Update
Hello everyone. Another great fall weekend and a busy one for us. Our middle daughter graduated in Recreation Therapy (be taking care of us soon) and our youngest daughter ran the Toronto Waterfront Marathon: 3 hours and 15 minutes.
And thus, the podcast version will go live tomorrow.
No new interviews went live but I have a couple in the pipe and a few more upcoming.
Summary
- Cheap funding has been the main cause of housing affordability crises.
- After two quarters of negative sales growth, luxury group LVMH creeps into positive territory.
- And after only one quarter of negative sales growth, Domino’s soars into positive growth territory.
- Amazing what happens when you improve your customer value proposition.
- Pepsi’s volume has declined for thirteen straight quarters.
- And prices continue to rise.
- London’s black cabs are increasingly under threat.
- And a look back.
- Sales growth returns to Delta.
- But still the K-Shaped economy.
- In Financial Ructions:
- Yes, higher government spending results in lower economic growth.
- A look at France.
- And a look at Japan and how soaring debt to GDP ratios are inversely correlated with real wages.
- Despite quantitative tightening, the Fed has been increasing its holding of securities with maturities longer than ten years.
- Yes, higher government spending results in lower economic growth.
- We finish our book review of Taxes Have Consequences:
- Fed Chair Volcker’s restricting the money supply, combined with tax cuts set the stage for almost two decades of stellar economic growth
- The Keynesian multiplier theory ignores the negative multiplier impact on the private side.
- As well as ignoring the negative impacts of the substitution effect.
- The authors believe that the optimal tax rate on the Laffer curve is in the sub-20% range.
- Whatever it is, it’s a lot lower than the current tax rate here in Canada.
- Thus our disastrous record on investment and productivity.
- Thus our disastrous record on investment and productivity.
- Whatever it is, it’s a lot lower than the current tax rate here in Canada.
News
Housing Unaffordability: The Fed Did It
In a letter to the WSJ, Ed Pinto of the American Enterprise Institute says that:
- “The law of supply and demand dictates that easing credit during a period of short supply – a sellers market – gets capitalized into higher home prices.”
- He also quotes former Fed Chairman Mariner Eccles (1930s):
- “If expanded credit calls forth more production it will be desirable. If it only permits one borrower to bid against anot6her would-be buyer for scarce goods & thus adds to upward pressure on prices, it is dangerous.”
- He finishes the letter by pointing out that the Fed kept the 30-year mortgage rate far too low for far too long (by buying $1.6 trillion in mortgage-backed securities).
- And this resulted in “exploding home prices.”
LVMH
LVMH is a France-based luxury products group that has acquired a number of luxury brands over the years and employs 213,000 people globally.
- Brands include:
- Wine & Spirits:
- Moet & Chandon champagne
- Cheval Blanc (that wine in the movie Sideways)
- Chateau D’Yquem
- Dom Perignon
- Hennessy
- Glenmorangie
- Krug
- Veuve Clicquot
- Fashion & Leather:
- Christian Dior
- Fendi
- Givenchy
- Louis Vuitton
- Perfumes & Cosmetics
- Guerlain
- Watches & Jewelry:
- Bvlgari
- Hublot
- Tag Heuer
- Tiffany
- Wine & Spirits:
- A look back in Post 272
Adjusted sales:
- 1Q/2024: +3%
- 2Q/2024: +1%
- 3Q/2024: -3%
- 4Q/2024: +1%
- 1Q/2025: -3%
- 2Q/2025: -4%
- 3Q/2025: +1%
- By category:
- Wine & Spirits: +1%
- For the first nine months:
- Champagne/Wine: +3%
- Cognac/Spirits: -12%
- Fashion & Leather goods: -2%
- Perfumes and cosmetics: +2%
- Watches and jewelry: +2%
- Wine & Spirits: +1%
- By category:
o By region:
§ US: +3%
§ Japan: -13%
§ Asia: +2%
§ Europe: -2%
The share price is up 22% over the last 6 months.
– But still down 33% from its peak in 2023.
Dominos
Domino’s is based in Ann Arbor, Michigan and is the largest pizza chain in the world with 21,750 stores:
- US: 7,090
- International: 14,660
A look back in Post 316
Quarterly US Same Store Sales Growth:
- 1Q/24: +5.6%
- 2Q/24: +4.8%
- 3Q/24: +3.0%
- 4Q/24: +0.4%
- 1Q/25: -0.5%
- 2Q/25: +3.4%
- 3Q/25: +5.2%
- Boosting sales were:
- Their Best Deal Ever promotion:
- $9.99 for any size pizza and as many toppings as you want if you order on-line or via their app.
- Stuffed crust pizza
- Their Best Deal Ever promotion:
- Boosting sales were:
Pepsi
Pepsi got its start in 1893.
- Company history in Post 277
Pepsi brands include:
- Pepsi
- Mountain Dew
- Gatorade
- Bubly
- Tropicana
- Lay’s
- Doritos
- Ruffles
- Sun Chips
- Cracker Jack
- Cheetos (my favourite, but deadly)
- Quaker Oats
- Aquafina
- Aunt Jemima
- Cap’n Crunch
- Miss Vickie’s
- Rice-a-Roni
- Walkers (PM: Amazing chips out of the UK. My favourite flavour is cheese and onion).
Pepsi adjusted sales growth by quarter:
- 2Q/2024: +1.9%
- 3Q/2024: +1.0%
- 4Q/2024: +2.1%
- 1Q/2025: +1.2%
- 2Q/2025: +2.1%
- 3Q/2025: +1.3%
- Pepsi pricing growth by quarter:
- 4Q/2021: +7%
- 1Q/2022: +10%
- 2Q/2022: +12%
- 3Q/2022: +17%
- 4Q/2022: +16%
- 1Q/2023: +16%
- 2Q/2023: +15%
- 3Q/2023: +11%
- 4Q/2023: +9%
- 1Q/2024: +5%
- 2Q/2024: +5%
- 3Q/2024: +3%
- 4Q/2024: +3%
- 1Q/2025: +3%
- 2Q/2025: +4%
- 3Q/2025: +4%
- Pepsi volume growth by quarter:
- 2Q/2022: +1%
- 3Q/2022: -1%
- 4Q/2022: -2%
- 1Q/2023: -2%
- 2Q/2023: -2.5%
- 3Q/2023: -2.5%
- 4Q/2023: -4%
- 1Q/2024: -2%
- 2Q/2024: -3%
- 3Q/2024: -2%
- 4Q/2024: -1%
- 1Q/2025: -2%
- 2Q/2025: -1.5%
- 3Q/2025: -3%
Since its volume started declining at the end of 2022 its share prices is down 15%.
London Black Cab Threat
The WSJ reports that Waymo (Google/Alphabet) robotaxis will be introduced into the London market next year.
- This will further challenge the black cab industry in London whose numbers are already in decline:
- 2015: 22,500
- 2025: 14,069
- Down 37%
- The article says that there are approximately 96,000 Uber drivers in London.
- London is a city that was built upon all sorts of smaller medieval villages and so at times it can seem that there is no rhyme or reason to the road network (because there isn’t).
- Drivers of the Black Cab company had to memorize London streets before they were allowed to drive a black cab and this could take 2-4 years.
- Many would drive scooters around the city memorizing the streets.
- The process was known as the Knowledge of London.
- Only one in five would successfully complete the task.
- This served as a barrier to entry because it was part of the government licensing requirements to drive a black cab.
Black Cab Tidbits:
- Short history here with some cool old photos of London.
- Officially known as Hackney carriages.
- Hackney means horse for hire.
- Started in the 1600s and apparently there were complaints back then about road rage with fast driving carriages.
- 1865: The Knowledge of London was first implemented.
- The taxi cabs:
- Very boxy with a high roof to allow for top hats.
- Tight turning radius to help navigate the ancient streets.
- Starting in 1875 cabmen’s shelters will installed throughout London: 61 in total.
- They are small green huts that would provide food and drink to cab drivers.
- There are still 13 left: article here.
- They are small green huts that would provide food and drink to cab drivers.
Delta Airlines
Delta Airlines is based in Atlanta, Georgia and got its start as a crop duster back in 1925.
- For a quick look back see Post 334.
Passenger revenue growth by quarter:
- 1Q/2023: +51%
- 2Q/2023: +21%
- 3Q/2023: +14%
- 4Q/2023: +12%
- 1Q/2024: +7%
- 2Q/2024: +5%
- 3Q/2024: +3% (adjusted for CrowdStrike outage)
- 4Q/2024: +5%
- 1Q/2025: +3
- 2Q/2025: 0%
- 3Q/2025: +1.5% (adjusted for CrowdStrike outage the previous year)
- Special K economy:
- Economy class: -4%
- Business class: +9%
- Special K economy:
Financial Ructions
Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…
Government Spending
According to the IMF, government spending as a percentage of the economy has soared over the last 60 years.
| 2023 | 1963 | |
| France | 57% | 23% |
| Germany | 48% | 29% |
| UK | 44% | 37% |
| Canada | 42% | 30% |
| Japan | 41% | 20% |
| USA | 36% | 26% |
PM: France’s (simple average annual) growth in constant GDP per capita by decade: FRED
- 1960s: 4.7%
- 1970s: 3.5%
- 1980s: 1.9%
- 1990s: 1.6%
- PM: Anyone spotting a trend?
- 2000s: 0.9%
- 2010s: 1.0%
- 2020s: 0.5%
- Compound average from 2019 to 2024 which excludes the big drop of COVID and the subsequent big rebound: 0.4%
PM: As a reminder, the government does not create any capital and all of its spending is financed by the private sector.
- Yes, the government can print money, but that money has no capital stored up in it i.e. the government did not need to produce anything (capital) to obtain that money.
- Unlike the rest of us who must create capital in one form or another to obtain money.
- So, the money we have when we sell our capital is effectively temporarily storing that capital.
- The newly printed government money obtains purchasing power by extracting capital from the rest of the money already in existence.
- So, every time the government prints money the private sector is that much worse off.
- And as the vast majority of government spending is consumption rather than investment, the more the government spends the more capital that’s consumed and the less that’s available for investment.
- The result is that economic prosperity is slowly strangled over time.
- Society then becomes increasingly angry with each other as they scrap it out over the diminishing pile of wealth being created.
Japan Real Wages Stagnating
According to an article from RIETA, real wages in Japan have stagnated.
- Change in real wages:
- 1970-1980: 58.4% (Debt to GDP: 21%)
- 1980-1990: 24.2% (Debt to GDP: 68%)
- 1990-2000: 16.1% (Debt to GDP: 93%)
- 2000-2010: 3.4% (Debt to GDP: 175%)
- 2010-2018: 1.2% (Debt to GDP: 228%)
- According to the article, the massive growth in real wages up to 1990 was due to:
- Vigorous capital accumulation
- Technological innovation
- More efficient resource allocation
PM: Note that government spending is much less efficient than that in the private sector and is also more focused on consumption rather than investment.
- The higher the government spending the more capital that is consumed rather than invested.
PM: Also note that the manipulation of interest rates to zero and even negative territory, a la Japan since 1995, results in a grotesque distortion of the price discovery mechanism of capital markets.
- All central banks have adopted this policy i.e. manipulate interest rates to zero to keep basket case companies alive rather than force them to restructure.
- Bye bye creative destruction and bye bye productivity growth.
- But hello higher asset prices, wealth inequality and housing affordability crisis.
- Bye bye creative destruction and bye bye productivity growth.
On the QT
The Fed started its quantitative tightening in June of 2022 i.e. drain liquidity from the system.
- But its holdings of 10-year+ US Treasuries (FRED) has steadily risen since that time:
- Jun 2022: $1.43 trillion
- Jun 2023: $1.49 trillion
- Jun 2024: $1.52 trillion
- Oct 2025: $1.59 trillion
- Up $160 billion since they started their so-called tightening.
- As 10-year notes/bonds mature the Fed only allows some of them to expire up to a cap and above the cap they reinvest the proceeds in new 10-year bonds.
- The Fed is buying 10-year plus maturities faster than they are falling below 10-years based on the aging of the portfolio.
- Obviously, they are attempting to keep the 10-year yield from rising and the impact that will have on 30-year mortgage rates.
- And doing so along with Treasury as it issues higher proportions of T-Bills vs. T-Bonds.
Book Review: Taxes Have Consequences: An Income Tax History of the United States
By: Arthur Laffer, Brian Domitrovic and Jeanne Cairns Sinquefield | 2022
Chapter 14: The Great Boom, 1982-2000
This was one of the greatest boom periods in American history.
- Real GDP grew at an average annual rate of 3.8%.
- PM: For context, real GDP growth in Canada over the last 25 years has been around 2%.
- 0.8% on a per capita basis.
- PM: For context, real GDP growth in Canada over the last 25 years has been around 2%.
The recessions of the early 1980s were particularly severe and the worst since the 1930s.
- PM: Note that this was a result of legendary Fed Chairman Paul Volcker restricting growth in the money supply to finally kill off inflation.
- Unemployment got to 11% in 1982.
- Previous attempts at raising interest rates were not reducing the money supply as no matter how high rates got they were still very low or even negative in real terms.
Volcker’s money supply crimping contributed to the Dow Jones falling to a single-digit price earnings multiple by 1982.
- In real terms, from 1966 to 1982 (16 years), the Dow Jones lost 75% of its value.
- PM: Stock markets are not always a good inflation hedge.
But also at this time the 1981 Economic Recovery Tax Act tax cuts were being phased in.
- The next two years saw an explosion in real GDP growth: a total of 13.9%
- Top marginal tax rates fell from 70% to 50%.
- The Tax Reform Act of 1986 took it down to 28%.
- For the three-year period ending 1985 the real growth was 18.6%.
- At the same time, inflation averaged 3.5%.
- One third of the average rate from 1979-1981.
- At the same time, inflation averaged 3.5%.
Through the 1980s fiscal deficits soared.
- The authors note that plummeting interest rates helped to offset the government financing costs.
- PM: There was significant increases in defense spending in the 1980s.
- Some credit this with finally ending the cold war with the collapse of the Soviet Union.
- PM: Note that in 1983 Federal tax receipts fell due to the lower tax rates, but then as economic growth responded, tax receipts grew at a simple annual rate of over 8% for the rest of the decade.
- PM: There was significant increases in defense spending in the 1980s.
- PM: Another reason given for the high budget deficits from a fiscal conservative like Reagan is that Congress was split in the early and mid-80s (House: Democrats, Senate: Republicans) and was fully Democrat in the late 80s.
- Still, those deficits were the highest since the US was exiting World War II and contributed to a new precedent for government spending from which we have never recovered.
The authors give credit to Jimmy Carter for his contribution to the 1980s boom.
- He started the deregulation that Reagan continued.
With the 1986 Tax Reform Act:
- There were only two income tax brackets:
- Lower income: 15%
- Higher income: 28%
- Starting in 1990 the number of tax brackets started increasing again and today we have seven.
- And the top corporate tax rate fell to 34%
- A number of exemptions/loopholes were eliminated.
- And it broadened the tax base.
- And it was a bipartisan effort.
- Voting for the Act were notable Democrats such as Joe Biden, Al Gore and Edward Kennedy.
In the 1920s, Treasury Secretary Andrew Mellon had suggested that if the top tax rate for the rich was low enough that it would generate enough tax revenue such that lower/middle income earners would not need to be taxed at all.
- However, the authors contend that politicians would miss the lobbying efforts that come with high taxation i.e. loopholes and exemptions.
- Tax favours.
- This was similar to the high tariff days of the 1800s where “Congress reveled in being approached by umpteen lobbyists.
- “Such attentions made Congress important.”
Tax revenue from the top 1% soared from 1981 to 1988.
The authors point out a close correlation between the tax hikes of George H. W. Bush and the recession of 1990:
- There were now three tax brackets:
- 15%
- 28%
- 31%
With Bill Clinton as president and a Republican controlled Congress in the late 1990s there was further reform.
- Capital gains tax rate cut.
- Exemption of most housing from capital gains taxes.
- Federal outlays fell from 20% of GDP to 17.6% by the year 2000.
The 1990s was a tremendous era of venture capital and starting a business due to low capital gains tax rates.
- And a much lower percentage of capital gains were merely from inflation i.e. not real and still being taxed on it.
Business had not seen such a friendly tax environment since the 1920s.
- And it resulted in an economic boom through the 1980s and 90s.
Chapter 15: Sluggishness in the 2000s
The authors start by noting that the budget surpluses of Bill Clinton’s administration happened after he started cutting taxes in 1996.
Initially there was a slow economic recovery out of the very shallow 2001 recession.
- But things picked up to 3% in the years 2003 to 2007.
- PM: Remember that this is when the Fed’s housing wealth effect policy took off.
- That is, no real capital/wealth being created when the Fed drives housing prices higher.
- But those rising house prices resulted in a plethora of equity extractions and that spending contributed significantly to final spending.
- PM: Remember that this is when the Fed’s housing wealth effect policy took off.
In 2009 the spending of the Obama administration “was enormous.”
- “The tag placed on this monstrosity was ‘stimulus.’”
- The justification is always the Keynesian multiplier.
- The administration warned that the unemployment rate would rise if not for the Keynesian spending prescription.
- Instead, despite the Keynesian stimulus, the unemployment rate went higher than the rate that the government predicted would happen without the spending.
- The Keynesian multiplier ignores the negative multiplier effect from the private sector:
- The source of all government spending comes from the private sector.
- That is, the private sector now has that much less to spend.
- So the multiplier effect equates to zero.
- The source of all government spending comes from the private sector.
- But there is also a substitution effect on the nature of the spending with less being produced and more being consumed leading to economic contraction or less growth than there otherwise would have been.
- For the years 2010 through 2015, the Obama administration was forecasting real GDP growth of anywhere from 3.0% to 4.5% per annum.
- Instead it averaged just over 2%.
The authors note that the “tax cliff” resulted in millions of people exiting the workforce.
- This results when those on benefits have more to lose by working.
- The lost benefits are higher than the after-tax income of working.
- The labor participation rate fell from two-thirds to 61/62%.
- 13 million workers dropped out of the labor force.
Chapter 16: The Trump Tax Cut and Economic Resurgence Into 2020
In 2017 the US had the highest corporate tax rate in the developed world: 35%.
- As of that same year, the US had not experienced a year of GDP growth of 3% or more in each of the previous twelve years.
And they point out the strong growth in household income for the bottom 20% in the years 2016 through 2019.
Conclusion
The authors obviously believe that the Laffer curve is real and that the optimal tax rate is closer to sub-20%.
- And that stimulus spending is “no way to enhance the standard of living.”
- PM: On the latter I wholeheartedly agree.
- On the former I think it’s obvious the Laffer curve is real, but exactly what the optimal tax rate is I really couldn’t say.
- But for sure in Canada we are way above it and it has been sapping investment and productivity for years.
- On the former I think it’s obvious the Laffer curve is real, but exactly what the optimal tax rate is I really couldn’t say.
PM: I hope you enjoyed my review of this book. I certainly learned a lot as this, along with the previous book we reviewed, were areas that I had never really studied. Yes, taxes, while necessary, do have consequences. Key is not trying to kid ourselves that they don’t.
That’s It:
- For Paulitical Economy Post 338
- Until next time:
- Be free
- And do no harm.
Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy® should not be considered as investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information. It is meant for general interest purposes only. Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.