Post 261

A snapshot of what’s going on in the world’s economy.  Financial Ructions and book reviews can be a bit more technical so feel free to skip them.  See disclaimer at the end of this note.  

Summary 

  • The Nordic countries score very well on honesty.
  • Cities in Ontario have three of the four highest percentages of immigrant populations in the world.
  • It’s not the cheeseburgers.
    • And self-righteous morons.
  • In Financial Ructions:
    • A look at how passive funds are driving stock markets higher.
    • Fund flows in the US:
      • Passive vs. Active.

News

Culture and Honesty

In a book called Social Justice Fallacies by Thomas Sowell, he cites an experiment to measure how honesty varies in different cultures.

  • The study involved leaving a dozen wallets with money in them at various points in a city and then seeing how many were returned.
    • Helsinki: 11 out of 12 returned.
    • Lisbon: 1 out of 12 returned.
      • And that was only because that one wallet was found by a couple visiting Lisbon from the Netherlands.
  • Another study had the following percentages of wallets returned:
    • Norway: 100%
    • US: 67%
    • China: 30%
    • Mexico: 21%
  • PM: What’s up with the Nordic countries?

Immigration

Cities with the highest proportion of foreign born populations (wiki)

  1. Brampton, Ontario: 59.1%
  2. Miami: 57.9%
  3. Mississauga, Ontario: 57%
  4. Toronto, Ontario: 51.9%
  5. Surry, BC: 50.8%
  6. Vancouver, BC: 48.8%
  7. Sydney, Australia: 45.4%
  8. Auckland, New Zealand: 41.9%
  9. Melbourne, Australia: 41.3%
  10. San Jose, US: 41.0%

As I have discussed many times in my posts, controlled immigration is a very good thing.

  • Out of control immigration to boost asset prices and rents and pay for the underfunded retirement of the older generation is not.

Here is my post from July 2023 and re-posted in May of this year:

Article on immigration by Claude Lavoie: He spent 30 years at the Department of Finance and the Bank of Canada.

  • A case can be made for immigration on purely humanitarian reasons.
  • But from an economic perspective, it’s not enough for immigration to grow the economy, but it should increase the size of the economy per person i.e. GDP per capita.
  • There are three main types of immigrants:
    • 25% are those chosen for their human capital
      • It takes less than five years for these people to do as well or better than someone born in Canada.
      • Their impact on the economy:
        • Short-term negative
        • Long-term positive
    • 60% are family members who accompany the first group.
      • They take 10-20 years to do as well as someone born here.
    • 15% are refugees.
      • Unfortunately, most will never reach the standard of living of the average Canadian.
  • Immigrants can help with short-term labour shortages, but ultimately create more shortages through their own increased demand for education, health care and housing.
    • Immigrants age too and often bring their parents and so immigration has little impact on the age of the population.
  • On the whole, immigration seems to have a slightly negative impact on Canadians’ standard of living in the short-term and slightly positive in the long-term.
  • All evidence suggests that the greatest beneficiaries of immigration are the immigrants themselves.
    • But immigration impoverishes the countries where they come from as those leaving are often the “best and brightest.”
  • Consequently, we must stop thinking about immigration as an economic solution and instead welcome them for humanitarian reasons and for the diversity they add to our society.
  • Article ‘here‘.

PM: I would add two things.

  • There is no net wealth creation for society in deliberately attempting to drive housing prices higher through zero interest rates, lax lending standards or high levels of immigration.  It is simply a transfer of wealth to homeowners, typically older people, and at the expense of the next generation and immigrants.  It results in frustration and resentment.
  • As mentioned in a previous post, politicians over-index in terms of real estate investment and in demonstrating their humanitarianism they drive the value of their asset prices and rental income higher.

Immigration and Self-Righteous Morons

The other day I was having lunch with a friend; we are both immigrants.

  • She was telling me that she was talking with a friend of hers and about the mess this government has gotten our country into through their ridiculous immigration policy.
  • To which her friend responded: “Wait a minute.  Aren’t you also an immigrant.”
    • This sort of person is from the land of the living woke.
    • It’s more important to them to “appear” righteous than acknowledge how the lives of so many people are being ruined by really bad policy; policy that benefits homeowners and landlords at the expense of younger people and those very immigrants.
      • Immigrants are not the issue.
      • The issue is policymakers who are creating class conflict in our country with really bad policy.
    • Of course I don’t know what motivates this kind of idiocy, but it could be:
      • She’s afraid of being labeled a racist by the woke mob.
      • She owns property and wants to see its value continue to soar.
      • She’s a landlord and wants her rental income to continue increasing.
      • She owns a business and likes the flood of immigrants driving down wages.
      • She owns a business and is being subsidised by the government for hiring “newcomers.”
      • See here for the myriad subsidies the government offers businesses for hiring immigrants.
      • Here’s one example:

Welcoming Newcomers Wage Subsidy Program

The Welcoming Newcomers Wage Subsidy Program provides employers in the electricity sector with a wage subsidy to hire newcomers to Canada in full-time roles. This federal program offers a wage subsidy of 50% up to $10,000. The purpose of the program is to help newcomers integrate into the Canadian workforce and relieve the labour demand shortages in the industry.

PM: Our government keeps telling us that there are labour shortages in this country.

  • If that’s the case, why is it we need to pay businesses to hire people?

PM: Calling people racist for pointing out really bad immigration policy is as stupid as blaming cheeseburgers for putting on weight.

  • I love cheeseburgers and think they are one of the great foods of this planet.
  • However, if I eat too many I put on weight.
  • But me pointing that out doesn’t mean I’m anti-cheeseburger.
  • The problem is my lack of discipline i.e. it’s not the cheeseburgers’ fault.
    • I can already see the headlines in the woke press:
      • Musson Compares Immigrants to Cheeseburgers.
  • The issue is not immigrants.
    • And to borrow from James Carville:
      • It’s bad policy, stupid.
    • And finally, note that no one was complaining about immigration until the numbers went through the roof and contributed significantly to Canada’s housing and rental crisis.

Financial Ructions

Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…

Thoughtful Money is a good podcast and it’s free.  You can listen on Apple podcast or watch on YouTube here. 

  • The latest episode featured Michael Green and he was talking about the impact that passive/index funds are having on stock markets i.e. driving them higher.
    • A lot of 401K (retirement plans) offered to employees invest in passive funds. 
  • They also inordinately benefit the larger stocks.
  • First, on driving markets higher.
    • He says that there is a multiplier impact when money enters the market however it is much greater for passive funds than for active managers.
    • Multiplier effect of $1 entering the market:
      • Active managers: $2
      • Passive funds: $17
    • Even if total flows were neutral, he says that they would still serve to drive stock markets higher.
      • Older generations hold more active managers.
      • Younger generations hold more passive.
      • So as boomers age and start selling down their portfolios, they are selling a 2x multiplier, but it’s being more than off-set by younger people buying a 17x multiplier.
      • Of course, boomers benefit from this as even though their selling the next generation is increasing their wealth by driving up their stock portfolios.
  • Second, on driving large stocks higher than smaller stocks he says it’s due to inelasticity with respect to the volume of shares traded by the big stocks.
    • He uses the example of Microsoft and Delta Airlines stocks.
    • Microsoft’s market cap is 112x larger than Delta Airlines so passive funds have to buy 112x more shares of Microsoft than Delta Airlines.
    • Yet the average daily liquidity for Microsoft is only around 2.1x that of Delta.
  • Here are the numbers assuming a two-stock market:
  • Market cap:
    • Microsoft: $3,272 billion
    • Delta: $29 billion.
      • MSFT: 113x bigger
      • Total market cap of the market: $3,301 billion
        • Microsoft: 99.1%
        • Delta: 0.9%
  • Average daily volume this year:
    • Microsoft: 20.5 million shares per day.
    • Delta: 9.8 million shares per day.
  • Assume a passive fund is putting $1 billion into the market and these were the only two stocks.
  • The money would be allocated as follows:
    • Microsoft: $991 million
    • Delta: $8.8 million.
  • Share prices:
    • Microsoft: $440.4
    • Delta: $44.9
  • Number of shares of each stock bought followed by % of daily volume:
    • Microsoft: 2.25 million shares (11%)
    • Delta: 195,662 (2%)
  • Michael Green believes that if the US goes into recession and unemployment rises then there will be less money going into 401K plans and withdrawals by older plan holders could exceed contributions by younger ones.
    • It’s possible that the multiplier effect of passive funds could then work in reverse.
    • PM: If that happened I wouldn’t be surprises if the Fed started buying passive funds to keep stock markets elevated.
      • A really bad thing for the economy via the distortion of the price discovery mechanism.
      • But very good for asset holders and in particular the top 1%.

Fund Flows

Related to the above note, according to the Morningstar via the FT, fund flows over the last two years in the US:

  • Passive: +$1.1 trillion
  • Active: -$1.4 trillion

The average asset-weighted annual expense ratio was 0.36%.

  • It has been declining for many years caused by:
    • More rapid growth of cheaper passive funds.
    • Active funds cannibalising their own business by offering cheaper ETFs.
  • Over the last two years, the cheapest 20% of passive funds took in 90% of all inflows.
  • In the first six months of this year:
    • S&P 500 Tracker Funds: +$69 billion.
    • All other US equity funds: -$44 billion.
    • Technology funds: +$17 billion.
  • Fund flows into the “new nine” spot Bitcoin ETFs:
    • 1Q/2024: $27 billion.
    • 2Q/2024: $6 billion.
  • Sustainable funds have seen at least twelve straight months of outflows.
  • The largest fund companies in the US:
    • Vanguard: $8.09 trillion
    • Fidelity: $2.851 trillion
    • iShares: $2.839 trillion
      • June inflows: $41 billion
    • American Funds: $2.283 trillion
      • June outflows: $7.3 billion
  • ETF assets:
    • Active: $669 billion
    • Passive: $8.5 trillion

Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy™ should not be considered as investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information.  It is meant for general interest purposes only.  Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.

Submit your email to get free notifications about new Paulitical Economy™ posts and updates: