in 1931.
- Watch movements and subsequently watch brands including:
- Hamilton
- Longines
- Watch movements and subsequently watch brands including:
- Founded in 1931.
- SSIH
- Founded in 1930:
- Brands include:
- Omega
- Tissot
- Brands include:
- Founded in 1930:
- ASUAG
- The industry had been in trouble since Japanese company Seiko came up with their quartz watches (see my comments below).
- 1986: Changed name to SMH
- 1983: Launched the Swatch brand to compete with Seiko.
- See article here on the smart marketing campaign for Swatch including hiring Andy Warhol protégé Keith Haring to create art for the watches.
- 1998: Changed name to Swatch
- 1992: Bought Blancpain:
- Founded 1735.
- 1999: Bought Breguet:
- Founded 1775.
2H/2024 Results:
- Adjusted sales: -10.7%
- Primarily due to significant declines in mainland China.
I made the following comment on the Swiss watch industry in Paulitical Economy™ Post #74 back in October 13, 2022:
- PM: Further to my comment yesterday on the founder of Hublot (pronounced who blow).
- He told us a great story about the Swiss watch industry. Up until the 1960s the Swiss watch industry sold itself on the accuracy of its mechanical watches and they used to have annual watch accuracy competitions as a sort of brand-building thing for the watch industry.
- But by the late 1960s Japanese company Seiko came up with the quartz watch that was far more accurate than anything the best Swiss watchmakers could produce and they were cleaning up in the award competitions.
- So they eventually stopped having the competitions only to be resumed many years later, but excluding Japanese watch companies.
- Anyway, as the whole accuracy thing was out the window, the Swiss watch industry needed to pivot to something else to market their products and they turned to history, provenance, craftsmanship and most important, luxury.
- Swiss watches were marketed as a way to show off our wealth at parties, in the office etc. As he said, people might not know you’re wealthy if they can’t see your large home and/or expensive car as you can’t bring them into the office.
- Personally, I love the mechanical aspect of watches and in particular clocks. I have around thirty mechanical clocks that need winding once a week; many of them very old, none of them expensive. When the clocks go back an hour in the fall it takes me most of the morning to get all of the clocks in order. Three cuckoo clocks, two grandfather clocks, mantle clocks, wall clocks etc. and most of them chime. On the hour it’s quite the gong-show.
Used Watches
The luxury used watch index has been declining steadily from its high in 2022:
- ChronoPulse Watch Index (14 luxury watch brands and 140 models):
- Dec 2019: 1,129
- Mar 2022: 1,832
- Jul 2024: 1,423
- Down 22% from the high.
- But still up 26% from pre-COVID.
- 5.3% per year.
- WatchCharts luxury watch index (10 luxury watch brands and 60 models)
- Jan 2021: 63,666
- Mar 2022: 104,121
- Jul 2024: 64,739
- Down 38% from the high.
From Paulitical Economy™ Post #83 Monday, October 2022:
Second-hand luxury watches have started selling at higher prices than their brand-new equivalent: often at multiples of the new price.
- Waiting lists to purchase can sometimes be as much as five years
- The price (approximate) of a Rolex Submariner ‘Hulk’:
- 2012: $5,000
- 2020: $15,000
- Peak (2021): $25,000
- Latest: $21,000
PM: Bunch of them here, with some priced at over $40,000.
- Millennials (Gen Y) are the most likely to buy a luxury second-hand watch with close to 50% saying it’s likely they would buy one in the next twelve months.
- This of course has attracted “superfake” models so buyer-beware.
- As mentioned, I love mechanical watches where you have to wind them up.
- My wife Cynne likes to say, “If it’s a Seiko, it’s a fake-o.”
- PM: if you are interested in buying or selling a luxury watch you might want to consider signing up with Chrono24 which is a global online marketplace for luxury watches and has been in operation since 2003.
Shoppers Pulling Back
Helen of Troy is a consumer products company with a whole mish mash of brands and products:
Brands include
- Hydro Flask
- Water bottles and tumblers
- Osprey
- Backpacks
- OXO
- Cookware and coffee makers
- Drybar
- Shampoo etc.
- Gold N’ Hot
- Curling/Straightening irons
- Revlon
- Hairdryers etc.
- Braun
- Thermometers etc.
- Honeywell
- Air purifiers
- Vicks
- Humidifiers etc.
- PUR
- Filtered water stuff.
A bit of history (Wiki):
- 1968: Founded as a wig store in El Paso, Texas.
- 1975: Expanded into hair appliances
- 1980: Licensing agreement with Vidal Sassoon
- Vidal Sassoon here in 1967
- Then made a number of acquisitions over the years.
1Q/2025 Results
- Adjusted sales: -12.3%
- Home and Outdoor: -8.6%
- Beauty and Wellness: -15.3%
- The company said that it is facing challenges and that “many of these challenges became more pronounced toward the end of the first quarter and some continue to evolve.”
- PM: In other words, things are getting worse.
- The stock price has fallen 75% since late 2021.
- But has still compounded at an annual rate of over 11% since 1984.
Car Insurance
According to nerdwallet, average car insurance premium by state:
- Highest:
- Florida: $3,067
- Louisiana: $3,037
- Texas: $2,511
- Lowest:
- Wyoming: $972
- Vermont: $1,085
- Idaho: $1,162
Note, that New Hampshire and Virginia don’t require that you purchase car insurance.
- In Virginia, if you don’t get insurance then you have to pay an annual fee of $500.
- In New Hampshire, if you don’t buy car insurance you must prove that you could cover a $50,000 bodily injury claim.
- In Florida, you need car insurance but you don’t need to pay for personal liability insurance.
- Note that if you are driving someone’s car in one of those states and you get into an accident then you won’t be covered i.e. your own insurance wouldn’t cover you. So if you get into an accident and someone sues you for $1 million you would be on the hook personally.
Financial Ructions
Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…
A Markets Insight piece in the FT by Pimco’s Peder Beck-Friis.
- He says that although the high levels of US debt “raises concerns” there is no reason to sound the alarm.
- And he believes that one of the reasons for this is that yes, debt has gone up, but net national wealth has gone up even more.
- PM: He doesn’t mention how the wealth has gone up but it’s primarily a result of stocks and housing.
- PM: I remember this argument being made just before the great financial crisis and it’s wrong.
- The truth is that debt has grown faster than real wealth and that’s why debt to GDP is rising.
- Federal debt held by the public as a percentage of GDP:
- 2014: 74%
- 2024: 97%
- Federal debt held by the public as a percentage of GDP:
- Much of the increase in peoples’ “wealth” is not real wealth and is simply a result of higher prices being paid for the same wealth.
- For instance, here is the growth over the last ten years of corporate profits and federal debt:
- Corporate profits (TradingEconomics): 51%
- Federal debt held by the public (FRED): 118%
- So, debt is increasing faster than wealth, but the price you have to pay for that wealth has gone up i.e. a rising PE ratio.
- And of course, when peoples’ homes increase in price there is no net wealth creation for society.
- Again, just forcing younger people to pay a higher price for the same actual “wealth.”
- And there is a big difference between the value of debt and the ephemeral wealth created through higher PE ratios and soaring house prices.
- The prices of stocks and houses can get cut in half fairly quickly, but the value of the debt wouldn’t budge.
- That’s why at one point during the GFC nearly a quarter of mortgage holders in the US were in a negative equity position i.e. their house was worth less than their mortgage.
- I remember stories during that time of how some people dealt with that.
- Let’s say their house was worth $300,000 but they had a mortgage of $400,000.
- They would first buy another similar home on the same street for $300,000 and then default on their original home.
- And as in most states there is no recourse when defaulting on your mortgage, they were able to swap a $400,000 mortgage for one of $300,000.
- The prices of stocks and houses can get cut in half fairly quickly, but the value of the debt wouldn’t budge.
- The truth is that debt has grown faster than real wealth and that’s why debt to GDP is rising.
Unsaving
US Savings Rate
- Average since 1957: 8.5%
- May 2024: 3.9%
- PM: Remember that these are averages so the very high savings rates of some off-set the negative savings rates of others.
- Related to this is that consumer loans are now over $1 trillion:
- Jul 2014: 612 billion
- Jul 2024: 1.056 trillion
- Up 72%
- Nominal GDP up 62%
Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy™ should not be considered as investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information. It is meant for general interest purposes only. Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.