Post 328

A snapshot of what’s going on in the world’s economy.  Financial Ructions and book reviews can be a bit more technical so feel free to skip them.  See disclaimer at the end of this note.

Update

Hello everyone,

A friend and follower of Paulitical Economy, JM, got me in touch with Shaun Newman and I was privileged to be a guest on his podcast last week.  Shaun does a great job and has lots of hockey players on his show so you should follow him and subscribe: Shaun Newman.

Link to our conversation: Here

Topics we discussed:

  • How I got my start in Toronto
  • Why I loved my job so much
  • Why our economic system is morphing from one of mutual benefit to one where people benefit at the expense of others.
  • Why I wrote my book Capital Offence: Why Some Benefit at Your Expense.
  • Why I communicate the way I do.
  • Why movie theatres (and all businesses) need to constantly invest in their business and innovate.
  • How a fake wealth effect is destroying the lives of millions of people.
  • Why and when deflation is a very good thing for the economy and the consumer.
  • The paradox of the paradox of thrift.
  • Why lower interest rates don’t make housing more affordable.
  • Why policymakers will attempt to revert to financial repression and yield curve control.
    • And how that will transfer your hard-earned savings to someone else.
  • Why policymakers won’t make the right decisions for the long-term health of the economy until we demand that they do so.

Summary

  • McDonald’s turns things around.
    • But lower income consumers are suffering.
  • Caterpillar sales are still falling but not as much.
    • A turnaround?
  • But things not looking good at Gucci.
  • RH (luxury furniture) has really turned things around.
    • And some examples of their great corporate culture.
  • Molson Coors no longer seems to be benefiting from the boycott of Bud Light.
    • It’s share price is down 54% over the last ten years.
      • And a look back.
        • And Creemore!
  • We look at the changes in Canada’s property prices since 1970.
    • And when our housing affordability crisis started and who was responsible
  • In Financial Ructions:
    • Canada’s jobs numbers tumbled in July after growing strongly in June.
      • And how since 2015 the growth in government jobs has far outstripped that of the private sector.
        • Spoiler alert: This is really bad for the productive capacity of the economy.
  • Book Review: The Way the World Works by Jude Wanniski
    • Alexander the Great and Julius Caesar were two of the first to go down the Laffer curve.
      • As did Britain after the Napoleonic wars.
        • But then after WWII they went up the curve and stayed there for a long time resulting in economic stagnation.

News

McDonald’s

  • Comparable sales growth (adjusted):
    • 1Q/2023: 12.6%
    • 2Q/2023: 11.7%
    • 3Q/2023: 8.8%
    • 4Q/2023: 3.4%
    • 1Q/2024: 1.9%
    • 2Q/2024: -1.0%
    • 3Q/2024: -1.5%
    • 4Q2024: +0.4%
    • 1Q/2025: 0%
    • 2Q/2025: +3.8%
  • Comparable sales growth US:
    • 1Q/2023: 12.6%
    • 2Q/2023: 10.3%
    • 3Q/2023: 8.1%
    • 4Q/2023: 4.3%
    • 1Q/2024: 2.5%
    • 2Q/2024: -0.7%
    • 3Q/2024: +0.3%
    • 4Q/2024: -1.4%
    • 1Q/2025: -3.6%
    • 2Q.2025: +2.5%

The company said that they are making efforts to reengage the low income consumer as they go to McDonald’s more frequently than middle and high income consumers.

  • McDonald’s remains “cautious about the overall near term health of the U.S. Consumer.
    • Visits to QSR (quick serve restaurants) by low income consumers was down double-digit.
      • Higher income consumer visits to QSRs are rising.
  • Snack wraps are back on the menu after a nine year absence.
    • $2.99 in the US.
  • They’ve been taking lessons from their beverage-focused Cosmic and implementing them into the core McDonald’s business.
  • Once someone joins the McDonald’s loyalty program they visit the store on average 26 times per year.
    • PM: Only once every two weeks: I thought it would be higher.
      • Back in the 1980s I worked in a bakery that was right next to a McDonald’s and I went there most days (breakfast, lunch or both!)
    • A quarter of their US business comes from their loyalty program.
  • McCrispy Strips are selling well.

Over 40 years its share price has grown at an average annual rate of 11.7%.

Turning It Around?

Caterpillar, is the world’s largest construction equipment manufacturer.

  • Its history goes back over a hundred years.
  • The original steam-driven wheeled tractors were very heavy and used to get stuck in the mud.
  • In 1904, the company decided to replace the wheels of its steam-driven tractor with tracks.  On seeing it, a photographer said “If that don’t look like a monster caterpillar.”  Thus the company name.
    • Works pretty good for tanks too.

Sales in North America by quarter:

  • 1Q/2023: +30%
  • 2Q/2023: +32%
  • 3Q/2023: +25%
  • 4Q/2023: +11%
  • 1Q/2024: +7%
  • 2Q/2024: +1%
  • 3Q/2024: -4%
  • 4Q/2024: -5%
  • 1Q/2025: -10%
  • 2Q/2025: -2%
  • By sector:
    • Construction: -7%
      • North America Construction: -15%
      • Last quarter it was down 24%
    • Resource Industries: -4%
      • Last quarter down 10%
      • North America Resource Industries: -8%
    • Energy & Transportation: +7%
    • Oil and Gas: +2-%
    • Power Generation: +28%
      • Driven by data center applications.
  • Other Regions:
    • Latin America: -4%
    • Europe, Africa, Middle East: +6%
    • Asia: -2%

Kering

Kering is based in Paris and owns a number of luxury brands.

  • It owns 1,788 stores.
  • Gucci was founded in Florence, Italy in 1921 by Guccio Gucci.
  • Yves Saint Laurent started his fashion house in Paris in 1961 after working at Christian Dior since 1955.
  • Bottega Venata was founded in Italy in 1966.

More about Kering in Post 243

  • Gucci:
    • 2Q/23: +1%
    • 3Q/23: -7%
    • 4Q/23: -4%
    • 1Q/24: -18%
    • 2Q/24: -19%
    • 3Q/24: -25%
    • 4Q/24: -24%
    • 1Q/25: -25%
    • 2Q/25: -25%
      • Over the last two years Gucci sales are down 39%.
  • Saint Laurent:
    • 2Q/23: +7%
    • 3Q/23: -12%
    • 4Q/23: -5%
    • 1Q/24: -6%
    • 2Q/24: -9%
    • 3Q/24: -12%
    • 4Q/24: -8%
    • 1Q/25: -9%
    • 2Q/25: -10%
  • But their Bottega Veneta House has been doing well:
    • 1Q/24: +2%
    • 2Q/24: +4%
    • 3Q/24: +5%
    • 4Q/24: +12%
    • 1Q/25: +4%
    • 2Q/25: +1%

Sales growth at their other houses were down 14%:

  • Balenciaga
  • Alexander McQueen
  • Brioni
  • Boucheron
  • 46% over the last year.

Over the last five years its share price is down 56%

PM: Speaking of luxury, you knew it was only a matter of time before I linked to Monty Python’s Four Yorkshiremen skit: Here featuring  Rowan Atkinson.

The Trend Is Your Friend

RH, formerly known as Restoration Hardware, is a luxury furniture retailer based in Corte Madera, California (San Fran area).

–       1980: Founded by Stephen Gordon in Eureka, California.

o   PM: Maybe that’s where people go when they have a good idea.

–       2001: Current CEO Gary Friedman joins the business.

–       2010: The company announces that they will now sell more high-end stuff.

–       2022: Opened their first hotel.

Business Description

–       Sofas can cost well over $10,000.

–       The retail stores are called “Design Galleries.”

o   They are meant to be “architecturally impressive” and be a “multi-level expression of the RH brand.”

o   They have a “hospitality experience” in 14 of them which includes restaurants and wine bars.

o   They are opening RH Guest Houses offering “privacy and luxury in the $200 billion North American hotel industry.”

o   In addition, they are launching RH Residences: “fully furnished luxury homes, condominiums and apartments.”

o   They have two luxury private jets: RH1 and RH2

o   And one luxury yacht, RH3, that can be chartered.

They like to say that “For the past 23 years we’ve heard others tell us what can’t be done, and for the past 23 years we’ve failed…to listen.”

Sales growth by quarter:

–       1Q/2023: -22.8%

–       2Q/2023: -19.4%

–       3Q/2023: -13.6%

–       4Q/2023: -4.4%

–       1Q/2024: -1.7%

–       2Q/2024: +3.6%

–       3Q/2024: +8.1%

–       4Q/2024: +10.0%

–       1Q/2025: +12.0%

They still maintain that the US is experiencing the worst housing market in 50 years:

–       The percentage of houses sold per year relative to the population in the US:

o   1978: 1.8%

o   2024: 1.2%

§  Down 33%

They are shifting their sourcing from China:

–       1Q/2025: 16%

–       Expected by 4Q/2025: 2%

PM: As mentioned in previous posts I really like the corporate culture of RH and they say a lot of good stuff.  This is from their most recent results:

–       We’ve learned during our journey at RH that when we’ve done extraordinary and remarkable work, we’ve always figured out a way to monetize it, and we’ve also learned that it’s hard to monetize ordinary and unremarkable.

–       It’s a culture of leadership versus follow-ship, innovation versus duplication, enlightenment versus ego. It’s believing none of us are smarter than all of us, that we need all the brains in the game and the egos out of the room. It’s about thinking until it hurts, until we can see what others can’t see, so we can do what others can’t do.

Molson Coors

Molson Coors is a combination of three historic beer families:

–       Molson

–       Coors

–       Miller

A look back: Here

–       1786: John Molson founds his brewery in Montreal.

–       1855: German immigrant Frederick Miller leases a brewery in Milwaukee.

–       1873: Almost a hundred years after Molson, German immigrant Adolf Coors starts his brewery in Golden Creek, Colorado;

o   After discovering the “perfect water” at the foot of the Rocky Mountains.

–       1919: Prohibition starts in the US.

o   Coors and Miller survive by brewing

§  Soda

§  Near-beer

§  Malt syrups

–       1941: Half of all Coors beer is brewed for the military.

–       1959: Molson Canadian is first brewed.

o   And introduces aluminum cans

–       1978: Coors Light is launched: the Silver Bullet

–       1989: Molson merged with Carling O’Keffe

–       1995: Coors launches Blue Moon

–       2002: Coors buys UK brewer Bass Brewers

–       2005: Molson and Coors merge

o   Also that year, the combined company bought Creemore Springs Brewery.

§  PM: Note this is the favourite beer (amber lager) of me and my Dad.

§  Creemore story here

§  1987: Founded by John Wiggins in Creemore Ontario

·      The beer is brewed with spring water from Creemore.

·      The beer is unpasteurized.

o   This improves the flavour

o   But reduces the shelf life.

·      Their motto used to be “100 years behind the times.”

–       2008: Molson Coors and SABMiller form a joint venture

–       2009: Molson Coors buys Granville Island Brewery which was founded in Vancouver in 1984.

–       Ads from the 1970s:

o   Molson ad here

o   Coors ad here

o   Miller Light ad here

World’s largest beer companies in millions of hectolitres: Vinepair

1.    Anheuser-Busch InBev (Belgium): 495

2.    Heineken (Netherlands): 245

3.    China Res Snow Breweries (China): 109

4.    Carlsberg (Denmark): 101

5.    Molson/Coors (USA/Canada): 80

6.    Tsingtao Brewery: 75

7.    Asahi (Japan): 65

13. Diageo (Guinness): 23

14. Kirin (Japan): 23

15. San Miguel (Philippines): 18

27. Sapporo (Japan): 8

Molson Coors adjusted sales:

–       1Q/2024: +10.1%

–       2Q/2024: -0.1%

–       3Q/2024: -7.8%

–       4Q/2024: -1.9%

–       1Q/2025: -10.4%

–       2Q/2025: -2.6%

o   Volume: -7.0%

o   Price/Mix: +4.4%

The company cited:

–       They believe the softness in the beer industry to be cyclical.

o   In other words, it’s temporary and should start growing again.

§  PM: Hope springs eternal.

PM: Note that Molson Coors benefited from the boycott of Bud Light which started in 2Q/2023 (April):

–       Molson Coors volume in the Americas by quarter:

o   3Q/2022: -1.0%

o   4Q/2022: -10.5%

o   1Q/2023: -0.5%

o   2Q/2023: +5.0%

o   3Q/2023: +6.6%

Over the last 40 years it’s share price has grown at an average annual rate of 4%

–       But from when it peaked 10 years ago it’s down 54%.

Canada House Prices

It is well known that Canada has one of the worst housing affordability crises in the world with a whole generation being priced out of the housing market.

Here are Canada’s housing price indices in nominal (listed) and real terms (adjusted for inflation): FRED

Nominal:

–       4Q/2019: 181.4

–       1Q/2022 (Peak): 252.7

o   Up 39%

–       1Q/2025: 215.0

o   Down 15% from the peak

o   Up 19% from pre-COVID

Real:

–       4Q/2019: 154.8

–       1Q/2022 (Peak): 200.2

o   Up 29%

–       1Q/2025: 154.0

o   Down 23% from the peak

o   Flat from pre-COVID

–       PM: Of course, whether or not housing is as affordable (or unaffordable) as it was in 2019 in real terms depends on whether wages kept up with reported inflation.

But here’s the kicker.

–       Take a look at this index chart of real property prices in Canada:​

A graph with a line
AI-generated content may be incorrect.

​

–       Note that from 1970 to 2001 property prices barely budged in real terms i.e. prices would rise in line with peoples’ incomes and so housing was affordable: 6-8x after-tax income.

o   But then in 2001 the Bank of Canada followed the US Federal Reserve by driving interest rates far below their natural rate (discussed in my book) in order to create a wealth effect by driving housing prices higher.

§  But no capital is created when housing prices are driven higher by central banks or by any other means.

·      Capital is simply redistributed within society.

o   House prices are now 12x after-tax income:

§  70% higher than the 1970-2001 average.

–       Average annual real price appreciation:

o   1970 to 2001: 1.5%

o   2001 to 2025: 4.0%

§  House prices growing 4% faster than incomes each year for 24 years.

–       In order to get back to the 2001 affordability levels, real house prices need to fall by 61%.

–       And as I have said many times, this transcends politics and is instead about fallacious central bank doctrine as espoused by heads of the US Federal Reserve:

o   Alan Greenspan

o   Ben Bernanke

o   Janet Yellen

o   Jerome Powell

o   With other country’s central bankers only too happy to follow suit:

§  Europe: Mario Draghi

§  Japan: Haruhiko Kuroda

§  Canada:

·      David Dodge

·      Mark Carney

·      Steven Poloz

·      Tiff Macklem

–       For the time being things are slowly moving in the right direction.

o   But there’s a long way to go.

o   And while it is painful for first time buyers who purchased at the top, there should be government (taxpayer) programs to partially help those people if they have to sell their home at a significant loss.

§  And that help should come from taxpayers who made a significant unearned gain on their home.

§  This is not about demonising anyone as none of us who made a fortune on our home broke any laws.

·      But we did nothing to earn it and so it comes at someone else’s expense.

Financial Ructions

Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…

Canada Jobs: May

  • Feb: 1,100
  • Mar: -33,000
  • Apr: 7,400 (Adjusted: -9,600)
  • May: +8,800
  • Jun: +83,000
  • Jul: – 41,000
    • Full-time jobs were down 51,000

The employment rate remained at a lower level: the percentage of those 15 years and older in the workforce.

  • Feb 2020: 62.1%
  • Nov: 2024: 60.6%
  • Dec: 2024: 60.8%
  • Jan 2025: 61.1%
  • Feb 2025: 61.1%
  • Mar 2025: 60.9%
  • Apr 2025: 60.8%
  • May 2025: 60.8%
  • Jun: 2025: 60.9%
  • Jul: 2025: 60.7%

Unemployment rate:

  • Feb: 6.6%
  • Mar: 6.7%
  • Apr: 6.9%
  • May: 7.0%
  • Jun: 6.9%
  • Jul: 6.9%
    • Toronto: 9.0%

The percentage of unemployed workers who have been out of work 27 weeks or longer: 23.8%

  • Highest percentage since 1998.

Youth unemployment: 14.6%

  • Highest since 2010

Amongst racialized youth groups:

  • Arab: 26.4%
  • Black: 23.4%
  • Chinese: 20.5%
  • Filipino: 19.4%
  • South Asian: 17.1%

Wage growth:

  • Jan: +3.5%
  • Feb: +3.8%
  • Mar: +3.6%
  • Apr: +3.4%
  • May: +3.4%
  • Jun: +3.2%
  • Jul: +3.3%
    • $36.16

Federal public employees:

  • 2015: 257,034
  • 2025: 357,965
    • Up 39%
      • 3.4% per year

Growth in employees from 2015-2024:

  • Private sector: 17%
  • Public sector: 27%

PM: This is a big problem.  While there are of course many hardworking people in the public sector it should not be growing faster than the private sector.

  • It should be growing much slower due to technology and economies of scale.

Book Review: The Way the World Works: How Economies Fail – and Succeed

By: Jude Wanniski | Basic Books, Inc. 1978

Chapter 9: The Building of Empires

In this chapter JW talks about the economic benefits of breaking down barriers between countries.  Barriers such as:

  • Different currencies
  • Different languages
  • Different common laws
  • Tariffs

Alexander the great had been schooled by Aristotle.

  • PM: Aristotle was a great believer in private property rights over communal property.
  • JW says that Alexander conquered the world “not by enslaving it, but by snapping – one small piece at a time – the barriers to communication and commerce…”

Next, JW moves on to Julius Caesar who he calls Alexander’s successor: “In five years he laid the foundation for a system that would endure for 500 years in the West and for 1,500 years in the East.”

He quotes from Will Durant’s The Story of Civilization:

  • Caesar:
    • “…required a means test for eligibility to the state dole of grain.”
    • “…ended one of the richest sources of financial profiteering – the collection of provincial taxes through corporations and publicans.”
    • “He scaled down debts, enacted severe laws against excessive interest rates, and relieved extreme cases of insolvency by establishing the law of bankruptcy essentially as it stands today.”
    • “He restored the stability of the currency by basing it on gold…”

JW now moves on to Augustus and says that his empire-wide tax census was the most important act of his reign.

  • The spreading of the tax burden across the whole empire enabled tax rates to come down.
    • Rome was effectively going down the Laffer curve.
  • Prosperity exploded and only ended with the death of Aurelius and the reign of his son Commodus who reversed course and sent Rome up the Laffer curve with tax and spend policies.
    • PM: In Chapter 2 we saw that Edward Gibbon marks Commodus as the beginning of the end for the Roman Empire.

It wasn’t until the American (1776) and French (1789) revolutions that economies started once again moving down the Laffer curve.

  • We saw in Chapter 2 how Napoleon used the Revolution as an opportunity to:
    • Lower domestic tax rates
      • Peasants went from paying 80% of their income in taxes to keeping 70%
    • Link the currency to gold
    • Establish his Civil Code which:
      • Provided legal solutions to feudal regimes
      • Ended the virtual enslavement of the peasant to the land.
      • Napoleon said that is Civil Code trumped all his military victories in terms of importance/legacy.
    • Another great achievement of Napoleon was “…cleansing and improving administration and the judiciary…”

After the Napoleonic wars Britain was still suffering from the 17 taxes of William Pitt the younger who was Prime Minister from 1783-1801 and 1804 to 1806.

  • JW claims that the enormous prosperity Britain enjoyed in the 1800s was not about finally defeating Napoleon but about finally defeating Pitt’s taxes and moving down the Laffer curve.

JW says that the American Civil War had “…deep roots in the conflict over tariff policy between the industrial North and the agrarian South.”

  • The North preferred high tariffs to protect their industries from imported British manufactured goods.
  • The South preferred low tariffs as they exported a lot of cotton and tobacco to Britain.

By the late 1800s, Britain was now wealthy enough to provide:

  • Free primary education
  • Unemployment insurance

However, spending on social services “quadrupled between 1900 and 1914, and income tax rates glided upward to finance these costs.”

  • It seemed at the time that Britain had “…hit upon a comfortable compromise of the growth and distribution models.”

Prior to 1914, all Britons paid the same rates.

  • After 1914 tax rates became progressive.
  • JW says that this was the turning point for Britain.
    • The 1800s was a system of lowering tax rates that resulted in stronger economic growth and higher tax revenues.
    • The 1900s was a trend of tax increases leading to lower tax revenue which in turn brought about even higher tax rates.

During the 1930s the US was hurt much more than Britain was with global trade coming to a standstill:

  • Britain had the Imperial Preference where there was low or no tariffs between trading nations of the British Empire.

Income taxes started in the US in 1913 with the Sixteenth Amendment:

Top income tax rates in the US:

  • 1913: 7%
  • 1918: 77%
    • Fighting WWI
  • 1922: 56%
    • Warren G Harding
  • 1928: 25%
    • Calvin Coolidge
  • 1932: 63%
    • Herbert Hoover
  • 1936-39: 79%
    • Franklin Roosevelt
  • 1944-45: 94%
    • Fighting WWII
  • 1954-63: 91%
    • Eisenhower
      • Although tariffs did fall
  • 1964: 77%
    • JFK/Johnson
      • Lowered the tax rate and tariffs even further.
  • 1973: 70%
    • Nixon

JW says that despite unemployment disappearing during WWII one could hardly call this prosperity.

  • Although a number of economists such as Galbraith (PM: and many other economists to this day) claimed that the war spending ended the depression.
    • Yes, output boomed but much of it was for war materiel.
    • In real terms, incomes were “lower during the war than they were in the Depression.”
    • JW also notes that there was little for consumers to buy and there was severe rationing.

As the war was ending in 1945, Keynesian economists were predicting a surge in unemployment as soldiers returned home.

  • And that massive government spending would be required to keep the economy afloat.
    • It didn’t happen.

JW says that the economy boomed after the end of WWII not so much because of the pent-up demand and high savings:

  • By holding billions of government bonds that helped fund the war, Americans simply owed other Americans.
    • And Britain had an even greater amount of pent-up demand and their economy struggled after the war.
  • The reason the US economy thrived was that throughout the war the Roosevelt administration started to abandon its New Deal policies and instead had hired business leaders to lead the war production effort.
    • Truman continued this policy at war’s end.
  • JW says that the “Keynesians lost at every turn” after the war and that rather than increasing government spending, taxes were cut (more so on lower incomes).

Germany drastically cut tax rates during the late 1940s and 1950s which led to the German economic miracle.

And Japan took a similar path after the war leading to their own economic resurgence.

  • JW says that in ever year from 1950 to 1978 the government either reduced marginal tax rates directly or indirectly through loopholes.
    • Japan had cut rates “by roughly 11 percent annually” and after twenty-four years tax revenue was $63 billion.
      • Four times the country’s entire GNP twenty-four years earlier.

Both Germany and Japan contributed greatly to world economic growth, while Britain detracted from it.

  • JW was writing in 1978 and said that due to Keynesian influence Britain had refused to lower the high wartime income tax rates.
    • PM: And Britain went through a few decades of socialist inspired economic stagnation.
    • AI estimated annual growth in real GDP from 1945-1980:
      • Japan: 10%
      • West Germany: 5%
      • USA: 4%
      • Britain: 2.5%

That’s It:

  • For Paulitical Economy Post 328
  • Until next time:
    • Be free
    • And do no harm.

Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy™ should not be considered as investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information.  It is meant for general interest purposes only.  Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.

Submit your email to get free notifications about new Paulitical Economy™ posts and updates: