Post 267

A snapshot of what’s going on in the world’s economy.  Financial Ructions and book reviews can be a bit more technical so feel free to skip them.  See disclaimer at the end of this note.

Summary

  • Deere has now had four straight quarters of negative sales growth and it is accelerating downwards.
    • The global economy is slowing.
  • Walgreens is closing up to a quarter of its stores and its share price is back to where it was in 1997.
    • A quick look at that year.
  • Clorox: a quick look back.
    • And sales are falling in the US
  • US retail sales continue to grow but are still negative when adjusted for inflation.
  • Despite declining housing starts in the US and many people “locked-in” to generationally low 30-year fixed rate mortgages,  housing inventory is starting to rise.
    • People can’t afford to buy them.
  • In Financial Ructions:
    • Canada’s debt ranking is much worse than the government says it is.
    • Mortgage rates have come off their highs.
      • But US home prices are still near peak levels and unaffordable for the median household income.

News

Oh Deere

Deere is a global leader in agricultural, forestry and construction equipment.

Quarterly sales growth for Deere:

 Production and AgricultureSmall Ag & TurfConstruction and ForestryTotal
4Q-2022+59%+26%+20%+37%
1Q-2023+55%+14%+26%+32%
2Q-2023+53%+16%+23%+30%
3Q-2023+12%+3%+14%+12%
4Q-2023-6%-13%+11%-1%
1Q-2024-7%-19%0%-4%
2Q-2024-16%-23%-7%-12%
3Q-2024-25%-18%-13%-17%

But their prices are still up.

Walgreens

Walgreens has over 8,600 stores in the US and is number two after CVS.

A look back ‘here’and ‘here’:

  • 1901: Founded in Chicago by Charles R. Walgreen Sr.

3Q/2024 Results:

  • Adjusted sales: +2.5%.
    • US comparable sales: +3.5%
      • Pharmacy: +5.7%
      • Retail: -2.3%
  • The CEO said that “We continue to face a difficult operating environment, including persistent pressures on the U.S. consumer…”
  • The WSJ reported that the company is planning on closing up a quarter (2,150) of its stores.
  • The pharmacy industry has struggled over the years due to:
    • Less revenue growth on prescription drugs
    • Reimbursement pressures
    • Competition from telehealth
    • Online pharmacies
  • The share price peaked in 2017 at around $86.
    • Since then it is down 87%
    • And back to where it was in 1997.
    • 1997 events:
      • Death of Lady Diana
      • The first Harry Potter book was published.
      • Hale-Bopp comet.
      • Woolworths (Woolies) closed its last stores
        • Not to be confused with the Australian supermarket chain.
      • Google.com registered as a domain name.
      • Beanie Babies
      • Top grossing movies:
        • Men in Black
        • The Lost World: Jurassic Park
        • Liar Liar
        • Air Force One
        • Star Wars: Episode IV – A New Hope
        • My Best Friend’s Wedding
        • Titanic (only released in December otherwise it would have been number one: it’s currently the fourth highest of all time)
      • Some of the top music artists that year were:
        • Jewel
        • Puff Daddy
        • Toni Braxton
        • Spice Girls
        • Usher
      • Top TV Shows
        • Seinfeld
        • E.R.
        • Veronica’s Closet
          • PM: I don’t even remember this one.
        • Friends
        • Monday Night Football.
          • PM: I remember back in the day ABC thought “Monday Night Football” was such a strong brand that when they showed a game on Thursday night they would call it ABC’s Monday Night Football, Special Thursday Night Addition.
            • What a joke.

Clorox

Clorox is based in Oakland California.

It has a mishmash of well-known brands such as:

  • Brita
  • Burt’s Bees (lip balm)
  • Clorox
  • Glad
  • Handi Wipes
  • Hidden Valley Ranch salad dressing
  • Kingsford (charcoal)
  • Liquid Plumr
    • PM: I never realised that’s how it’s spelt.
  • Neocell: Vitamins
  • Pine-Sol
  • S.O.S (steel wool pads: not the sanitary type)
  • Tilex
  • And many more.

Brief history

  • 1913: Founded as a bleach factory in 1913 on the east side of San Francisco Bay (Oakland?), California: The Electro-Alkaline Company.
  • 1928: Changed its name to Clorox:
  • The name comes from a blend of it’s too main ingredients:
    • Chlorine
    • Sodium Hydroxide
  • 1940s: If you worked at Clorox you could avoid going to war (military deferment).
    • Bleach was important for the war effort:
      • Disinfect wounds (ouch)
      • Neutralize enemy gases
      • Purify water

Clorox “bleach it away” ad here.

  • 1957: Procter & Gamble buys Clorox
  • 1969: Procter & Gamble sells Clorox after being ordered to by the Federal Trade Commission due to monopoly concerns.
  • 1969: Buys Liquid Plumr.
  • Share price performance since:
    • 1980: +13,748%
      • +11.9% per annum.
        • 9.2% for the S&P500
    • 2019: -5%
    • 2020 peak (disinfectant sales went through the roof): -39%
  • 1972: Buys Hidden Valley Ranch salad dressing mixes.
    • PM: Seems like an odd thing for a bleach company to buy but they still own it.
  • 1973: Buys Kingsford (charcoal)
    • PM: Again, kind of weird but they still own it.
  • 1990: Buys Pine-Sol
  • 1999: Merged with First Brands Corporation brining in brands such as:
    • Glad
    • Scoop-Away
    • Handi-Wipes

4Q/2024 Results

  • Adjusted sales: -3%
  • By division:
    • Health & Wellness (Clorox, Liquid Plumr, Neocell): 0%
    • Household (Glad bags, Kingsford, cat litter) : -10%
    • Lifestyle (Hidden Valley, Brita, Burt’s Bees): -2%
    • International: +5%

Retail

US Retail and Food Services Sales For July (Census Bureau)

Growth vs. the same month last year:

  • Jun: +2.0%
  • Jul: +2.4%
    • PM: A reminder that these numbers are not adjusted for inflation.
      • So as inflation is currently higher than retail sales the amount of stuff purchased year-over-year has fallen again.
        • The ole price up volume down thing continues to play-out.
  • Moving Up:
    • Nonstore retailers: +6.7%
    • Electronics and appliance stores: +5.2%
    • Food services and drinking places: +3.4%
  • Moving Down:
    • Sporting goods, music, books etc.: -6.8%
    • Furniture: -2.4%

The percentage change for the first seven months of the year vs. the first seven months of 2023:

  • Total retail sales: +2.9%
    • Note that the growth was +2.4% on the originally released number which was revised lower.
    • Nonstore retailers: +8.8%
    • Food services and drinking places: +5.3%
    • General merchandise: +2.9%
    • Clothing: +2.9%
    • Building materials and garden: -2.3%
    • Sporting goods, music, books etc.: -3.5%
    • Furniture: -6.2%

US Housing

Housing inventory in the US (FRED):

  • Feb 2020 (pre-COVID): 928,000
  • Feb 2022 (low): 347,000
  • Jul 2024: 884,000
    • Down 5% from pre-COVID.
    • Up 155% from the low.

New housing starts (FRED):

  • Jan 1996: 1.5 million
  • Jan 2006 (peak): 2.3 million
  • Apr 2009 (low): 0.5 million
  • Jan 2016: 1.1 million
  • Apr 2022: 1.8 million
  • Jul 2024: 1.2 million

PM: Note that the US population has grown considerably over this time period.

Monthly supply of new houses FRED

  • Feb 2020: 5.6 months
  • Jun 2024: 9.3 months
  • 50-year average: 6.1 months

Financial Ructions

Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…

Debt Canada

According to a new report from the Fraser Institute.

  • Canada’s debt ranking vs. other G7 countries is worse than the government leads you to believe.
    • They will tell you that Canada has the lowest debt to GDP figure of any G7 country.
      • PM: Note that this is nothing to crow about if all the other countries are a bunch of fiscal basket cases.
      • Similar to claiming that the US dollar is a strong currency because its exchange rate keeps improving vs. other currencies.
        • It’s not a strong currency, it’s just less weak than most others i.e. if a country has inflation it’s currency is getting weaker.
    • However, the Canadian government uses a “net” debt figure instead of  “gross” debt.
    • Gross debt is primarily bonds that have been issued and they account for 76% of Canada’s total gross debt.
      • The second largest part of gross debt is government employee pension plans.
    • Net debt subtracts from the gross debt any financial assets the government owns.
    • So, when calculating the country’s total government debt they will subtract from that the assets held within the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Quebec Pension Plan (QPP).
      • This is extremely misleading.
      • First, the assets within the CPP/QPP are not available to the government and are earmarked to fund the retirement of Canadians.
      • Second, if those assets are subtracted from the government’s total debt then an equivalent amount should be added back to the debt in terms of the now unfunded future liabilities within CPP/QPP.
      • The following is from Wikipedia:
        • The Department of Finance’s method to calculate net debt has been criticized for including the assets (but not the liabilities) of the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Quebec Pension Plan (QPP). Yakabuski and Clemens and Palacios argue that the Department of Finance methodology understates net debt, since CPP and QPP assets are set aside to pay for future public retirement plan benefits, so they are not available to also pay down government debt.[11][12]
    • Canada’s debt ranking among 32 countries IMF:
      • Net debt: 5th
        • 13.3% of GDP
      • Gross debt: 26th
        • 107.1% of GDP
      • Note that in the US that social security (and pension plans of many other countries) are invested entirely in their own government bonds.
        • So when social security assets grow they invest in US government bonds
    • But it doesn’t serve to reduce the “net” debt of the US because the new asset in social security is matched by a new liability in the form of a new treasury.
      • In Canada, when CPP/QPP assets grow they are not invested in government bonds so there is no corresponding liability and thus it serves to reduce the net debt figure for Canada.
      • In the US, some say that it makes sense to subtract from the US gross debt that debt that is held within social security as the government owes it to itself.
    • This net number is called Federal debt held by the public i.e. it excludes debt held by things like social security.
      • However, the money lent by social security to the government is not invested in a productive asset and is instead, for the most part, consumed i.e. the government doesn’t have money invested somewhere that it can use to pay off the debt held by social security.
    • It has to tax its citizens to pay off the debt it owes social security.
      • At least with CPP/QPP the assets are invested in the debt and equity of corporations in the private sector and thus those are real “producing” assets that are available to fund the retirement of Canadians.
      • With social security in the US there are no real assets available to fund the retirement of Americans and instead it’s funded by the government’s ability to tax future generations.

Housing Bubble

US 30-year fixed rate mortgage FRED:

  • Dec 2019: 3.7%
  • Jan 2021 (low): 2.7%
  • Oct 2023 (high): 7.8%
  • Aug 2024: 6.5%
    • PM: This has led to a resurgence in refinancings.
      • But not in home purchases as prices are still out of reach for most people.
  • Median house price as a multiple of median household income (FRED, FRED, and PM estimates of household income for 2023/2024)
    • 1984: 3.6x
    • 1990: 4.1x
    • 2000: 4.0x
    • 2006: 5.1x
      • Bernanke’s fallacious wealth effect doctrine.
    • 2015: 5.2x
    • 2022 (peak): 5.8x
    • 2024: 5.0x
      • Median house price is down 6.8% from the peak.
      • But still up 25% from pre-COVID.
  • But according longtermtrends, the multiple is much higher as they use the S&P/Case-Shiller Index for house prices.
    • 1984: 4.1x
    • 1990: 4.6x
    • 2000: 4.4x
    • 2006: 6.7x
      • Bernanke’s fallacious wealth effect doctrine.
    • 2015: 5.3x
    • 2022: 7.3x
    • 2024 (peak): 7.7x

Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy™ should not be considered as investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information.  It is meant for general interest purposes only.  Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.

Submit your email to get free notifications about new Paulitical Economy™ posts and updates: