Post 337: “More Beer, Less Bubbles: When Policymakers Toast Fake Growth”

Update

Happy Thanksgiving to all of our Canadian readers and listeners.  We always have a capon instead of a turkey.  They’re not easy to find but we much prefer them; easier to cook and tastier.  And also my homemade stuffing and gravy and potatoes from our garden.  And beer and wine! All the best. 

My latest interview was with Ephraim Herschmann on his Come Together podcast and we had a great discussion.  The audio quality on my end was not the greatest so turn the volume up a bit. 

  • When I first took on my attitude of be free and do no harm.
  • We all have our not finer moments.
  • Being honest, working hard and being dependable has great long-term benefits.
  • Being proactive with your career rather than hoping things will get better or something else will come along.
  • The natural state of an economy should be prices that are slowly falling.
  • Ephraim was shocked that the top marginal tax rate in the US in the 1950s was over 90%.
  • The paradox of the paradox of thrift.
  • Policymakers always believe in the popular way out that ultimately inflicts significant harm on society.
  • The laws of economics can be annoyingly inconvenient.
  • Ephraim rightly points out the hazards of companies focusing on quarterly results.
  • The central bank put results in rational behaviour by market players, but that all comes at great expense to the broader economy.

Summary 

  • Beer maker Constellation Brands’ sales and share price are going down faster than its beer. 
  • US office vacancy rate ticked down from last year. 
    • But is still over 25% in some Western cities. 
  • When you buy a home the government assumes you’re paying rent to yourself and they add it to GDP making the economy look much stronger than it really is.
    • Particularly if there’s a housing bubble. 
      • Another reason policymakers like to drive housing price higher.
  • Mercedes Benz sales have been falling for some time. 
    • And a look back. 
  • In Financial Ructions: 
    • We look at an apologist for central banks. 
      • Who believes that government debt to GDP over 100% is nothing to worry about.
        • PM: Spoiler alert: It is.
    • There may be a new prime minister in Japan and some are likening her to the next Margaret Thatcher: Uh, no.
      • And gargantuan levels of government debt have sapped economic growth over the last 35 years.
    • One of the original architects of rampant investment in the unproductive housing sector in Canada, now says we need more productive investment.
      • Better late than never I suppose.
    • A journalist claims that the stock market is one of the best economic indicators.
      • No, it’s an indicator of spending through the wealth effect.
      • It no longer says much about the underlying health of the economy.
    • A sociologist is right about the cracks in our economic system.
      • But wrong with respect to how they got there.
  • In our book review of Taxes Have Consequences:
    • President Kennedy distances himself away from the New Deal doctrine of the Depression era 1930s.
    • In 1932, local taxes were four times higher than federal taxes.
      • Not anymore.
    • Keynes cautions against high taxation.
    • From 1966 to 1974 the S&P 500 fell approximately 60% in real terms.

News 

Constellation Brands 

Constellation Brands is an American beer, wine and spirits company that got its start in 1945 in the Finger Lakes area of New York state.

Some of its more popular brands include:

  • Beer:
    • Modelo (US license)
    • Corona (US license)
  • Wines:
    • Simi
    • Meiomi 
    • Robert Mondavi
  • And many more

Announced their 1Q/2026 results: 

  • Adjusted sales by quarter:
    • 1Q/2024: +6%
    • 2Q/2024: +7%
    • 3Q/2024: +1%
    • 4Q/2024: +7%
    • 1Q/2025: +6%
    • 2Q/2025: +3%
    • 3Q/2025: -0.2%
    • 4Q/2025: +1%
    • 1Q/2026: -4%
    • 2Q/2026: -8%

Beer Sales:

  • 4Q/2025: 0%
  • 1Q/2026: -2%
  • 2Q/2026: -7%
    • Their beer Modelo Especial maintained its number one market share position in the US. 
  • The company said that it has a large Hispanic customer base and that they are being more impacted by the crackdown on immigration. 

Wine and Spirits adjusted sales:

  • 1Q/2025: -7%
  • 2Q/2025: -12%
  • 3Q/2025: -14%
  • 4Q/2025: +11%
    • They said that the growth was mainly driven by Canada.
      • Perhaps we Canadians patriotically ordered our US booze before the tariffs kicked-in. 
  • 1Q/2026: -21% 
    • Yup, looks like the previous quarter’s growth was due to Canadians front-running tariffs.
  • 2Q/2026: -19%
    • Sales were already falling but Canadians boycotting US wines and spirits may be contributing to the fall.

Over the last year its share price is down 43%.

US Offices

US national office vacancy rate: Commercialcafe.com

  • Aug 2024: 19.5%
  • Aug 2025: 18.7%
  • Some major cities:
    • Seattle: 27.2%
    • Austin: 26.5%
    • San Francisco: 25.9%
    • Denver: 23.5%
    • San Diego: 22.6%
    • Dallas: 22.4%
    • Portland: 21.3%
    • Boston: 16%
    • Miami: 14.3%
    • Manhattan: 13.6%

The percentage of US office buildings with a vacancy rate of 25% or higher:

  • 2015: 15%
  • 2025: 20%+

Office rent year over year is down 0.4%

Two thirds of US companies continue to offer flexible working hours.

Imputed Rents

A good article here by Better Dwelling

What are imputed rents?

  • If you buy a home you obviously don’t have to pay any rent.
  • But the government says that as your house is providing you with a service that it’s adding to the wealth of the economy.
    • And so, they estimate what rent you would have to pay to live in your home and they add that to GDP.
      • PM: You can’t make this stuff up.
  • As the article shows, imputed rents in Canada accounted for over 12% of the country’s real growth over the last year.
    • And is 8.5% of total real GDP.
      • As you might expect, this has increased significantly since central banks started driving house prices higher back in 2001.

So, think of it this way.  You have a choice of renting an apartment or building a home.

  • You decide you don’t want to pay rent and so you spend the upfront cost of buying your home i.e. the price of building your home is sort of like the net present value of all of your rental payments if you had decided to rent instead.
  • So, building your home adds to GDP because real capital was produced i.e. you built a home.
    • But the government says that by subsequently living in your home you’re contributing to GDP through the imputed rent i.e. the rent you would have to pay if you didn’t own your home.
      • But you do own your home: you decided to pay upfront precisely because you didn’t want to have to pay rent to anyone.
    • The home doesn’t change, you don’t pay any rent (no cash changes hands), yet the government assumes that society is that much better off regardless.
    • And if the government creates a housing bubble like it did since 2001, imputed rents go up with house prices, so GDP is higher than it otherwise would be.
      • But there is no capital created in any way by driving housing prices higher.
        • People are just paying more for the same economic good.
    • It’s the same amount of houses and the same amount of people not paying rent to themselves.
      • Imagine an island with three houses on it priced at $400,000.
      • The island government includes imputed rent in the island GDP.
      • Now the three residents agree to buy their homes from each other at a price of $500,000.
        • Imputed rents would rise and boost the island GDP.
        • Yet, absolutely no capital in any way shape or form was created or added to the island economy.

But it gets worse.  Some countries actually tax homeowners on the fake rental income that they’re supposedly paying themselves.

  • And yes, they’re all in Europe.
    • Next they’ll be taxing imputed rents for riding your bike.

Mercedes Benz: Sales growth would be a luxury.

But first a look back:

  • 1886: Karl Benz makes the world’s first car: a three-wheeler.
  • 1886: Gottlieb Daimler and Wilhelm Maybach develop the first four-wheeled car.
    • Many years later, Maybach later becomes the luxury line of cars for Mercedes.
      • 2026 SUV here: $180,000
  • 1894: Daimler wins the first auto race in history:
    • 126 km from Paris to Rouen (northwest of Paris).
      • Is that where the road to ruin came from?:)
  • 1900: A sales partner of Daimler pushed for a more powerful car.
    • Daimler named the car after the guy’s daughter; Mercedes.
  • 1910: A Benz car breaks the world speed record at Daytona Beach: 131.7 miles per hour.
  • WW I: Both companies shift to making aircraft engines.
  • 1923: At the peak of the great German hyperinflation, Daimler printed its own emergency money.
  • 1926: Benz and Daimler merge to form Mercedes Benz.
  • WW II: Switched to making trucks and aircraft engines.
    • They also made a number of luxury cars for Hitler, one of which is in the war museum in Ottawa. 
      • Article with photo here and how it ended up in Canada.
  • 1955: Race car driver Stirling Moss wins races driving a Mercedes 300 SLR.
    • Video here of a road version of one (only two left in existence): Sold for $142 million. 
  • 1955: Mercedes withdraws from racing after a 300 SLR crashed in the 24 Hours of Le Mans race. 
    • The car hit the back of another car and catapulted into the crowd killing 83 spectators.
      • The driver was also killed. 
    • They fully returned with factory-backed racing in 1987.
  • 1981: First carmaker to introduce airbags.
  • 1998: Merged with Chrysler
  • 1998: Buys US heavy truck-maker Freightliner.
  • 2007: Sells most of its stake in Chrysler.
  • 2009: Chrysler files for bankruptcy protection and was rescued by taxpayers.

Quarterly sales growth:

  • 2Q/2023: +5.1%
  • 3Q/2023: -1.9%
  • 4Q/2023: -3.9%
  • 1Q/2024: -4.4%
  • 2Q/2024: -3.9%
  • 3Q/2024: -6.7%
  • 4Q/2024: -2.4%
  • 1Q/2025: -7.4%
  • 2Q/2025: -9.8%
    • Unit (car) sales: -9%
      • Electric vehicles: +4%

Financial Ructions

Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…

In an opinion piece in the FT, Adam Tooze says that:

  • Although the UK debt continues to rise (PM: From already dangerously high levels) it is “far from critical levels…”
    • PM: As we saw in our last post, the UK government debt to GDP is already over 100%.
      • According to K. Rogoff and C. Reinhart in their book This Time is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly, once a country’s debt to GDP exceeds 90%, its real GDP growth is 1% lower than it would otherwise be.
        • Note that through 2023 and 2024 real GDP growth in the UK has averaged 0.8% per annum.
        • So, if Rogoff and Reinhart are correct, the “far from critical levels” of debt have more than cut economic growth in half in the UK.
      • PM: Seems critical to me.
  • Next, he says that “…a democracy dogged by fear of bond market vigilantes is unhealthy.”
    • His prescription?  As the UK is a “monetary sovereign” (PM: a favourite term of the something for nothing MMT crowd) the Bank of England needs to come to the rescue just like:
      • Bernanke did in the wake of the Great Financial Crisis.
        • PM: The crisis that he caused and then sacrificed the economy on the altar of higher asset prices.
      • Mario Draghi financially suppressing the continent.
        • PM: Financial repression is a really bad thing.  It extracts capital from peoples’ savings and transfers it to the government which encourages even more spending profligacy and an even weaker economy.
  • He says that the relationship between the government and the Bank of England was poisoned due to the high inflation of 2022 but “the shock came mainly from the supply side.”
    • PM: No, it was not a supply shock.  As I’ve discussed numerous times, inflation soared along with spending as record amounts of goods were going through the supply chains.
  • He goes on to say that investment-led growth should be the priority.
    • PM: Ya think?  But this won’t happen when investors have no faith in the reckless government spending and debt that continues to pile up.
  • Finally, he says that the “fear of a debt market crisis” is “paralysing the effort by democratic politicians to answer the fundamental questions facing the nation.”
    • PM: What a joke.  The fundamental question facing the nation is out of control government spending supported by his very central banks.
    • PM: The bond vigilantes are worried about his prescription of financial repression and of course demand higher interest rates as compensation.
    • PM: He also wants lower interest rates to help to better service the debt or take even more on.
      • Lower interest rates result in lower economic growth, but they do result in higher asset prices.

More Kicking the Can

Japan is the poster child for reckless government debt-fueled spending with debt to GDP of 235%.

  • Yet, investors are now excited at the prospect of the government spending even more beyond its means.
    • The Nikkei hit a record high.
    • Unfortunately, so did the Japanese government 30-year bond yield:
      • 2004 (previous high): 2.68%
      • Pre-COVID: 0.63%
      • Oct 2025: 3.30%
    • And the 10-year bond yield is the highest it’s been in 18 years:
      • Pre-COVID: -0.02% (yes, that’s a minus sign)
      • Oct 2025: 1.69%

Sanae Takaichi was elected as the new leader of the ruling Liberal Democratic party:

  • Some are calling her the new Margaret Thatcher.  PM: Hardly.
    • Takaichi is expected to increase government spending and pressure the Bank of Japan to lower interest rates.  I guess because that strategy has worked so well so far.
      • As per FRED
        • Central government debt to GDP:
          • 1990: 52%
          • 2022: 216%
        • Bank of Japan interest rate:
          • 1990: 6%
          • 2025: 0.5%
        • Japan Real GDP per Capita:
          • 1960-1990: +5.1% per year
          • 1990-2024: +0.8% per year
        • US: +3.5% per year.
        • And would have been even higher if not for the increased government involvement in the economy with higher debt and lower interest rates.
          • And real wages in Japan have fallen for eight straight months: The Japan News.

Canadian Economic Shambles

In an opinion piece in the Globe and Mail, David Dodge (former head of the Bank of Canada who followed the US Fed down the path of destructive negative real interest rates) and Don Drummond discuss the challenges facing Canadians.

  • Over the last four years, investment in machinery and equipment in Canada has fallen 12% in real terms.
  • Annual investment in machinery and equipment per worker:
    • US: $12,800
    • Canada: $4,100

They rightly say that investment in Canada needs to increase in order to improve labour productivity.

  • Which means lower private and public consumption.
  • PM: Note that private savings and investment in Canada is much lower than it would otherwise have been if Dodge hadn’t started the country down the negative real interest rates fake wealth effect housing boom path 24 years ago.
    • Canadians started saving and investing less than they otherwise would have done as they increasingly started to rely on the soaring equity levels in their homes which the next generation pays for.

Now I’ve Heard It All

In an analysis piece in the Globe and Mail, Reuters reporter Jamie McGeever says not to worry about the lack of economic data coming from the US government because of the shutdown.

  • That’s because we still “have access to one of the best economic indicators: the stock market.”
  • He points to the wealth effect of rising stock prices leading to higher consumption.
    • PM: Just like the wealth effect of rising stock prices and house prices resulted in higher consumption in the mid-2000s; just before the crash.
  • Like many mainstream pundits, he points out that US households have never been richer, particularly “the wealthiest households, who account for an outsized share of consumer spending.”
    • PM: K-shaped economic recovery.
  • US household wealth rose $7.1 trillion and rising stock markets accounted for $5.5 trillion of that or 77%.
  • He notes that job growth has ground to a halt.
  • And that the wealthiest 10% of the population accounts for 50% of consumer spending.
  • He does acknowledge that consumer confidence is near all-time lows.
  • And he concludes that all of this is good news for investors and for the “economy as a whole.”

PM: This is astonishing stuff.  One would have thought that mainstream market commentators would have learned a thing or two after Greenspan and Bernanke blew up the global financial system with their wealth effect policy in the early 2000s.

  • A rising stock market used to be a much better “economic” indicator when it was a closer reflection of the level of capital being invested and produced in the economy.
    • Today, it is a much greater reflection of central bank moral hazard policy i.e. the market knows the Fed will come to their rescue.
    • If stock markets are rising due to higher valuations/multiples that is not a sign of a stronger economy.
    • Yes, it will result in more spending, but spending is not the fount of economic prosperity.
      • If spending was responsible for economic growth the economy would be roaring right now.
    • He doesn’t mention the housing wealth effect that also boosts spending but only does so by transferring wealth from the next generation i.e. boomers get to spend and consume more capital than they created.

Uh, No

In a New York Times opinion piece, sociologist Andreas Reckwitz says that there are now doubts about liberal democracy being able to sustain itself.

  • PM: The issues are not liberal democracy: depending on your definition.
  • PM: He does rightly say that “As the experience of loss contradicts the modern promise of never-ending progress, a general sense of grievance prevails.”
    • However, he is wrong when he talks about the “naïve belief in progress.”
  • PM: And he rightly points out the dangers of a two-tier K-shaped economic recovery.
    • And that populism results from the broken political promise of endless improvement.
  • PM: To me, this again speaks to inductive reasoning i.e. looking at the world as it is and then trying to come up with a reason for it.
    • As I’ve said many times before, through deductive reasoning (theory) one could have easily predicted the predicament we are now in.
    • Yes, the distribution of wealth is unfair, it’s criminal that a whole generation is being priced out of the housing market and for a number of years countries such as Canada have dramatically underinvested in the productive capacity of the economy.
      • But these issues were all caused by policy and not market players with their own skin in the game.
      • It is a result of short-term fairy tale something for nothing thinking:
        • That driving stock market higher through valuation rather than the creation of more capital doesn’t have any consequences.
        • That driving house prices higher when houses are not a productive asset doesn’t have any consequences.
        • That governments spending far more than they collect in taxes and thus foisting the burden onto the next generation doesn’t have any consequences.
        • That believing that it’s consumption that results in economic prosperity rather than investment doesn’t have any consequences.
        • That continuously increasing the non-productive side of the economy i.e. government, at the expense of the productive side i.e. private industry, doesn’t have any consequences.
          • He is right about the failing health of society, but he has misdiagnosed the cause.

Book Review: “Taxes Have Consequences: An Income Tax History of the United States“

By: Arthur Laffer, Brian Domitrovic and Jeanne Cairns Sinquefield | 2022

Chapter 11: The Growth Takeoff of the 1960s

Although he was only president for a thousand days, John F. Kennedy set the U.S. in motion away from high taxation in three ways:

  • Reforms on the depreciation of capital equipment.
    • Since the Great Depression, depreciation schedules were unindexed to inflation and thus capital purchases were not able to be fully counted against income.
  • Major global tariff reductions.
    • Average reduction of 35%.
  • Personal and corporate tax rate reductions.
    • From 1951 tax rates were sky-high:
      • Corporate: 52%
      • Personal: Up to 91%
  • These helped to usher in “the big move in the long-term growth of the standard of living…”

Kennedy was against devaluing the dollar vs. gold (the Keynesian approach) and instead wanted the US dollar to be considered “as good as gold.”

  • This was counter to the advice that he was receiving from Paul Samuelson who recommended big government spending programs and thus maintenance of high tax rates.
    • And that if this meant a weaker dollar then so be it.
  • Kennedy also wanted to distance himself from the government New Deal policies of the Great Depression era.

On discussing the consequences of “restrictive tax rates” he said that “budget deficits are not caused by wild-eyed spenders but by slow economic growth and periodic recessions.”

  • PM: Of course, his definition of wild-eyed spenders would have been a fair bit different from what governments are doing today.

After February of 1961 the US economy was recession-free until December 1969.

The authors explain that the success of the tax cuts was not a result of some form of “Keynesian” demand-side economics as proffered by the president’s CEA and instead came from Treasury.

  • Tax cuts incentivized work and production rather than consumption and demand(emphasis mine).

The resulting shift of high income earners from attempting to shield their income to not shielding it “makes that high income more efficiently allocated within the marketplace.”

  • And tax revenue went up.
    • Income earners of over $500,000 increased their tax payments by over 80%.

GDP grew at 5% per annum from 1961 to 1969.

  • This was “among the greatest episodes of economic growth the United States has ever seen.”

Chapter 12: The States After World War II

The authors remind us that state and local taxes in 1932 were much higher than federal taxes i.e. 4x higher.

  • And they believe this played a major role in the Great Depression.

But once World War II started, federal taxes dwarfed state and local taxes and have done so ever since.

Today, there are still nine states that don’t have an income tax:

  • Alaska
  • Florida
  • Nevada
  • New Hampshire
  • South Dakota
  • Tennessee
  • Texas
  • Washington (but does tax capital gains)
  • Wyoming

They plot the 10-year population growth for states with and without income tax.

  • Going back to 1960, population growth in “no income tax” states has exceeded that of states that do tax in every single year.

Once states adopt income taxes it’s very difficult to go the other way:

  • “Like smoking, adopting an income tax is both highly addictive and toxic.”
  • PM: This is similar to monetary policy; the Fed has increasingly involved itself in the economy with its unconventional monetary policy and now we can’t get rid it.
    • Government bureaucracy grows after every financial crisis (which they cause) and never shrinks back to its pre-financial crisis state.
  • PM: Although encouragingly, Florida is in the process of debating on whether to significantly reduce or possibly eliminate property taxes.

When a state introduces a new income tax, tax revenue initially increases because it takes time for the economy to adjust to the new tax structure.

  • But over time:
    • People leave the state
    • High-income earners shelter their income.
    • Capital formation declines
    • Jobs vanish
  • All resulting in lower tax revenue.

Keynes had this to say about taxation:

  • Nor should the argument seem strange that taxation may be so high as to defeat its object, and that, given sufficient time to gather the fruits, a reduction of taxation will run a better chance than an increase of balancing the budget.
    • He likens government actions of raising taxes to cover budget deficits to a company that is losing money and foolishly raises its prices to off-set the losses.
      • Only to discover that sales fall even more leading to yet greater losses.
    • PM: But this common sense mindset is lost on most policymakers.

Around 55% of state and local government spending is on education:

  • Pre-K, K-12, colleges and universities.

Seven states have a monopoly on the sale of liquor:

  • Alabama
  • Idaho
  • New Hampshire
  • North Carolina
  • Pennsylvania
  • Utah
  • Virgina

Sin taxes are a significant source of revenue for these states.

  • And the authors note that these states have become addicted “to the very taxes they adopted to deter addiction.”

In the early 1970s property prices took off in California in part driven by lower interest rates that occurred right after Nixon took the US off the gold standard.

  • As home property taxes were not indexed for inflation they were growing faster than people’s income.
  • In 1978 California voters approved Proposition 13 to cut property taxes, which are essentially a wealth tax, from 2.7% to 1%.
    • And the California economy boomed for the rest of the century.

Chapter 13: Taxes and Stagflation

According to Keynesian doctrine, the stagflation of the 1970s (high inflation and high unemployment) was not supposed to be possible.

  • PM: empirically disproven in the 1970s after it had been theoretically disproven by Milton Friedman in the 1960s.
  • Inflation in the US at one point in 1980 was running at an annual rate of 20%.

The authors note another hazard of inflation and how the government gets its hands on more of your money.

  • If your investment portfolio is increasing simply due to inflation you’re not making money in real terms.
    • But when you sell your stocks you’re dinged with a capital gains tax and so you are worse off even though your portfolio increased in nominal terms in line with inflation.
  • In this way, inflation is a nonlegislated tax.

Government spending increased significantly from 1965 to 1969:

  • Social programs: +56%
  • Defense: +41%

Gold redemptions “surged under LBJ, averaging some $890 billion per year.”

The tax reform act of 1969, amongst other things, put restrictions on tax-deferred compensation.

  • While this was targeted at executives using loopholes to defer taxes it also made it more expensive for companies to hire workers.
  • The authors believe this tax reform played a key role in the slow economic growth and high unemployment of the 1970s.

Nixon closed the gold window on Aug 15, 1971.

  • In his address to the nation, he said it was a temporary measure.
    • But according to the authors, he was telling his aides that it would be permanent.
  • There had been runs on gold in the early 1930s and through the late 1960s.
    • Both runs were accompanied by significant increases in taxation.

PM: The S&P 500 peaked in 1966 and troughed in 1974.

  • Nominal return: -33.8%
  • Real return: -57.8% (others have it at -65%).

Typical of the attitude of some in government, President Carter’s tax commissioner said that people who are complaining about tax bracket creep should “take a lower paying job.”

That’s It:

  • For Paulitical Economy Post 337
  • Until next time:
    • Be free
    • And do no harm.

Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy™ should not be considered as investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information.  It is meant for general interest purposes only.  Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.