Post 332: Kraft Heinz Splits, Canada Drowns in Debt, Jobs Scarce — and Central Banks Sparked the Housing Crisis

Update

I was fortunate to do an interview with Dustin Sutton on his Tools, Talents and Techniques podcast.  We discussed a lot of things including:

  • Why it took me a long time to decide upon a career path.
  • My investment style being a reflection of my personality.
  • Why and when the monetary system started morphing into one in which people benefit at the expense of others rather than a system of mutual benefit.
  • Why and how wealth inequality has increased over the last 25 years.
  • Why fundamentals cannot matter for a long time.
  • The importance of managing expectations.
  • Why entrepreneurs tend to treat their employees well.
  • Why economics is a social science and how that is manipulated by some economists to justify their ideology.
  • Why you learn by writing or speaking.

You can watch or listen to the interview:

You should check out his show.

Summary

  • After seven straight quarters of sales declines, and fourteen quarters of declining volume, Kraft Heinz has announced that they will split up the company.
    • The merger of the two companies back in 2016 has been a disaster.
    • And we take a look back.
  • Canadians are falling behind on their debt payments.
  • Home prices in Canada have outpaced those in the US.
    • It’s primarily due to money supply growth and low interest rates.
    • And Canadian politicians benefited more from this than the average Canadian.
  • The Bank of England confirms that it was responsible for the UK’s housing affordability crisis.
  • Auto loans in the US are increasing in length.
    • This adds considerably to the amount of interest paid on the life of the loan.
      • And particularly for those with poor credit scores.
  • In Financial Ructions:
    • The US jobs situation is worsening in numbers and in quality.
      • Government and part-time jobs up.
      • Private industry and full-time jobs down.
    • The Canadian economy is bleeding jobs.
      • Unemployment is reaching levels not seen in 9 years.
    • The Canadian government is considering relaxing some bank capital requirements.
      • This is a bad idea.
  • Book Review
    • We start reviewing a new book and it’s our second look at supply side economics.
      • This one is called Taxes Have Consequences: An Income Tax History of the United States written by Arthur Laffer, Brian Domitrovic and Jeanne Cairns Sinquefield.
      • We start by reviewing the first two chapters and how very high tax rates lower reported income.

News

Kraft Heinz

Kraft Heinz owns nearly 200 brands including the following:

  • Oscar Mayer
  • Velveeta
  • Heinz
  • Kool-Aid
  • Jell-O
  • Philadelphia Cream Cheese
  • Maxwell House
  • Cool Whip
  • Miracle Whip
  • Shake N Bake
  • Stove Top
  • HP Sauce
  • Daddies (brown sauce)
  • A.1. (steak sauce)

A look back:

  • 1903: James Kraft starts his cheese delivery business in Chicago.
  • 1909: His four brothers join the business, and it’s incorporated as J.L. Kraft and Bros. Company.
  • 1915: They invented pasteurized processed cheese that didn’t need to be kept in the fridge.
    • They were a major supplier to the US army during WWI
  • 1924: Changed their name to Kraft Cheese Company.
  • 1928: Acquired Phenix Cheese Co.: maker of Philadelphia cream cheese.
  • 1930: Kraft was bought by National Dairy.
  • 1930s: National Dairy buys Sealtest.
  • 1940s: During World War 2, the company sent 4 million pounds of cheese per week to Britain.
  • 1950: Developed Kraft Singles
  • 1952: Develop Cheez Whiz
  • 1969: National Dairy changes its name to Kraftco.
  • 1976: Changed name to Kraft Inc.
  • 1980: Merged with Dart Industries:
    • Duracell
    • Tupperware
    • KitchenAid
      • PM: Those crazy days of the conglomerates.
  • 1988: Sold Duracell
    • Was bought by Gillette in 1996.
      • Gillette bought by Procter & Gamble in 2005.
  • 1988: Philip Morris (tobacco) buys Kraft.
    • Philip Morris already owned General Foods:
      • Oscar Mayer
      • Maxwell House
      • Jell-O
      • Kool-Aid
      • Post Cereals
      • Shake ‘n Bake
  • 1990: Philip Morris acquires Jacobs Suchard
    • We talked about this company in Post 287 last November:
      • Toblerone (PM: My favourite and a Christmas tradition for us).
        • 1908: Started in Switzerland by Theodor Tobler.
    • The name Toblerone came from the founder’s last name and Torrone which is Italian for nougat.
      • 1967: It was featured at Expo in Montreal.
      • 1970: Merged with Suchard to become Interfood
      • 1982: Acquired by Klaus Johann Jacobs to become Jacobs Suchard.
      • 1990: Jacobs Suchard acquired by Philip Morris:
  • 1993: Acquired the cereals business of RJR Nabisco:
    • Shreddies
    • Terry’s of York
  • 1994: Sold their frozen dinners business to Heinz.
  • 2007: Philip Morris spins-out Kraft.
  • 2009: Kraft buys Cadbury’s: Also, from Post 287 a bit on Cadbury.
    • 1824: Founded in Birmingham, England.
    • 1969: Merged with Schweppes.
    • 2003: Acquired Adams chewing gum business:
      • Halls
      • Dentyne
      • Trident
    • 2008: Company splits into two: Cadbury and Schweppes.
      • Merger was Schwepped aside.
    • 2010: Cadbury was bought by Kraft Foods Inc.
  • 2012: The company is split into two:
    • The snacks business became Mondelez.
    • The grocery business became Kraft Foods Group
      • In 2015 it became Kraft Heinz.
  • 2015: Kraft Foods Groups merges with Heinz to become Kraft Heinz
  • 2025: Kraft Heinz announce the company is splitting up its Kraft and Heinz business.
    • PM: Talk about coming full circle.
      • But pretty good for investment banking fees.

Adjusted sales by quarter:

  • 3Q/2023: +1.7%
  • 4Q/2023: -0.7%
  • 1Q/2024: -0.5%
  • 2Q/2024: -2.4%
  • 3Q/2024: -2.2%
  • 4Q/2024: -3.1%
  • 1Q/2025: -4.7%
  • 2Q/2025: -2.0%
    • Price: +0.7%
    • Volume: -2.7%
      • North America: -3.2%

Volume by quarter:

  • 4Q/2021: +0.1%
  • 1Q/2022: -2.2%
  • 2Q/2022: -2.3%
  • 3Q/2022: -3.8%
  • 4Q/2022: -4.8%
  • 1Q/2023: -5.3%
  • 2Q/2023: -7.0%
  • 3Q/2023: -5.4%
  • 4Q/2023: -4.4%
  • 1Q/2024: -3.2%
  • 2Q/2024: -3.4%
  • 3Q/2024: -3.4%
  • 4Q/2024: -4.2%
  • 1Q/2025: -5.6%
  • 2Q/2025: -2.7%

Back in 2015 Kraft and Heinze merged with the rationale that:

  • Substantial synergies for marketing and innovation would be unlocked.
  • Combining Kraft’s dominance in cheese and meats with Heinz’s sauces and condiments would create cross-category leadership.
  • It would “drive long-term sustainable growth.”
    • PM: It always sounds good on paper.

But after:

  • Billions of dollars of impairment charges
  • 14 straight quarters of shrinking volume.

The company has announced that they are splitting the company into two separate businesses:

  • Company A: Sauces, spreads and seasonings:
    • Heinz ketchup, Philadelphia cream cheese, Kraft Mac & Cheese.
  • Company B: Grocery staples:
    • Oscar Mayer, Kraft Singles and Lunchables

Warren Buffet was instrumental in bringing the two companies together saying “This is my kind of deal.”

Since the merger was announced in 2016, the share price is down 70%.

  • PM: No one gets them all right.

Canadian Debt Delinquencies

Mortgage debt delinquency rate in Toronto: CMHC

  • 1Q-2019: 0.10%
  • 1Q-2021: 0.10%
  • 1Q-2023: 0.08%
  • 1Q-2024: 0.14%
  • 1Q-2025: 0.23%

Non-mortgage debt in Canada: Equifax

  • Average: $22,147
    • Delinquency rate: 1.6%
      • Up 14% from last year.
    • Delinquency rate for 26-35 year olds: 2.39%
      • Up 20% from last year.

Non-mortgage delinquencies compared to mortgage delinquencies:

  • 2019: 45% higher
  • 2025: 96% higher

Canada Housing Crisis

According to an article in the Globe and Mail by Hanif Bayat:

  • Canada’s housing affordability crisis has been driven mainly be ultra low interest rates and a rapidly rising money supply:
    • Average growth rate of 7.3% since 2005:
      • This has been care of the Bank of Canada:
        • David Dodge
        • Mark Carney
        • Steven Poloz
        • Tiff Macklem
  • Compared to the US, Canadians have experienced:
    • More rapidly rising home prices.
    • Less rapidly growing wages.
  • But “restrictive zoning” and irresponsible population growth have also contributed to the problem.
    • And outrageous increases in government development fees and taxes.
  • And remember that those in government over-index in terms of real estate investment as per my Post 178 back in May of 2023

From @readpassage

  • Nearly 40% of Canadian members of parliament (MPs) are landlords or are invested in real estate.
  • This research was based on public disclosures that MPs are required to make available on the website of the Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner.
  • PM: I’m sure they’re all well intentioned, but by having so much skin in the real estate game one can’t help but be biased on whether one thinks driving interest rates down to zero and outsized immigration are good for the economy.
    • Spoiler alert, they’re not.
  • But both policies are very good for those who own assets (homeowners/landlords) in terms of house price appreciation and soaring rents.
  • Naturally determined interest rates and right-sized immigration are very good for the economy, but it would mean that housing prices would not rise, except in some circumstances.
    • And from these levels house prices and rents would both fall as determined by market forces rather than government/central bank policy.

And remember that our housing minister has a personal real estate portfolio of over $10 million.

  • How do you spell conflict of interest?

It’s About Interest Rates

In a study by the Bank of England back in 2019, they noted that:

  • Over the previous 40 years house prices almost quadrupled in the UK
  • And that the “substantial decline in the real risk-free interest rate” more than accounted for this.
    • In other words, the low-interest rate effect was so strong in terms of driving housing prices higher that it more than off-set some other factors that may have resulted in lower home prices.
  • Their models predict that a sustained increase in interest rates of 1% could lead to a 20% decline in house prices in the long-run.
    • Real interest rates in the UK:
      • 1980s: 4-7%
      • 1990s: 3% to 5%
      • 2000s: 2% to 4%
      • 2010s: -2% to 0%
      • 2025: 0%
    • So, a clear pattern of declining real interest rates sent housing prices soaring: It works in practice and theory.
    • And if a 1% increase in real rates would result in house prices falling 20%, a return to interest rate normalcy could result in a 60% price decline.
    • Here in Canada, home prices are 12x after-tax income vs. an average of around 7x before central banks started their fake wealth effect back in 2001:
      • A return to normalcy would result in a drop of 42%.

Car Loans

Interest rates (plus fees) on car loans in the US based on credit rating: Nerdwallet.

 New CarsUsed Cars
Prime6.8%9.4%
Nonprime10.0%14.0%
Subprime13.4%18.9%
Deep subprime16.0%21.6%

For the next three years up to $10,000 of interest expense on the loan for a new vehicle is tax deductible.

  • Must be assembled in the US.
  • Starts phasing out on income of $100,000.

According to Edmunds:

  • 7-year auto loans reached a new record:
    • Percentage of new car loans:
      • 1Q-2024: 15.8%
      • 1Q-2025: 19.8%
  • PM: Note that back in the 1960s/70s, car loans were typically 3-4 years.
    • More recently they were for 5 years.
    • To some extent, longer car loans can be justified by the fact that cars last longer than they used to:
      • 1960s: 6-8 years
        • My Dad had a 1970 Ford (Mercury) Meteor and within five years or so big chunks of rust were falling off the car: Images here.
      • 1980s: 10-12 years
      • 2020s: 12-15 years
  • Here is the difference in the amount of interest one pays over the life of a car loan for a new car priced at $50,000:
 5-Year Loan7-Year Loan
Prime$9,121$12,797
Nonprime$13,741$19,725
Subprime$18,875$27,323
Deep subprime$22,954$33,421

Financial Ructions

Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…

US Jobs

  • Establishment Survey: +22,000
  • Household Survey: +288,000
  • ADP: +54,000

June jobs were revised lower again for a loss of 13,000 jobs.

Job Quality:

  • Private industry jobs: -884,000
  • Government jobs: +811,000
  • Full-time jobs: -357,000
  • Part-time jobs: +597,000

Unemployment rate:

  • Aug 2024: 4.2%
  • Dec 2024: 4.1%
  • Aug 2025: 4.3%

Unemployment duration: Weeks

  • Aug 2024: 21.0
  • Dec 2024: 23.7
  • Aug 2025: 24.5
    • Longest since Apr 2022.

US Jobs Available

Job openings and labor turnover (JOLTs) in the US in the month of July:

  • 2019: 7.2 million
  • 2020: 6.7 million
  • 2021: 10.8 million
  • 2022: 11.4 million
  • 2023: 8.9 million
  • 2024: 7.5 million
  • 2025: 7.2 million

PM: Note that the US is back to where it was in 2019 in terms of the number of job openings.

  • Job openings as a percentage of those unemployed:
    • Jul 2019: 118%
    • Jul 2025: 100%
      • The number of job openings is actually slightly lower than the number of unemployed.
      • And the JOLTS numbers are suspected by many to be artificially inflated.
  • Indeed job postings index: Feb 2020 set at 100:
    • Feb 2020: 100
    • Jul 2020: 74
    • Jul 2021: 137
    • Jul 2022: 155
    • Jul 2023: 130
    • Jul 2024: 115
    • Jul 2025: 106

Canada Jobs: August

  • Feb: 1,100
  • Mar: -33,000
  • Apr: 7,400 (Adjusted: -9,600)
  • May: +8,800
  • Jun: +83,000
  • Jul: – 41,000
  • Aug: -66,000
    • Mainly due to a decrease in part-time workers.

The employment rate remained at a lower level: the percentage of those 15 years and older in the workforce.

  • Feb 2020: 62.1%
  • Nov 2024: 60.6%
  • Dec 2024: 60.8%
  • Jan 2025: 61.1%
  • Feb 2025: 61.1%
  • Mar 2025: 60.9%
  • Apr 2025: 60.8%
  • May 2025: 60.8%
  • Jun 2025: 60.9%
  • Jul 2025: 60.7%
  • Aug 2025: 60.5%

Unemployment rate:

  • Feb: 6.6%
  • Mar: 6.7%
  • Apr: 6.9%
  • May: 7.0%
  • Jun: 6.9%
  • Jul: 6.9%
  • Aug: 7.1%
    • Highest in 9 years.
    • If calculated the same way as in the US: 6.2%
      • Up from a low in 2022 of 3.7%

Unemployment rate when including those who have given up looking for work:

  • Dec 2024: 6.3%
  • Aug 2025: 8.2%
    • Highest since 2012.

Wage growth:

  • Jan: +3.5%
  • Feb: +3.8%
  • Mar: +3.6%
  • Apr: +3.4%
  • May: +3.4%
  • Jun: +3.2%
  • Jul: +3.3%
  • Aug: +3.2%
    • $36.31

Growth in employees from 2015-2024:

  • Private sector: 17%
  • Public sector: 27%

PM: This is a big problem.  While there are of course many hardworking people in the public sector it should not be growing faster than the private sector.

  • It should be growing much slower due to technology and economies of scale.

Thin End of the Wedge

The Globe and Mail reports that the government is considering relaxing bank capital requirements to encourage investment in areas of the government’s choosing.

  • PM: This is a bad idea.
  • Capital requirements should be based on risk and not on where governments feel banks should be lending.
    • As the article says towards the end: “…OSFI will be wary of undoing too many of the increased capital requirements that have helped shore up the banking system against unexpected shocks since the 2008 financial crisis.”
    • This response by the government is typical in that the longer we go without anything bad happening the more relaxed they become that nothing bad will ever happen.

Book Review: Taxes Have Consequences: An Income Tax History of the United States

By: Arthur Laffer, Brian Domitrovic and Jeanne Cairns Sinquefield | Post Hill Press 2022

Chapter 1: Whatever

Income taxes started in the US in 1913 with the Sixteenth Amendment to the Constitution.

The top marginal tax rate in the US has varied widely:

  • 1920s: 25%
  • 1940s: 94%
  • 1950s/60s: 91%
  • 1980s: 28%

Offsetting these high tax rates were numerous loopholes.

  • The current tax code is seventy thousand pages listing all types of exclusions and exemptions.
    • Many of these exclusions  are “…a record of the congressional lobbying activities of the rich.”
  • The result was that no matter if taxes were high or low, the top 1 percent paid roughly the same effective tax rate i.e. 20%.

Next they point out that high levels of taxation can push people into tax favoured investments i.e. not necessarily the areas that would result in the most wealth creation, but the most wealth retention for those investors.

  • This hurts job prospects for people and lowers economic growth.

They say that the Great Depression was not a result of “capitalism” or the gold standard but the outrageously high tax rates imposed first by Hoover and then Roosevelt.

  • PM: As we have seen in previous book reviews, it is a “…myth that World War II ended the Great Depression.”
    • When looking at the national standard of living, WW II deepened the Depression.
    • The Depression ended after WW II and for two main reasons:
      • Tax rate cuts
      • An “…epic decline in government spending.”
    • They note that the1950s was not nearly as prosperous as “memory serves.”
      • Between 1949 and 1960 there were four recessions.
      • The top income tax rate during this time was 91 or 92 percent
  • The boom of the 1960s was a result of John F. Kennedy’s tax cuts.

There is a misconception that higher taxes on the rich result in “more income” for everyone else.

  • However, they say that “There is no theoretical or factual basis to this belief.”
    • And this is because income at the top is the most variable of all income i.e. the people earning it do not desperately need it.
      • PM: I suppose one could say that income of the rich is elastic i.e. higher taxes results in them earning less.
        • And for lower income people income is inelastic i.e. even if taxed higher they have no choice but to continue working.
  • There are two things that happen when governments increase taxes on the rich:
    • They will work less and thus earn less.
    • They will spend more on tax accountants to shelter their income.
  • And that the economy is harmed when people do not “…put their capital assets, let alone their expertise, to vigorous use.”
    • The use of tax shelters reduces the amount of resources that are “…doing real economic work.”
    • In this way, “high tax rates have forced the economy into its periods of substandard performance.”
  • The authors list a number of legal methods of sheltering income such as:
    • “Retain income in closely held businesses as an unrealized capital gain, funding lifestyles with interest-deductible debt collateralized by the equity in the business.”

Hoover and Roosevelt both did the opposite of what they should have done when the Great Depression hit in that they sent the top tax rate soaring from the 25% rate that sent the 1920s roaring:

  • 1932 – Hoover: 63%
  • 1936 – Roosevelt: 79%
  • WW II – Roosevelt: 94%
    • During WW II private consumption per hour worked fell to the lowest levels “…not seen since the hardest of times in the previous century.”
      • PM: As we discussed in our previous book reviews, much of GDP during the war was for war materiel, which while necessary at the time, does not contribute to economic prosperity i.e.  all of that production is ultimately consumed in the war effort.

The presidency of Dwight Eisenhower. 1953 -1961 saw a continuation of high tax rates and was a period of:

  • Sluggish growth
  • Moderately high unemployment
  • Three recessions

PM: Note that the book has a lot of great charts showing top marginal tax rates over time as well as the percentage of tax revenue from the top and bottom 10% etc.

Chapter 2: Income Tax Avoidance: The Income of the Rich is Not What it Seems

The authors find that although high tax rates result in lower tax revenue coming from the rich, it’s not necessarily that the rich are earning less income  but instead are reporting less of it to government authorities.

  • They give an example of a corporation using profits to buy a yacht and write off all kinds of expenses.
    • This serves to reduce the reported level of income of the rich but does not reflect the true degree of income inequality.

They talk about the impact of the tax code that excluded municipal bond interest payments from income i.e. tax free.

  • It “…not only deprived the government of revenue” but also “…starved the private capital markets.”
    • And they believe that the “…state and local exemption played a major role in accelerating the Great Depression in the early 1930s.”

Tax rates went up during the Korean War to 91% but were kept there once hostilities ended.

  • The result was that tax avoidance became “democratized.”

o   It “became a national pastime and widely understood that getting one’s reported taxable income greatly down was normal and expected.”

They note that “In 1953, company airplanes outnumbered scheduled airliners by a factor of seven.”

Next, they re-tell an anecdote that was often told in Britain during the 1970s when the top tax rate went up to 98%.

  • A guy goes to a doctor and asks how much it would cost for an appendectomy.
    • The doctor says it would cost £50,000.
      • The reason it costs so much is because at 98% tax the doctor would only keep £1,000.
      • The guy then tells the doctor that to pay for the appendectomy, he would have to earn £2.5 million i.e. he would have £50,000 left after paying taxes at 98%.
      • After the discussion, they both agree that a fair price for the appendectomy would be a case of premium scotch.
      • With barter replacing income, it results in lower reported income but does not lower the standard of living of the rich.
        • Instead, it lowers tax revenue.
  • They say that during periods of very high taxation reported income goes down but the standard of living of the rich doesn’t.
    • And so it looks like high taxation results in less wealth disparity.
      • And instead the disparity is still there and less wealth is being created.

There is an enormous cost involved in complying with the tax system.

  • Arthur Laffer and John Child did a study in 2011 and found that the cost that year was $431 billion.
    • For every dollar collected in taxes, Americans pay another 30 cents to comply with the tax code.
      • PM: Good for accountants.
  • Cutting taxes would make it “insufficiently lucrative” to pursue tax shelters.

That’s It:

  • For Paulitical Economy Post 332
  • Until next time:
    • Be free
    • And do no harm.

Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy™ should not be considered as investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information.  It is meant for general interest purposes only.  Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.

Submit your email to get free notifications about new Paulitical Economy™ posts and updates: