A snapshot of what’s going on in the world’s economy. Financial Ructions and book reviews can be a bit more technical so feel free to skip them. See disclaimer at the end of this note.
Welcome to Paulitical Economy where we strive to give our readers and listeners a clear view of what’s going on in the world. It’s a view that is often contrary to the sensationalist headlines in mainstream media as well as from fallacious economic and monetary doctrine that has served to make the world a more divided place. It’s simple and easy to understand language aimed at empowering the average person who is anything but average when it comes to intelligence and what to do with their own hard-earned capital.
Feel free to direct your friends and family to our website where they can sign up for notifications for our free newsletter.
Website link to free newsletter
Update:
I had the pleasure of being on the Startergirlz Podcast with Jennifer Loehding. I love Jennifer’s positive energy and we had a great conversation. We discussed:
- When trickle down does work.
- Why you learn when you write.
- The consequences of short-term first order effect thinking.
- How the best laid plans of central banks have priced millions of young people out of the housing market.
- Why understanding and knowledge can lead to greater empathy.
- How bad systems and environments can bring out the worst in very good people.
- Something that we are all experiencing today.
You can watch and listen to our conversation here.
Summary
- The Ford F-Series of pickup trucks have constantly been in the top six of cars sold going back to the 1960s.
- Pickup trucks now account for four of the top six.
- In the 2010s Japanese cars accounted for four of the top six.
- After experiencing two straight years of declining sales, Home Depot seems to be turning things around: slowly.
- Amazon continues its strong sales growth.
- Advertising and web services leading the way.
- And are now offering same-day delivery for groceries.
- Advertising and web services leading the way.
- Deere Corporation sales continue to fall.
- And its share price continues to soar.
- The cost of renting an apartment in Canada has gone through the roof over the last 15 years.
- And is significantly higher (adjusted for inflation) than it was in past decades.
- In Financial Ructions:
- Stock market values are very high.
- 10 and 20-year stock market returns have been very low or negative from these elevated levels.
- Reverse Repo is almost gone and will no longer be adding liquidity to the market.
- Foreigners’ purchases of Canadian federal bonds are down 85% this year.
- Probably getting increasingly nervous about rumours of even more debt-fueled government spending.
- And no, government spending does not grow the economy.
- Probably getting increasingly nervous about rumours of even more debt-fueled government spending.
- Japanese long-term bond yields continue to climb.
- In our book review of The Way the World Works we look at:
- How governments responded to higher inflation by raising taxes:
- Worst of both worlds for taxpayers.
- And how fallacious economic doctrine made things considerably worse in the 1970s.
- How governments responded to higher inflation by raising taxes:
- Stock market values are very high.
News
Top Selling Cars By Decade (GROK)
1960s: Muscle cars at the top
- Chevrolet Impala
- Top 5 muscle cars based on performance and cultural impact:
- Ford Mustang
- Ford F-Series pickup truck
- Volkswagen Beetle
- Ford Falcon
- Chevrolet C/K Series pickup truck
1970s: Exploding Cars
- Oldsmobile Cutlass
- Chevrolet Impala/Caprice
- Ford F-Series pickup truck
- Ford Pinto
- You may remember that there was controversy with this car as the gas tank was behind the rear axle.
- If the car was rear-ended it could cause an explosion.
- At least 27 people died in such collisions.
- Incredibly, Ford did a cost benefit analysis of recalling many of their vehicles that had defective fuel lines and decided not to recall them as the cost of fixing the cars would have been more than the cost of settlements from deaths and injuries.
- Pre-production crash tests showed that the car could ignite if rear-ended at speeds of as low as 20mph.
- The 1985 movie Top Secret included the Pinto in a scene:
- See first 20 seconds here
- If the car was rear-ended it could cause an explosion.
- You may remember that there was controversy with this car as the gas tank was behind the rear axle.
- Volkswagen Beetle
- Jeep Cherokee
1980s: Two Pickup Trucks in the Top 6
- Oldsmobile Cutlass Supreme
- Ford F-Series pickup truck
- Chevrolet Cavalier
- Ford Escort
- Jeep Cherokee
- Chevrolet C/K Series pickup truck
1990s: Japanese Cars Making Their Mark
- Toyota Camry
- Honda Accord
- Ford F-Series pickup truck
- Ford Explorer
- Ford Taurus
- Jeep Grand Cherokee
2000s: Japanese Cars and Pickup Trucks
- Ford F-Series pickup truck
- Toyota Camry
- Honda Accord
- Chevrolet Silverado pickup truck
- Toyota RAV4
- Ford Explorer
2010s: Ditto
- Ford F-Series pickup truck
- Chevrolet Silverado pickup truck
- Toyota Camry
- Toyota RAV4
- Honda CR-V
- Honda Civic
2025: Pickup Trucks Dominating
From the VisualCapitalist
- Ford F-Series pickup truck
- Chevrolet Silverado pickup truck
- Toyota RAV4
- Honda CR-V
- Dodge Ram pickup truck
- GMC Sierra pickup truck
Home Depot
Started in 1979 in Atlanta, Georgia.
- It has 2,353 stores:
- US
- Canada
- Mexico
- Puerto Rico
- US Virgin Islands
- Guam??
A look back in Post 266
Comparable sales by quarter:
- 3Q/2022: +4.3%
- 4Q/2022: -0.3%
- 1Q/2023: -4.5%
- 2Q/2023: -2.0%
- 3Q/2023: -3.1%
- 4Q/2023: -3.5%
- 1Q/2024: -2.8%
- 2Q/2024: -3.3%
- 3Q/2024: -1.3%
- 4Q/2024: +0.8%
- 1Q/2025: -0.3%
- 2Q/2025: +1.0% (+3.3% in July)
- Transactions: -0.4%
- Average ticket: +1.4%
- A result of:
- Customers buying more big ticket items
- $1,000 or more:
- +2.6%
- $1,000 or more:
- Inflation
- Customers buying more big ticket items
- A result of:
US comparable sales:
- 3Q/2022: +4.5%
- 4Q/2022: -0.3%
- 1Q/2023: -4.6%
- 2Q/2023: -2.0%
- 3Q/2023: -3.5%
- 4Q/2023: -4.0%
- 1Q/2024: -3.2%
- 2Q/2024: -3.6%
- 3Q/2024: -1.2%
- 4Q/2024: +1.3%
- 1Q/2025: +0.2%
- 2Q/2025: +1.4%
- Canada and Mexico were also positive.
Amazon
- Adjusted sales growth:
- 1Q/2024: +13%
- 2Q/2024: +11%
- 3Q/2024: +11%
- 4Q/2024: +11%
- 1Q/2025: +10%
- 2Q/2025: +12%
- Online stores: +10%
- Highest growth in over a year.
- Physical stores: +7%
- Also, the highest in over a year.
- Advertising sales: +22%
- Subscription services: +11%
- Amazon Prime
- Amazon Music
- Amazon Kids
- Amazon Pharmacy
- Ring Protection Plan
- PM: We have this and love it.
- And a number of others.
- Amazon Web Services (AWS): +17.5%
- AWS accounts for 18% of Amazon’s total sales.
- Signed new agreements with:
- Pepsi
- Nissan
- Airbnb
- Warner Bros.
- Introduced a new robot called Vulcan:
- The first robot to combine sight and touch.
- 90-second video here
- Amazon already has over 750,000 robots in use in its warehouses.
- The first robot to combine sight and touch.
- Online stores: +10%
- The company announced same day delivery for fresh groceries in 1,000 cities (2,300 by the end of the year).
- Free delivery for Prime members on orders of $25 or more
- Down from $100.
- According to the WSJ, Amazon has 197 million prime members in the US.
- Free delivery for Prime members on orders of $25 or more
- But Walmart still leads on same day delivery and has slightly better pricing.
- Amazon has around 3% of the US grocery market.
US Grocery Stores Market Share:
- Walmart: 24%
- Kroger: 10%
- Costco: 7%
- Albertsons: 5%
- Ahold Delhaize: 4%
- Publix: 3.5%
- Target: 3%
- H-E-B: 2.5%
- Aldi: 2.1%
- Amazon: 2.0% (different source from above)
Deere Corporation
Deere is a global leader in agricultural, forestry and construction equipment.
Quarterly sales growth for Deere:
| Production and Agriculture | Small Ag & Turf | Construction and Forestry | Total | |
| 4Q-2022 | +59% | +26% | +20% | +37% |
| 1Q-2023 | +55% | +14% | +26% | +32% |
| 2Q-2023 | +53% | +16% | +23% | +30% |
| 3Q-2023 | +12% | +3% | +14% | +12% |
| 4Q-2023 | -6% | -13% | +11% | -1% |
| 1Q-2024 | -7% | -19% | 0% | -4% |
| 2Q-2024 | -16% | -23% | -7% | -12% |
| 3Q-2024 | -25% | -18% | -13% | -17% |
| 4Q-2024 | -38% | -25% | -29% | -28% |
| 1Q-2025 | -37% | -28% | -38% | -30% |
| 2Q-2025 | -21% | -6% | -23% | -16% |
| 3Q-2025 | -16% | -1% | -5% | -9% |
Their outlook for the industries in which they operate this year in the US and Canada:
- Large agriculture: Down around 30%
- Construction: Down 10%
Note that its sales are still higher than they were for fiscal 2019 but its share price has far outpaced that:
Sales:
- 3Q/2019: $ 9.0 billion
- 3Q/2025: $ 12.0 billion
| Annual sales growth | Annual Share price growth | |
| 1984 to 2019 | 4.9% | 10.7% |
| 2019 to 2025 | 3.1% | 21.4% |
Despite continuing sales declines its share price is up 30% over the last year.
This is what central banks can do when they explode the money supply higher.
- US monetary base:
- May 2019: $3.2 trillion
- May 2025: $5.8 trillion
- Up 81%.
- But it does not create wealth in society on a net basis.
- It redistributes it.
- The actual wealth creation comes from Deere increasing its sales and profitability.
Renting in Canada
Year over year rents are falling in Canada with the following rents for a 1-bedroom apartment:
- Vancouver: $2,496 (down 9.6%)
- Toronto: $2,286 (down 6.4%)
- Mississauga: $2,120 (down 10.3%)
- Ottawa: $1,981 (down 1.7%)
- Montreal: $1,728 (down 1.6%)
- Calgary: $1,593 (down 9%)
- Winnipeg: $1,441 (down 0.1%)
- St. John’s: $1,023 (down 0.6%)
- Canada: $1,869
- Note that despite rents recently falling, they are still 18% higher than 2019.
- However, over the same period cumulative inflation was around 23%.
- So, in real terms, rents have fallen 4% since 2019.
- But this can vary significantly depending on the city.
- And presumes that wages rise in line with inflation.
- However, when I look at median pre-tax monthly income (Statcan: 25-54 year olds) compared to monthly rent it certainly doesn’t look like wages have kept pace with rents.
- Income to rent by year:
- 1990: 7.5x
- 2000: 6.3x
- 2010: 5.2x
- 2020: 4.1x
- 2023: 3.5x
- Income to rent by year:
- So, in real terms, rents have fallen 4% since 2019.
- And rent of $1,869 today is equivalent to the following inflation adjusted rents:
- 1970: $232
- 1980: $501
- 1990: $890
- 2000: $1,086
- 2010: $1,324
- But according to CMHC, actual rents were as follows:
- 1990: $462
- 2000: $582
- 2010: $756
- So, in inflation adjusted terms, today’s national average rent is significantly higher than it was in past decades.
- Since 1990: Up 93%
- Since 2000: Up 87%
- Since 2010: Up 75%
- With the vast majority of this real growth happened during the Bank of Canada’s ultra low-interest rate era of 2010-2020.
- Note that GROK says they are up 84%, 92% and 73% respectively.
- With the vast majority of this real growth coming in the Bank of Canada’s ultra low-interest rate era of 2010-2020.
- Causing this rent inflation are things like:
- Lower interest rates that drive asset prices which requires landlords/investors to charge tenants more.
- Rising government development fees and taxes that get passed on to tenants
- As asset prices rise, municipal governments charge higher and higher property taxes which get passed on to tenants.
- Exactly why is it more expensive to run the government because your house prices went up?
- Spoiler alert: It isn’t.
- Exactly why is it more expensive to run the government because your house prices went up?
- Outrageous and irresponsible levels of immigration which sent rental demand through the roof.
- Simple average annual rent increase in Canada by decade:
- 1990s: 1.9%
- 2000s: 2.6%
- 2010s: 2.9%
- 2020s: 6.0%
- Simple average annual rent increase in Canada by decade:
- Note that today’s interest rates are not responsible for high rents.
- Comparing all of the above with figures in 2000 with those post 2001:
- Government development fees and taxes soared significantly higher.
- Now 1/3 the cost of new development in some cities.
- Immigration soared
- Now stopped.
- Years of ultra low interest rates.
- In the year 2000 the yield on the Canada 5-year bond was over 5%.
- In 2015 it was 0.7%
- Today it’s 2.98%
- In the year 2000 the yield on the Canada 5-year bond was over 5%.
- That is, much lower than when rents were much more affordable back in 2000.
Financial Ructions
Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…
US Stock Market Valuation
Price to Sales: multpl.com
- Mar 2001: 1.5x
- Mar 2007: 1.5x
- Mar 2013: 1.4x
- Mar 2019: 2.1x
- Mar 2025: 2.8x
- Aug 2025: 3.2x
- PM: Returning to a normal price to sales ratio would require stock prices to fall 53%.
- Or stock prices to remain flat and sales grow 213%
- PM: Returning to a normal price to sales ratio would require stock prices to fall 53%.
Shiller Cyclically Adjusted Price Earning Ratio (CAPE)
- Average since the year 1900: 17.7x
- High: 44.2
- Low: 4.8
- Dec 1999: 44.2
- Over the next ten years the S&P500 fell 21%
- And over the next 20 years (1999-2019) it returned 4% per annum.
- Over the next ten years the S&P500 fell 21%
- Aug 2025: 37.9
Q is the ratio between a company’s stock market value and the replacement value of its net worth: Andrew Smithers
- It’s at an all-time high.
- Previous highs:
- 1920
- Subsequent 20-year return: -25%
- 1962
- Subsequent 20-year return: +4% per annum
- 1920
Reverse Repo
From March 2021 to May 2023 Reverse Repo drained reserves from the banking system and set a floor for interest rates.
- That is, the Fed flooded the market with so many reserves via Quantitative Easing to support reckless government spending (stimulus cheques) during COVID that it needed a mechanism to soak up the excess liquidity.
- And set a floor for interest rates.
- After the GFC, the Fed was able to soak up the excess reserves created through QE by paying interest on excess reserves (IOER).
- However, this time a different mechanism was needed because the QE indirectly funded stimulus cheques with the money not simply being held by the banks and instead ended up in higher yielding money market funds (MMFs)
- And MMFs are not allowed to hold reserves and so couldn’t lend to the Fed.
- But with Reverse Repo, MMFs are allowed to lend to the Fed.
- By keeping the Reverse Repo rate at a similar level to the government Treasury Bill rate, money market funds would park money in Reverse Repo which served to lower the amount of reserves available to banks.
- However, the reckless government spending over the last few years resulted in massive T-Bill issuance.
- The government switched from longer-term T-Bond issuance to shorter-term in order to keep the 10-year rate from rising.
- The Fed helped fund the T-Bill issuance by ensuring that the RRP rate was lower than the T-Bill rate.
- From 2020 to May of 2023 1-month T-Bills yielded pretty much the same as reverse repo.
- Starting in May of 2023 the yield advantage switched to 1-month T-Bills and money started flooding out of reverse repo.
- From 2020 to May of 2023 1-month T-Bills yielded pretty much the same as reverse repo.
- For the rest of 2023 an average of $203 billion per month was flooding out of reverse repo and into the market.
- The monthly average in 2024 was $53 billion.
- There is currently $35 billion left in reverse repo.
- Dec 2022 (Peak): $2.6 Trillion
- Aug 2025: $35 billion
- Down 99%
Foreign Investment Into Canada: Statcan
- Jan-Jun 2024: +$90.4 billion
- Jan-Jun 2025: -$22.6 billion
- The biggest decline was foreigners decreasing their purchases of federal government bonds:
- Jan-Jun 2024: $53.7 billion
- Jan-Jun 2025: $8.1 billion
- Down 85%
- In other words, foreigners are getting nervous about Canada’s ability to service our debt pile and particularly as even larger amounts of debt-fueled government spending seems to be on the way.
- And spoiler alert, government spending does not grow the economy.
- It grows GDP which is primarily a reflection of final spending/consumption.
- All it means is more capital is being consumed.
- Government doesn’t create any capital and can only access capital by taking it from the private sector via taxation, borrowing or printing money.
- So that government spending takes capital from the private sector that otherwise could have been invested to create more capital.
- It grows GDP which is primarily a reflection of final spending/consumption.
Japan Long-Term Bond Yields
30-Year Bond:
- 2019: 0.43%
- 2025: 3.22%
- Record high.
10-Year Bond:
- 2019: -0.025% (stupid)
- 2025: +1.62% (how stupid is it when you actually have to put a plus or minus sign in front of a bond yield).
- Last time it was this high was May 2008.
Note that the government expects to issue YEN31.2 trillion of 10-Year bonds this year (US$214 billion)
- 2015 yield: 0.35%
- Interest expense:
Book Review: The Way the World Works: How Economies Fail – and Succeed
By: Jude Wanniski | Basic Books, Inc. 1978
Chapter 10: The Breakdown of Bretton Woods: Part 2
With Bretton Woods, the US was the only country that could increase the money supply and thus it determined the world’s inflation rate.
- And the government continuously ignored the “…danger signal from gold…” (gold reserves being drained) as they inflated to increase employment.
- PM: A fallacious economic doctrine.
- As wages increased to off-set inflation it pushed workers into higher tax brackets and further up the Laffer Curve.
- The higher taxation pushed the country into recession which of course was the opposite of what policymakers intended.
- And it had the same effect in other countries due to the fixed exchange rate.
- Only Germany and Japan escaped as they lowered taxation.
- And it had the same effect in other countries due to the fixed exchange rate.
- And note that as higher wages were pushing people into higher tax brackets, they had less after-tax income in real terms which made housing less affordable.
- The higher taxation pushed the country into recession which of course was the opposite of what policymakers intended.
Britain was the first country to chip away at the Bretton Wood foundation when they devalued their currency in 1967.
- However, JW says that depreciating one’s currency does not make a country more competitive as the lower price of the currency is fully offset by higher domestic inflation.
- JW notes that devaluing the currency weakens “…the relationship between reward and effort.”
JW notes that President Nixon’s worst reform was “…a tightening of the tax treatment of capital gains…”
- Of course, Treasury had rosy estimate about how much extra tax revenue this would add to the coffers, but instead tax revenue fell.
President Nixon subscribed to a Keynesian derived policy called the “full-employment budget concept” as put forward by Herbert Stein and others in 1947..
- The idea is that the government should spend as much money as it would receive in taxes if the economy was at full employment.
- And that this deficit spending would then cause the economy to be fully employed.
- Nixon called it a “self-fulfilling prophecy.”
- PM: Kind of like our former prime minister saying back in 2014 that by growing the economy the budget would balance itself.
- How’s that working out?
- Only in an economy that grows through savings and investment, and lower government debt-fueled spending can the budget balance itself.
- Canada’s budget:
- 2014: $0.55 billion surplus
- 2018: $14 billion deficit
- 2024: $62 billion deficit
- An “adjunct” to Nixon’s plan was to have the Federal Reserve increase the “money supply at a rapid rate to accommodate the self-fulfilling prophecy of full employment.”
- And with Fed Chair Arthur Burns “accommodating” by increasing the money supply at an annual rate of 11% in early 1971, imports rose with US dollars used to purchase those imports coming back to the US and in many cases demanding gold rather than treasuries.
- And that this deficit spending would then cause the economy to be fully employed.
In closing the gold window on August 15th, 1971, and abandoning the fixed rate exchange system, both Keynesians and moneterists advised Nixon that “…the international monetary system could be run on wisdom alone.”
- PM: Joke.
Oil prices soared from 1966 to 1974 by 344%
- But this would not have been possible without the abandonment of Bretton Woods.
- It was the “…cutting of the monetary link to real goods, through gold, that led inevitably to the global rise in prices.”
The world slipped into recession in 1974/75 but Canada escaped it:
- JW claims it was a result of Canada indexing its progressive personal income tax system i.e. higher inflation did not take workers into higher tax brackets.
- However, JW notes that one province, Quebec, did not index their provincial taxes.
- And so, Quebecers were moving further up the Laffer curve as inflation raged.
- Prime Minister Trudeau then imposed a 10% surtax on all incomes above $30,000 ($158,000 today) which hurt Quebecors more.
- Finance Minister John Turner resigned as a result.
- Unemployment in Quebec soared to 10% and later that year a separatist party (Parti Quebecois) was voted into power.
From 1970 to 1976 inflation soared now that the golden handcuffs had been removed from central banks:
- Germany: 141%
- US: 147%
- UK: 215%
- 14% per annum!
In the 1970s, the top marginal tax rates in the UK were way up the Laffer curve:
- Earned income: 83%
- Unearned income (investment income etc.): 98%
In the early 1970s the US economy was contracting in real terms:
- From 1970 to 1975 real GNP fell 5.2%.
JW says that the Keynesian school argued that “counter-cyclical spending on welfare and unemployment benefits would automatically arrest an output decline by increasing aggregate demand.”
- But the experience was a decline in real wealth being produced as workers “…found it increasingly beneficial to be unemployed rather than employed.”
- PM: Welfare and unemployment benefits are very important and are only made affordable by a productive and unhampered private sector.
- But the trouble starts when policymakers look at benefits as a stimulus measure rather than benefits to help those who have fallen on hard times.
- George Selgin talks about this in his new book False Dawn which looks at the impact of Roosevelt’s New Deal.
- And how the New Deal (or Deals) was successful in terms of Reform and Relief, but in terms of Recovery the New Deal was a failure.
- George Selgin talks about this in his new book False Dawn which looks at the impact of Roosevelt’s New Deal.
- But the trouble starts when policymakers look at benefits as a stimulus measure rather than benefits to help those who have fallen on hard times.
- I’ll be reviewing this book soon.
- PM: Welfare and unemployment benefits are very important and are only made affordable by a productive and unhampered private sector.
- Government transfer payments as a percentage of wages and salaries:
- 1965: 6.9%
- 1974: 20.4%
That’s It:
- For Paulitical Economy Post 330
- Until next time:
- Be free
- And do no harm.
Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy™ should not be considered as investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information. It is meant for general interest purposes only. Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.