A snapshot of what’s going on in the world’s economy. Financial Ructions and book reviews can be a bit more technical so feel free to skip them. See disclaimer at the end of this note.
Summary
- Caterpillar’s sales decline continues.
- And goes negative in North America for the first time in a while.
- Apple’s share price is growing considerably quicker than its business.
- Alphabet (Google), Amazon and Meta (Facebook):
- Juggernauts that continue to power ahead with very strong business growth.
- Marriott revenue per available room growth has returned to more normal levels.
- Budget category barely growing.
- US jobs numbers were all over the place depending on the survey.
- Year-over-year:
- Private industry and full-time jobs way down.
- Government and part-time jobs way up.
- Year-over-year:
- We then look at two different views from two different newspapers with respect to how well the economy is doing.
- In Financial Ructions:
- Reverse Repo is almost fully drained.
- We take a quick look at M0, M1 and M2
- M2 is rising again.
- The Fed continues to shrink its balance sheet.
- But it’s still 69% higher than pre-COVID.
News
Caterpillar
3Q/2024 Results
- Sales: -4.2% (mainly due to lower volume: prices were higher)
- Construction: -9 %
- -11% in North America
- Resource Industries: -10%
- -17% in North America
- Energy & Transportation: +5%
- Construction: -9 %
- Sales by region:
- North America: -4%
- Latin America: +5%
- Europe, Africa, Middle East: -6%
- Asia Pacific: -7%
- Sales in North America by quarter:
- 1Q/2023: +30%
- 2Q/2023: +32%
- 3Q/2023: +25%
- 4Q/2023: +11%
- 1Q/2024: +7%
- 2Q/2024: +1%
- 3Q/2024: -4%
Apple
Announced their full year results for 2024:
- Sales: +2%
- By region:
- Americas: +3%
- Europe: +7%
- Greater China: -8%
- Japan: +3%
- Rest of Asia: +4
- By category:
- iPhone: 0%
- Mac: +2%
- iPad: -6%
- Wearables, Home and Accessories: -7%
- Services: +13% (higher advertising)
- Total sales growth at Apple excluding Services:
- 2023: -5.7%
- 2024: -1.1%
- Over the last two years, Apples sales have fallen a total of 0.8% (down 6.7% excluding services)
- But the share price is up 65%
Alphabet (Google)
3Q/2024 Results:
- Adjusted sales: +16%
- Google advertising: +10.4%
- Google subscriptions, platforms, devices: +27.8%
- Google cloud: +35.0%
- YouTube ad and subscription sales over the last year were in excess of $50 billion.
Amazon
3Q/2024 Results
- Total sales: +11%
- Online stores: +7%
- Physical stores: +5%
- Third-party seller services: +10%
- Advertising services: +19%
- Subscription services: +11%
- Amazon Web Services: +19%
- They expect that by 2025, half of the US will be covered by their Amazon Pharmacy same-day delivery.
Meta
3Q/2024 Results:
- Sales: +19%
- Family daily active people were 3.29 billion: +5%
- Ad impression: +7%
- Price per ad: +11%
Marriott International
Marriott International owns a number of hotel brands including:
- Marriott
- Sheraton
- Westin
- Ritz-Carlton
- Le Meridien
- St. Regis
- Delta
- Courtyard
- Residence Inn
- Fairfield
They have:
- 9,100 properties
- 1.675 million rooms
- Luxury: 161,139
- Premium: 714,839
- Select: 757,940
- Midscale: 17,932
- Timeshare: 22,750
- 3,802 properties under development with nearly 585,000 rooms.
- Its origins were as an A&W franchise in Washington DC in 1927
- 1928: Founded by J. Willard Marriott and his wife Alice.
- Opened the first drive-through restaurant on the East Coast.
Adjusted revenue per available room (RevPAR) by quarter:
1Q/2023: +34.3%
2Q/2023: +13.5%
3Q/2024: +8.8%
4Q/2024: +7.2%
1Q/2024: +4.2%
2Q/2024: +4.9%
3Q/2024: +3.0%
- US/Canada: +2.1%
- Luxury: +2.0%
- Premium: +3.8%
- Select: +0.8%
- International: +5.4%
- Europe: +9.5%
- Asia Pacific: +9.2%
- Greater China: -7.9%
US October Jobs
Number of jobs created in September by survey:
- Establishment Survey: +12,000 (impacted by hurricanes)
- Household Survey: -368,000 (not impacted by hurricanes)
- ADP: +233,000 (?)
Establishment jobs by quarter:
- Jun: 118,000
- July: 144,000
- Aug: 78,000
- Sep: 223,000
- Oct: 12,000
- Average jobs created per month:
- 2023: 231,000
- 2024: 170,100
- 6-month average job creation is down five months in a row:
- May: 236,000
- Jun: 207,333
- Jul: 188,667
- Aug: 162,333
- Sep: 147,833
- Down 37% from May.
- Oct: 121,833
Household survey jobs:
- Month over month:
- Private industry: -102,000
- Government: : -103,000
- Year over year:
- Private industry: -461,000
- Government: +449,000
- Poor quality job growth.
- Annual job growth:
- Full-time: -1,006,000
- Part-time: +1,232,000
- Poor quality job growth
Unemployment rate:
- May: 4.0%
- Jun: 4.1%
- Jul: 4.3%
- Aug: 4.2%
- Sep: 4.1%
Multiple job holders: -354,000
- Outside of COVID, this is the biggest monthly drop since at least 2019.
Unemployment duration in weeks:
- Jul: 20.6
- Aug: 21.0
- Sep: 22.6
- Oct: 22.9
- Getting harder to find a job?
Not Getting It
Greg Ip of the WSJ thinks that the economy is in great shape.
- Because like most mainstream press, economists and policymakers, they determine whether or not an economy is in good shape based on how much money is being spent.
- They measure GDP which adds up all final spending in an economy and if it is rising, they simply claim how great the economy is.
- They rarely if ever look at what is responsible for the spending.
- Nor do they look at who is doing the spending.
- He mentions that US productivity growth has been strong.
- The formula for calculating productivity is GDP divided by total labor hours.
- So if the government borrows trillions of dollars and spends it that gooses the GDP number and makes it look like productivity is increasing.
- Unfortunately, so is the debt.
- In 2020 (COVID).
- Unfortunately, so is the debt.
- Debt soared: Up 20%
- And so did productivity growth: Around 6%
- While long-term productivity suffers because government is becoming a greater part of the economy.
- And by definition this means that more money is being consumed than invested.
- And this leads to lower productivity growth over time.
Getting It
Meanwhile, Rushir Sharma of the FT correctly points out that “US growth is a mirage for most Americans.”
- And that the growth is driven by the richest consumers:
- Rising wealth
- Discretionary spending
- Also, that the stock market is distorted by the success of a few very large companies: See above.
- And that the growth is “heavily dependent on spending and borrowing by the government…”
- He also discusses what we have pointed to in earlier posts:
- People falling behind on paying their credit card debt.
- The housing affordability crisis.
- Finally, he says that US government deficit spending is “artificially inflating America’s growth.”
- PM: Refreshing.
Financial Ructions
Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…
Reverse Repo (FRED)
- Dec 2022 (peak): $2.6 trillion
- Nov 2024: $155 billion
- Down: 94%
- PM: As a reminder, when Reverse Repo declines it injects liquidity into the system.
- Down: 94%
M0 (Monetary Base): FRED
- Currency in Circulation plus bank reserves held on account at the Fed.
Change in M0:
- Feb 2020 (pre-COVID): $3.5 trillion
- Dec 2021 (peak): $6.4 trillion
- Sep 2024: $5.6 trillion
- 60% higher than pre-COVID
- Note that this is the ultimate driver of all money expansion in the system.
- Banks cannot make loans unless they own reserves.
- Note that a bank can make a loan before it finds the reserves, but they better have those reserves by the time their client spends the money the bank lent them.
M1: FRED
- Currency in circulation held by the public.
- Demand deposits.
- This was the previous definition of M1.
- Then in May 2020 they changed the definition to include:
- Other checkable deposits
- Savings deposits
- Retail money market deposit accounts
Change in M1:
- Feb/2020: $4.0 trillion
- Apr/2022: $20.7 trillion
- The change above impacted the increase.
- Sep/2024: $18.2 trillion
M2: FRED
- M1
- Savings accounts
- Money market funds
- Time deposits
Change in M2:
- Feb/2020 (pre-COVID): $15.5 trillion
- Mar/2022 (peak): $21.7 trillion.
- Up 40% in 2 years; thus the highest inflation in 40 years.
- Note that M2 would have been unimpacted by the change in definition of M1 as the accounts added to M1 were previously only included in M2.
- Oct/2023 (recent trough): $20.7 trillion
- Sep/2024: $21.2 trillion
- Up 2.1% from last year.
Fed’s Balance Sheet
Average monthly increase in the Fed’s balance sheet:
- Mar 2020 to Apr 2022: $184 billion
Average monthly decrease in the Fed’s balance sheet:
- May 2022 to Oct 2024: $64 billion
Fed’s balance sheet:
- Nov 2007: (pre-GFC) $0.9 trillion
- Feb 2020 (pre-COVID): $4.2 trillion
- Apr 2022 (peak): $8.9 trillion
- Up 115%
- Oct 2021: $7.0 trillion
- Still up from pre-COVID: 69%
- 12.3% annual growth rate.
- Still up from pre-COVID: 69%
Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy™ should not be considered as investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information. It is meant for general interest purposes only. Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.