Post 336: “Truckloads, Tax Loads, and the Working-Class Squeeze”

A snapshot of what’s going on in the world’s economy.  Financial Ructions and book reviews can be a bit more technical so feel free to skip them.  See disclaimer at the end of this note.

Update

Hello everyone.  The glorious fall weather continues up here in the Toronto region, but it’s not helping my golf game.

I was a guest on another podcast: Too Hard For the Radio.  Nick and I had a great chat:

  • The so-called ‘geniuses’ who mistake a bull market for stock-picking skill.
    • As the old saying goes, don’t confuse brains with a bull market.
  • Democratising economics
    • People are deliberately kept in the dark.
  • Blaming gravity for plane crashes.
  • We have the government that we deserve/demand.
    • But we don’t know what to demand.
  • All the capital that the government spends comes from the private sector and it obtains it in one of three ways.
  • Every politician should have tried to start a business at least once in their career. 
  • Entrepreneurs make the world go around.
  • Good deflation.
  • The importance of the natural rate of interest for a strong economy.
    • And how the neutral rate destroys productivity growth.
  • A mortgage is like a forced savings plan: it’s the only way you should be able to build up equity in your home.
  • Putting Band-Aids on bullet wounds.
  • Why inflation is higher than you think.

Summary

  • PACCAR is one of the leading truck manufacturers in the U.S.
    • A look back.
    • New truck deliveries are down 13.5% from pre-COVID
  • J.B. Hunt is one of America’s largest trucking companies and its sales growth has finally nudged into positive territory.
    • And no, supply chain bottlenecks did not cause the inflation of 2022.
  • UPS sales growth in the US returns to negative territory.
  • But Fedex’s sales accelerate.
  • Mortgages in Canada are renewing at much higher rates.
  • Inflation has a much greater impact on the working class.
    • And their real earnings are falling.
  • Car sales jumped temporarily as buyers rushed to beat the expiring EV tax credit. 
  • In Financial Ructions
    • Canada is heading for a budgetary crisis.
      • And total government debt to GDP is over 100%.
    • No, A.I. should not prevent corporate profitability from mean reverting.
  • In our book review of Taxes Have Consequences:
    • We see why the US economy soared after the war rather than collapse like many Keynesians predicted it would.
      • Spoiler alert: it was because of less government.
    • And the 1950s was all that it was cracked up to be.
      • High taxation had returned and individuals and corporations spent more of their energy avoiding taxes than growing the economy.

News

Keep On Trucking

PACCAR is a large manufacturer of trucks based in Bellevue (Seattle), Washington with the following brands:

  • Kenworth
  • Peterbilt
  • DAF (outside of North America)

A look back:

  • 1905: Started in Seattle making railway and logging equipment.
  • 1917: Through a merger it became the Pacific Car and Foundry Company from which the PACCAR name comes from: letters are all in caps for acronyms.
  • 1942: Starts making Sherman tanks for the U.S. Army.
  • 1945: Acquired Kenworth Motor Truck Corporation (founded 1923 in Seattle, Washington)
  • 1958: Bought Peterbilt Motors Company (founded 1939 in Oakland, California).
  • 1958: Bought Dart Trucking Company (mining vehicles).
  • 1972: Name changed to PACCAR.
  • 1981: Bought UK truck company Foden Trucks (founded 1856).
  • 1996: Bought Dutch truck maker DAF Trucks.
  • 1998: Bought UK company Leyland Trucks
    • Leyland history goes back to 1914.
      • Ran into financial difficulty in the disastrous UK economy of the 1970s.
      • It was nationalised by the UK government in 1975.

Quarterly truck sales growth:

  • 4Q/2023: +11.4%
  • 1Q/2024: +2.0%
  • 2Q/2024: -3.7%
  • 3Q/2024: -9.2%
  • 4Q/2024: -18.3%
  • 1Q/2025: -20.1%
  • 2Q/2025: -20.3%
  • New truck deliveries by region:
    • US: -19.9%
    • Europe: -7.8%%

New Truck deliveries in the US:

  • 4Q/2019: 26,600
  • 2Q/2022: 24,400
  • 1Q/2023: 26,000
  • 2Q/2023: 27,500
  • 3Q/2023: 27,500
  • 4Q/2023: 28,100
  • 1Q/2024: 29,500
  • 2Q/2024: 28,700
  • 3Q/2024: 25,900
  • 4Q/2024: 22,300
  • 1Q/2025: 22,200
  • 2Q/2025: 23,000
    • Down 22% from peak.
    • Down 13.5% from pre-COVID
  • Total trucks produced:
    • 2019: 198,800
    • 2023: 204,200
    • 2024: 185,300
      • Down 9.3% from 2023
      • And down 6.8% from pre-COVID

Freight Stable?

Largest trucking companies (by profit) in the US: Freightrun

  • UPS
  • Fedex
  • Old Dominion
  • J.B. Hunt
  • XPO Logistics
  • Knight-Swift

J.B. Hunt Transport Services Sales by quarter:

  • 2Q/2022:
    • Intermodal loads: +7.9%
    • Truck loads: +13.9%
  • 3Q/2022: +22%
  • 4Q/2022: +4%
  • 1Q/2023: -7%
  • 2Q/2023: -18%
  • 3Q/2023: -18%
  • 4Q/2023: -9%
  • 1Q/2024: -9%
  • 2Q/2024: -7%
  • 3Q/2024: -3%
  • 4Q/2024: -5%
  • 1Q/2025: -1%
  • 2Q/2025: +1%

PM: Note above that in 2Q/2022 when inflation was peaking in the US, supposedly due to supply chain issues, truck loads were going through the roof.

  • Up 40% from pre-COVID
  • In other words, people were buying record amounts of stuff with their stimulus cheques and that is what caused the inflation.

UPS And DOWNS

US sales growth:

  • 1Q/2025: -5.0%
    • Volume: -3.2%
  • 2Q/2024: -1.9%
    • Volume was up.
  • 3Q/2024: +5.8%
    • Volume: +6.5%
  • 4Q/2024: +2.2%
    • Volume declined
  • 1Q/2025: +1.4%
    • Volume declined
  • 2Q/2025: -0.8%
    • Volume declined.

Fedex

Sales by quarter:

  • 1Q/2025: -0.7%
  • 2Q/2025: +0.4%
  • 3Q/2025: +2.7%
  • 4Q/2025: +1.0%
  • 1Q/2026: +4.4%
    • US package volume +4.7%

Mortgage renewals

According to WOWA, mortgage renewals in Canada will accelerate over the next 18 months.

  • Excluding RBC (which does not disclose), $154 billion in mortgages will renew over the next six months across the other top six banks. 
  • According to Ratehub.ca the discounted 5-year fixed rate mortgage rate:
    • Sep 2020: 1.64%
    • Sep 2025: 4.04%
  • Monthly mortgage payment on a $1 million mortgage:
    • Sep 2020: $4,065
    • Sep 2025: $5,300

Inflation: Greater Impact on the Working-Class

The Ludwig Institute for Shared Economic Prosperity looks at the price rises of basic necessities or True Living Cost (TLC) vs. what the government tells you with respect to inflation (CPI).

  • Middle- and working-class Americans are more impacted by TLC.
  • In 2023 the prices of basic necessities rose at twice the rate of the consumer price index.
    • CPI: 4.1%
    • TLC: 9.4%
  • Earnings in 2023 rose 5.4%
    • So according to the government, real wages (wage increase less inflation) increased 1.3%.
    • But for lower income households, their real wages declined 3.7%.
  • Since 2001:
    • CPI: +72.1%
  • TLC: +97.4%

Stellantis Car Sales Falling

Stellantis is based in the Netherlands and owns 14 car brands including the following:

  • Chrysler
  • Dodge
  • Jeep
  • RAM
  • Alfa Romeo
  • Citroen
  • Fiat
  • Maserati
  • Opel
  • Peugeot
  • Vauxhall

Total car shipments by quarter (latest report was in July):

  • 1Q/2024: -10%
  • 2Q/2024: ?
  • 3Q/2024: -20%
  • 4Q/2024: -9%
  • 1Q/2025: -10.0%
  • 2Q/2025: -6.6%

North America car shipments by quarter:

  • 1Q/2024: -20%
  • 2Q/2024: -18%
  • 3Q/2024: -36%
  • 4Q/2024: -28%
  • 1Q/2025: -20%
  • 2Q/2025: -25%

Notes:

  • On average the prices of their vehicles fell 2%.
  • Market share by region:
    • North America: 7%
    • Europe: 17%
    • South America: 24%
  • The company’s estimate for tariff impact:
    • 1H/2025: €0.3 billion
    • 2H/2025: €1.2 billion
  • Its share price is down 31% this year.

Tesla

Tesla Deliveries:

  • Car deliveries by quarter:
  • 1Q/2023: 422,875
  • 2Q/2023: 466,140
  • 3Q/2023: 435,059
  • 4Q/2023: 484,507
  • 1Q/2024: 389,810
  • 2Q/2024: 443,956
  • 3Q/2024: 462,890
  • 4Q/2024: 495,570
  • 1Q/2025: 336,681
  • 2Q/2025: 384,122
  • 3Q/2025: 497,099
    • +12.0%
    • And the highest quarterly deliveries in the company’s history.
    • With the $7,500 electric vehicle tax credit expiring at the end of September a lot of sales may have been pulled forward.
      • If so, we could see a weaker 4Q.

Over the last year its share price is up 78.6%.

General Motors

3Q/2025 Sales:

  • +8%
    • Electric vehicle sales were up over 100% from last year.
    • PM: Also benefiting from the rush to beat the expiry of the electric vehicle tax credit.
      • But internal combustion engine cars doing well too.

US market share: 17.2%

  • Highest since 2015.

Percent change in vehicles delivered by brand:

  • Buick: -14%
  • Cadillac: +25%
  • Chevrolet: +8.3%
  • GMC: +8.6%
  • GM Total: +7.7%

Financial Ructions

Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…

Canadian Finances: Dire Reading

The Parliamentary Budget Office’s Economic and Fiscal Outlook: September

Overall, the report highlights the dangerous fiscal path the government is going down and how this will make Canada’s economic growth even worse than it has been over the last ten years.

Simple average annual Real GDP growth by decade:

  • 1960s: 5.7%
  • 1970s: 4.1%
  • 1980s: 2.9%
  • 1990s: 2.4%
    • This was a tale of two halves.
      • The first half of the 90s saw recession and exploding government spending: Real GDP growth was 1.2% per year.
      • The second half saw the government running fiscal surpluses: Real GDP growth was 3.5% per year.
        • Of course, not all else was equal as developed economies started to benefit from the Internet’s productivity boom.
  • 2000s: 2.1%
  • 2010s: 2.3%
  • 2020s: 1.7%
  • Last two years: 1.5%
    • On a per capita basis it has been negative.

Over the next five years, the PBO expects real growth to be in the range of 1.2-1.8%.

Estimated Federal government revenue for 2024/2025: $502 billion.

  • Breakdown of major components:
    • Personal income tax: 46%
    • Corporate income tax: 19%
    • Goods and Services Tax: 11%
    • Unemployment insurance premiums: 6%

Estimated Federal government expenditures for 2024/2025: $549

  • Breakdown of major components:
    • Cost of running the government: 25%
      • 14% of which is compensation.
      • Compensation accounts for 31% of personal income taxes collected.
    • Transfers to indigenous, grants, international aid: 20%
    • Elderly benefits: 15%
    • Public debt charges: 9.8%
    • Canada health transfer: 9.5%
    • Canada child benefit: 4.7% 
    • Employment insurance: 4.6% 

Bottom line is that the more the government spends the slower the economy grows.

  • The more the government spends the more capital that is consumed rather than invested and thus less stuff produced than there otherwise would have been.
  • It’s even worse if the government is spending way beyond the already obscene levels of taxation in this country.
    • Gross debt to GDP by country: IMF
      • Japan: 235%
      • Italy: 137%
      • USA: 123%
      • France: 116%
      • Canada: 113%
      • UK: 104%
      • Spain: 100%
      • Germany: 65%
      • Australia: 51%
      • Norway: 43%
      • Switzerland: 37%

Not Getting It 

I saw a clip on X this week with some guy saying that with A.I. helping to reduce costs for businesses, that profit margins should no longer mean revert.

  • If anything, in a properly functioning economy, A.I. should simply delay the mean reversion.
  • Profit margins mean reverting is not about a lack of technological improvements but about freedom of competition.
  • Companies invest in their business to become more efficient.
    • This improves profitability.
    • The higher profitability attracts more competition with prices coming down for consumers and profitability mean reverting.
    • Governments can prevent the competition from happening with things such as:
      • Local licensing laws (interprovincial trade barriers).
      • Bailouts/subsidies for local producers.
      • Government granted monopolies
      • Trade barriers

Book Review: Taxes Have Consequences: An Income Tax History of the United States

By: Arthur Laffer, Brian Domitrovic and Jeanne Cairns Sinquefield | 2022

Chapter 9: Government Retreat and the Emergence of Post-World War II Prosperity

The authors start this chapter by pointing out that the post WW II economic boom was a result of “three major policy initiatives” and each one “lessened the government’s role in the economy.”

  • Tax cuts
  • Deciding not to pursue a national full-employment program
  • A dramatic decline in government spending

Post WW II there was:

  • A decline in real GDP because of lower defense spending.
  • An increase in consumable real GDP.
  • Voluntary reductions in labour inputs.
  • An increase in leisure time “which had all but vanished during the war.”
  • Higher real wages.
  • Higher consumption.

Growth of real GDP excluding defense spending is the true measure of the national standard of living.

  • From 1945 to 1950 that measure grew at 8% per annum and it was accompanied by an increase in leisure time.

The Revenue Act of 1945 reduced the top income tax rate from 94% to 86.45%.

  • This resulted in the highest earners more than doubling their after-tax income.
  • The bottom tax rate fell from 23% to 19%.
  • The Act also repealed the corporate excess profits tax.
    • For the largest companies, if they made more than 5% on their capital that excess was taxed 95%.
    • PM: Although the authors don’t mention it, this tax was put in place in 1940 to prevent companies from benefiting excessively from defense spending: war profiteering.
      • As we have seen, in the early 1940s corporate America pivoted from producing consumer goods to producing war materiel and did so on a monumental scale.
        • Whether this would have been even greater without the tax is debated by some, but regardless, the amount of ships, tanks and guns produced by the US was mindboggling.  Monthly production in 1944:
          • Planes: 8,000
          • Tanks: 1,000
          • Ships: 200
  • The corporate income tax rate was cut from 40% to 38%.

As previously mentioned, the Keynesian mindset was that if the government cut defense spending after the war at the same time that millions of troops were returning home looking for work, that it would result in another Great Depression.

  • A government panel of economists (the future President’s Council of Economic Advisers: CEA) would assess how far below full employment (4%) the economy might be in 18 months’ time, triggering a new government jobs program.
  • However, as Congress was discussing this idea through 1945 and early 1946 the economy was booming without more government spending and so the idea withered away.
  • Not only that, but the boom became self-reinforcing as the private sector began to finally believe that no New Deal sort of policies were on the way.

Increases in non-defense output per man-hour:

  • 1945: +15%
  • 1946: +49%
  • But if one simply looked at GDP which includes defense spending, it fell through 1945 and 1946 by 11.6%.

The decline in government spending after the war was enormous.

  • Fell by nearly three quarters.
  • To 11% of GDP: “a low point that has not been seen since.”
    • 40% in 1944.
  • The government ran a budget surplus from 1946 to 1949.
    • The authors believe that this would not have happened if there had not been a “national exhaustion over the legacy of the New Deal.”

More US states were allowing income splitting and Congress passed a bill that provided for this for Federal income tax reasons.

  • It was twice vetoed by President Truman before being passed in 1948.

Taxes were again cut in the Revenue Act of 1948 to 82%.

  • These were the last tax cuts until Kennedy in the early 1960s.
    • Likewise, “the exceptional growth in the standard of living of the late 1940s would not see its like again until the next wave of tax cutting in the 1960s.”

Chapter 10: High Tax Rates and the Sluggish 1950s

The authors start by saying that the idea that the “1950s is the quintessential decade of American prosperity” is largely “myth.”

  • From 1949 to 1960 there were four recessions.
  • Unemployment was in the 5-7% range.
  • Under President Eisenhower from 1953-1961, GDP averaged 2.5% per year.
    • The 1950s had the highest average tax rate in the history of the United States.
      • Top rate of 92%.
    • The focus in the 1950s became one of avoiding high taxation rather than investing for growth.

The authors have a graph on page 262 that shows real GDP growth per capita vs. the long-term trend.

  • Two clear periods of growth are seen through the 1960s and 1990s.
  • And two clear periods of decline:
    • 1970s decline starts precisely when Nixon took the US off the gold standard in 1971.
    • 2000s/2010s/2020 decline starts in 2001 with the beginning of Greenspan’s/Bernanke’s wealth effect unconventional monetary policy.

The authors give an example of how high taxation was discouraging investment.

  • The top corporate tax rate in 1954 was 52%.
  • The tax rate on dividends was 91%
    • So, if a company earned $100 it would only have $48 net of tax.
    • And if it paid it all out in the form of dividends only $4.32 would be retained by the investor
    • So, of the $100 of profit, $95.68 would go to the government.

The high tax rates of the 1950s resulted in a deferred-compensation mania.

  • One method was to pay executives the same amount of money but stretch it out over a number of years including out into retirement.
    • In 1954, 85% of New York Stock Exchange companies offered deferred compensation benefits.
  • Corporations would contribute to executive pension plans and those contributions were tax deductible.
    • The benefits to the executives were in the future and they would also benefit from the capital gains tax exemption.
  • Stock options became very popular in the 1950s as a way of avoiding/deferring taxation.
    • And the authors note that if the stock price fell “the company’s board would reprice the options to make them in-the-money.”
    • PM: This happened a lot in the wake of the dot.com crash.
      • Which of course makes a mockery of supposedly aligning the interests of executives with shareholders.

The authors go into detail about how corporate expense accounts exploded during the 1950s:

  • Country clubs
  • Fine dining
  • Luxury offices.

It was a way of offering tax-free compensation to executives.

  • While at the same time allowing corporations to write-off those expenses.

And they note that the economics of the business became “a secondary concern.”

This all conspired to making it look as though “the level of average top income was so uncannily, so implausible, low in that decade.”

  • The “difference between the reported and real income of the top 1 percent gaped as never before or since.”

From 1949 to 1961, the US economy was in recession 29% of the time.

They note a principle of tax history is that three things happen with high taxation:

  • High earners earn less income.
  • High earners report less of what they earn.
  • The economy does poorly.

That’s It:

  • For Paulitical Economy Post 336
  • Until next time:
    • Be free
    • And do no harm.

Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy™ should not be considered as investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information.  It is meant for general interest purposes only.  Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.