Update
I had a great chat with Emiliano Segales on his Coffee Lounge podcast: Here. We discussed:
- What should be responsible for driving stock markets higher.
- And what shouldn’t.
- The fake wealth effect.
- How Boomers benefit at the expense of the next generation.
- A generational class struggle caused by central banks.
- There is no trickle down from these policies.
- How Boomers benefit at the expense of the next generation.
- Politicians want to do the right thing.
- But are only capable of doing so once we demand it.
- Why I think it’s best to fix our current monetary/economic system rather than blow it up and adopt a new one.
- Zombie companies.
- And how central banks threw our good money after bad.
- Saving and investment come first.
- Consumption comes second.
- Yes, people are working twice as many hours to purchase a home than in days gone by.
- The American Dream has gone by many of the next generation
- Over time, lower interest rates make mortgage payments more expensive.
- The facilitators of the creation of capital (finance and government) are overtaking those who actually create it.
- We talk a bit about Bitcoin.
- The hazards of governments discouraging work.
- My advice to those who are struggling and to those who aren’t.
- The long and fun journey of truth and understanding.
Summary
- All of a sudden a lot more companies are announcing layoffs.
- Things have significantly changed from when companies used to hoard employees just in case.
- A look back at Porsche.
- And sales are falling as their customers are feeling poorish.
- US inflation ticks up to its highest level in eight months with core inflation remaining well above the Fed’s 2% target.
- Which itself is a joke.
- Core inflation measures in Canada remain elevated.
- One of the biggest increases is in property taxes.
- As new development tax revenue plummets what for property taxes to rise even higher.
- Heaven forefend that instead municipalities would become more efficient and cut taxes.
- As new development tax revenue plummets what for property taxes to rise even higher.
- One of the biggest increases is in property taxes.
- New rental prices in Canada are moving down: twelve months in a row.
- Existing rents still moving higher.
- In Financial Ructions
- I have a go at a couple of pieces that attempt to rationalise today’s expensive stock markets.
- And no, valuation is not a timing tool.
- Martin Wolf says that the UK economy needs more investment.
- And higher taxation.
- I have a few comments.
- And higher taxation.
- Some notes from a Grant Williams podcast which looks at the Wicksell spread.
- It was driven down to record negative territory post-COVID and has resulted in monumental misallocation of capital.
- I have a go at a couple of pieces that attempt to rationalise today’s expensive stock markets.
- Book Review
- We start looking at a number of things Keynes said about interest rates and the author’s response.
- And how Keynes wanted to do away with the economic truth that interest rates disclose.
- And Hazlitt’s refutation of Keynes’s liquidity preference used to explain interest rates.
- We start looking at a number of things Keynes said about interest rates and the author’s response.
News
Layoff Frenzy
UPS continue with their transformation strategy announcing that they have let go 48,000 employees: Here
- Management positions: 14,000
- Operations: 34,000
They also closed 93 operating facilities with more likely to come.
The project started in response to planned volume declines from their “largest customer” (Amazon).
3Q/2025 Results:
- Average daily US package volume: -12.3%
- Adjusted cost per package: +10.4%
Speaking of Amazon, the WSJ reports that they are also shrinking their workforces by letting go 14,000 employees with another 16,000 also set to go.
- They said that as they roll out more generative AI that they “…expect that this will reduce our total corporate workforce.”
Molson Coors: we took a look back in Post 328
- Announced their own layoffs: Here.
- 400 salaried positions are to be eliminated.
- A 9% reduction in their Americas salaried workforce.
- 400 salaried positions are to be eliminated.
Paramount is implementing an efficiency strategy of their own.
- According to the WSJ, Paramount will let go 2,000 employees.
- The WSJ said that the company wants to focus on “speaking to the large politically centrist audience in America.”
- PM: Well that certainly is a change.
- PM: Note that the cuts are also related to their recent acquisition of Skydance Media.
Porsche
A look back: Porsche Historical Background
- 1948: Founded by Ferdinand Porsche and his son Ferdinand (Ferry).
- Ferdinand senior had worked for Mercedes-Benz
- And established a design firm that designed the Volkswagen Beetle.
- Ferdinand junior helped design Porsche’s first sports car, the 356: See here
- 356 was the design project number.
- They hand-built the first 52 cars in Gmund, Austria.
- 356 was the design project number.
- Northwest of Vienna on the Czech border.
- Ferdinand senior had worked for Mercedes-Benz
- 1953: Launch of the 550 Spyder.
- 1955: James Dean is killed while driving a 550 Spyder.
- Cool looking car: Here.
- But certainly doesn’t look very safe with no roll bar.
- Cool looking car: Here.
- 1964: Introduced the Porsche 911 at a price of $5,000.
- $57,000 in today’s money.
- 1965: Introduced the Porsche 912 which was a cheaper model of the 911: $4,000 ($42,000 in today’s money).
- Stopped production in 1969.
- 1966: Porsche launched a targa version of the 911.
- Targa is a semi-convertible body style: removable hardtop roof panel over the front seats.
- 1970: After halting production of the 912 they replaced it with the Porsche 914 which had a Volkswagen engine.
- The 914/6 had a Porsche engine.
- 1973: Porsche starts using the name Carrera on the 911.
- Carrera is Spanish for race.
- 1976: Launched the Porsche 924 powered by an Audi engine.
- 1978: Introduced the Porsche 928 with a V-8 engine.
- 1982: Porsche 944 launched based on the 924 but with a Porsche engine.
- 1983: Porsche 911 Cabriolet.
- Cabriolet means folding soft top that folds down behind the rear seats.
- 1993: Introduced a concept car called the Boxster which they started producing in 1997.
- 2003: Cayenne Sport Utility
- 2009: Porsche Panamera which is a four-door sports sedan.
- 2013: Porsche Macan compact luxury SUV.
- 2019: Porsche Taycan, fully electric.
PM: Note there are loads of different sub-model launches but I skipped the vast majority of them otherwise I’d be here all day.
- Porsche fans can click the historical background link above.
3Q/2025 Results:
- Sales: -6.0%
- Car deliveries: -6.0%
- Up 4.8% in North America.
- Percentage of cars that are electric: 35%
- 56% in Europe.
Since 1994, it’s share price has grown at an average annual rate of 8.1%.
US Inflation
September inflation: BLS
US Inflation: BLS
- Dec: 2.9%
- Jan: 3.0%
- Feb: 2.8%
- Mar: 2.4%
- Apr: 2.3%
- May: 2.4%
- Jun: 2.7%
- Jul: 2.7%
- Aug: 2.9%
- Sep: 3.0%
Core inflation (Less food and energy) did likewise.
- Dec: 3.2%
- Jan: 3.3%
- Feb: 3.1%
- Mar: 2.8%
- Apr: 2.8%
- May: 2.8%
- Jun: 2.9%
- Jul: 3.1%
- Aug: 3.1%
- Sep: 3.0%
- Note that core services (less impacted by tariffs) are still growing faster than core commodities (more impacted by tariffs):
- Services: +3.5%
- Commodities: +1.5%
- Note that core services (less impacted by tariffs) are still growing faster than core commodities (more impacted by tariffs):
Moving Up:
- Coffee: +18.9%
- Beef and veal: +14.7%
- Vet services: +7.8%
- Car maintenance/repair: +7.7%
- Household insurance: +7.5%
- Watches: +6.6%
- Tools/hardware: +6.2%
- Hospital services: +5.5%
- Electricity: +5.1%
- Used cars: +5.1%
- According to the BLS, used car prices are up 17.6% since December 2019.
- But according to the Manheim Used Car Index, the price is up around 31%.
- That’s because Manheim doesn’t hedonically adjust the price of a car down in their index every time the quality of the car improves.
- Health insurance: +4.2%
- Alcohol away from home: +4.1%
- Food away from home: +3.7%
- Shelter: +3.6%
- Food: +3.1%
Moving Down:
- Smartphones: -14.9%
- Admission to sporting events: -6.9%
- TVs: -6.0%
- Car rental: -5.0%
- Eggs: -1.3%
Canada Inflation: September
Consumer Price Index (Dec, Jan, Feb adjusted for GST holiday):
- Sep: +1.6%
- Oct: +2.0%
- Nov: +1.9%
- Dec: +2.3%
- Jan: +2.7%
- Feb: +3.0%
- Mar: +2.3%
- Apr: +1.7%
- 2.3% adjusting for the impact of the elimination of the carbon tax.
- May: +1.7%
- 2.3% adjusted?
- Jun: +1.9%
- 2.5% adjusted?
- Jul: +1.7%
- Aug: +1.9%
- Sep: +2.4%
Inflation excluding gasoline ticking up:
- Jan: +1.7%
- Feb: +2.6%
- Mar: +2.5%
- Apr: +2.9%
- May: +2.7%
- Jun: +2.7%
- Jul: +2.5%
- Aug: +2.4%
- Sep: +2.6%
Rising:
- Property taxes: +6.0%
- PM: It’s scandalous that property taxes rise faster than the rate of inflation.
- In fact, they should be growing less than inflation as the cost of many government services should shrink on a per capita basis due to economies of scale and investment in productivity.
- Rent: +4.8%
- PM: Note that rentals.ca have rent falling (see below)
- Food at stores: +4.0%
Falling:
- Air transportation: -6.5%
- Gas: -4.1%
The Bank of Canada’s favourite measures of core inflation
CPI-Trimmed Mean: excludes the top and bottom 20% price changes
- Dec-24: 2.5%
- Jan-25: 2.7%
- Feb-25: 2.9%
- Mar-25: 2.8%
- Apr-25: 3.1%
- May-25: 3.0%
- Jun-25: 3.0%
- Jul-25: 3.1%
- Aug-25: 3.0%
- Sep-25: 3.1%
CPI-Weighted Median: focuses on the middle value
- Dec-24: 2.5%
- Jan-25: 2.5%
- Feb-25: 2.8%
- Mar-25: 2.8%
- Apr-25: 3.1%
- May-25: 3.0%
- Jun-25: 3.0%
- Jul-25: 3.1%
- Aug-25: 3.2%
- Sep-25: 3.2%
Canada For Rent
According to rentals.ca October report: Here.
- Year-over-year rents have fallen twelve months in a row.
- Rents across Canada fell 3.2%
SoSurrey: -11.8%- Mississauga: -9.3%
- Calgary: -8.7%
- Vancouver: -7.8%
- Toronto: -2.4%
- Declines are due to record high completions of apartments.
Average rent for:
- 1-Bedroom Apartment: $1,861
- 1-Bedroom condominium: $2,002
The reason rentals.ca and StatsCan have rents moving in opposite directions is that they measure two different things:
- Rentals.ca measures rent changes on new/vacant rentals.
- So if you move to a new rental you’ll pay less than the previous tenant.
- They obtain their information from apartment listings.
- So if you move to a new rental you’ll pay less than the previous tenant.
- Statcan measures rent changes on existing leases.
- So if you are already renting your rent is going up.
- They obtain their information via surveys of households and landlords.
- So if you are already renting your rent is going up.
Financial Ructions
Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…
He’s At It Again
Reuters journalist Jamie McGeever again demonstrates his mainstream stock market cheerleading, rationalization tendencies.
In an opinion piece in Reuters he suggests that investors’ concerns about extreme market concentration in the US stock market “may be overblown.”
- The reason?
- “Concentration on Wall Street is not that extreme by global standards.”
- In other words, if you’re 50 pounds overweight it’s nothing to worry about if your buddy is 70 pounds overweight.
- PM: This reminds me of our Canadian government bragging about debt to GDP being lower than other G7 countries.
- “Concentration on Wall Street is not that extreme by global standards.”
- This was from my Post 267 in August of last year:
Debt Canada
According to a new report from the Fraser Institute.
- Canada’s debt ranking vs. other G7 countries is worse than the government leads you to believe.
- They will tell you that Canada has the lowest debt to GDP figure of any G7 country.
- PM: Note that this is nothing to crow about if all the other countries are a bunch of fiscal basket cases: 70 pounds overweight.
- Similar to claiming that the US dollar is a strong currency because its exchange rate keeps improving vs. other currencies.
- It’s not a strong currency, it’s just less weak than most others i.e. if a country has inflation its currency is getting weaker.
- However, the Canadian government uses a “net” debt figure instead of “gross” debt.
- Gross debt is primarily bonds that have been issued and they account for 76% of Canada’s total gross debt.
- The second largest part of gross debt is government employee pension plans.
- Net debt subtracts from the gross debt any financial assets the government owns.
- So, when calculating the country’s total government debt they will subtract from that the assets held within the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Quebec Pension Plan (QPP).
- This is extremely misleading.
- First, the assets within the CPP/QPP are not available to the government and are earmarked to fund the retirement of Canadians.
- Second, if those assets are subtracted from the government’s total debt then an equivalent amount should be added back to the debt in terms of the now unfunded future liabilities within CPP/QPP.
- The following is from Wikipedia:
- The Department of Finance’s method to calculate net debt has been criticized for including the assets (but not the liabilities) of the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Quebec Pension Plan (QPP). Yakabuski and Clemens and Palacios argue that the Department of Finance methodology understates net debt, since CPP and QPP assets are set aside to pay for future public retirement plan benefits, so they are not available to also pay down government debt.[11][12]
- Canada’s debt ranking among 32 countries IMF:
- Net debt: 5th
- 13.3% of GDP
- Gross debt (not subtracting assets and including provincial): 26th
- 107.1% of GDP
- Note that in the US that social security (and pension plans of many other countries) are invested entirely in their own government bonds.
- So, when social security assets grow they invest in US government bonds
- Net debt: 5th
- But it doesn’t serve to reduce the “net” debt of the US because the new asset in social security is matched by a new liability in the form of a new treasury.
- In Canada, when CPP/QPP assets grow they are not invested in government bonds (for the most part) so there is no corresponding liability and thus it serves to reduce the net debt figure for Canada.
- In the US, some say that it makes sense to subtract from the US gross debt that debt that is held within social security as the government owes it to itself.
- This net number is called Federal debt held by the public i.e. it excludes debt held by things like social security.
- However, the money lent by social security to the government is not invested in a productive asset and is instead, for the most part, consumed i.e. the government doesn’t have money invested somewhere that it can use to pay off the debt held by social security.
- It has to tax its citizens to pay off the debt it owes social security.
- At least with CPP/QPP the assets are invested in the debt and equity of corporations in the private sector and thus those are real “producing” assets that are available to fund the retirement of Canadians.
- With social security in the US there are no real assets available to fund the retirement of Americans and instead it’s funded by the government’s ability to tax future generations.
- They will tell you that Canada has the lowest debt to GDP figure of any G7 country.
But I digress
- Next, he rightly points to the “buy the dip mentality” that is keeping stock markets elevated.
- PM: Of course, that is a result of the Fed put i.e. speculators know that the Fed will continue to distort the price discovery mechanism of capital markets (at great expense to the economy) in order to keep asset prices elevated.
- He suggests not rocking the boat if you want to continue enjoying the returns of the tech giants.
- And that a “bigger risk may be betting on a reversal too soon.”
- PM: No, you should not be “betting” when it comes to deciding what to do with your investment portfolio.
- Consider the quality of the business and the price you are being asked to pay for the future stream of cash flows and then invest accordingly.
More on the concentration issue:
According to Seeking Alpha, the top ten stocks in the S&P 500 are at a record high concentration going back to 1980. Ok, it’s only 45 years, but still…
Alger.com says that the current concentration of the top five is about 25%.
- Since 1990, the average concentration has been 14%.
- Top five in the Russell 1000: 40%
- Average since 1990: 21%
- The top five account for 15% of the earnings in the S&P 500.
- PM: But those earnings would be growing significantly faster than the average company in the S&P 500.
- Which would warrant a multiple premium.
- The question, of course, is how much of a premium.
- Apart from Apple, the top five are growing their top line at least double that of the index average.
- But their price multiples still appear to be very expensive.
- Of course, it doesn’t mean that they can’t become even more expensive.
- Valuation is not a timing tool, but a fairly good indicator of what sort of return to expect over the long-term.
- The higher the valuation the lower the return and vice versa (all else equal).
- PM: But those earnings would be growing significantly faster than the average company in the S&P 500.
- Alger.com do a bit of rationalizing themselves when they point out that the PEG ratio (Price earnings multiple divided by the EPS growth rate) for the top five is actually lower than for the rest of the S&P 500.
- What he neglects to mention is that the PEG ratio for the rest of the S&P 500 is 52% higher than its 100-year average.
He’s At It Again
Martin Wolf of the Financial Times asks “Why has it become so difficult to run western democracies successfully?”
- He then quotes James Carville: “It’s the economy stupid.”
- PM: Wolf is right about that, but not much else.
The main issue appears in his first sentence. The reason western economies are in so much trouble is precisely because people like him try to run them.
- The issues we are facing are not a result of free-market forces making decisions with their own skin in the game.
- Rather it’s a result of people like Martin Wolf thinking they know better what people should be doing with their hard-earned capital.
- And so, if the economy is out of balance due to previous bad policy, those in charge will introduce even worse policy to get spending growing again.
He correctly says that economic growth is the answer in terms of increasing everyone’s standard of living, but his policies in terms of fiscal and monetary stimulus which increase spending in the short-term, restrict growth from happening in the long-term.
- Remember that consumption does not lead to economic prosperity.
He maintains that the UK has become a zero-sum game.
- No, for the most part the economy is still a mutual benefit type of system i.e. create capital and exchange that capital for money (medium of exchange) and then use that money to purchase capital that others have produced.
- But yes, the economy is increasingly moving towards the “zero-sum, benefit at the expense of someone else” type of system. And this has happened because of the very policies he has urged all these years.
- The result has been:
- Housing affordability crises in a number of developed economies
- Soaring wealth disparity
- Higher inflation
- Exploding government debt and deficits.
- The result has been:
He next says that all of this causes a chronic fiscal problem.
- No, it’s the other way around.
- Chronic deficit spending and loose monetary policy are the cause, not the result.
According to him, economic growth really slowed after the Great Financial Crisis (GFC).
- Total factor productivity which is meant to measure innovation has been negative from 2007 to 2025 in all G7 countries except for the US (but has still fallen in the US).
- PM: This is what happens when you distort the price discovery mechanism of capital markets via QE in order to drive asset prices higher.
PM: Encouragingly, he is now embracing creative destruction rather than bailing out zombie businesses.
- Of course this comes with the short-term pain of job losses
- However, it also results in the long-term gain of better paying jobs in the future and higher productivity growth.
- For decades mainstream economists have imposed policies that resulted in the exact opposite and thus the quagmire in which we find ourselves.
He rightly points out that the UK desperately needs “much higher investment.”
And can I believe my ears when he says that savings need to rise?
- What happened to the Keynesian euthanasia of the rentier class i.e. those doing the saving and investing?
- In an FT piece in May 2020 he attempts to excuse central banks for their role in enabling the explosion of global debt:
- Instead, he says it was the fault of people saving over and above investment opportunities.
- And that this is what caused interest rates to fall resulting in too much debt-fuelled demand.
- PM: What a joke. I’m pretty sure that central banks printing trillions of dollars to explicitly drive down longer-term interest rates and drive asset prices had something to do with it.
- Central banks suppressed interest rates far below their natural rate which has resulted in the declining productivity growth.
- As Mises said, policymakers can deny people the right to receive the natural rate of interest (PM: By printing money and driving interest rates down to the neutral rate) but they can’t eliminate its existence.
- Instead, he says it was the fault of people saving over and above investment opportunities.
However, he then says that taxes must be raised.
- PM: This will achieve the exact opposite of what he says the UK economy desperately needs i.e. investment.
- And he’s recommending the exact opposite of what he said was necessary after Sunak raised corporate taxes back 2001.
- Instead, he recommended “…tight control over spending and slashing the headline rate of corporation tax.”
- PM: I guess his fiscal policy recommendations depends on which party’s in power.
- And he’s recommending the exact opposite of what he said was necessary after Sunak raised corporate taxes back 2001.
- The issue is not that the UK government is not collecting enough in taxes, it’s just the opposite.
- According to the IMF, UK tax revenue as a percentage of GDP:
- 1900: 7.8%
- 1950: 33.5%
- 2023: 38.2%
He finishes off by saying that “Fortunately, the system is in such a mess that radical change is both possible and beneficial.”
- PM: No, we’re not fortunate that we’re in this mess.
- However, it is true that during times of crisis people are often finally willing to do the right thing.
- In other words, don’t waste a good crisis.
- But that’s exactly what they did after the Great Financial Crisis i.e. they wasted the opportunity to abandon their fake wealth effect, asset inflating, economy destructive ways, and instead doubled down.
- It was totally predictable that we would end up here and exactly what I have been explaining to my clients for the last fifteen years.
- However, it is true that during times of crisis people are often finally willing to do the right thing.
Natural Interest Rate
Grant Williams has a podcast service that you can subscribe to and I highly recommend doing so: https://www.grant-williams.com/podcast/
- In a recent podcast with Julien Garran, Garran talks about the Wicksell spread.
- Knut Wicksell was a Swedish economist from around a hundred years ago.
- The Wicksell spread says that the average cost of debt for a corporation should be a couple of percentage points above nominal GDP growth (real GPD growth plus inflation).
- And that this would result in the fastest expansion of the capital stock and quickly do away with capital destroying zombie companies.
- Post-COVID, the Fed took interest rates to zero, and printed trillions of dollars which resulted in a Wicksell spread of negative 13%.
- Along with the reckless fiscal stimulus, this all conspired to take the level of misallocated capital to unprecedented levels.
- The misallocated capital is 17x higher than during the Dot.com bubble.
- When the bubble bursts, Garran believes there will be massive monetary and fiscal response leading to the debasement of the dollar:
- PM: Financial repression.
- But it doesn’t necessarily mean that the dollar will depreciate vs. other currencies because they’ll all be doing it.
- PM: Financial repression.
- Global financial repression.
- Garran says, and I couldn’t agree more, that “perhaps one of the biggest problems facing the global economy is that there’s an ignorance about what makes things work, at a very basic level, how does the world actually work?”
- PM: This is a result of policymakers being influenced by normative economics i.e. economic laws as they wish them to be rather than as they are.
- This fallacious economic doctrine is then foisted on to the press who repeat ad nauseum to their audience.
- PM: This is a result of policymakers being influenced by normative economics i.e. economic laws as they wish them to be rather than as they are.
- People have been sold a false bill of goods with respect to how an economy is supposed to work and what truly leads to economic prosperity.
- Thus my book Capital Offence: Why Some Benefit at Your Expense and this weekly blog.
Book Review: “Where Keynes Went Wrong: And Why World Governments Keep Creating Inflation, Bubbles and Busts“
By: Hunter Lewis | 2009
Chapter 10: Drive Down Interest Rates (and Reap a Whirlwind of Inflation, Bubbles, and Busts). Part 1.
In this chapter I’ll start with what John Maynard Keynes (JMK) said and Hunter Lewis’s (HL) response.
JMK: Interest rates are too high.
- He believed that the “rate of interest is not self-adjusting at a level best suited to the social advantage but constantly tends to rise too high…”
HL:
- What Keynes is essentially saying is that the price system cannot be trusted and that this is “a frontal assault on the entire price system.”
- Interest rates are the most important price in the economy as they affect all other prices.
- He quotes Oysten Dahle in that interest rates must be allowed to “tell the economic truth.”
JMK: High interest rates keep the world poor.
- He blames high interest rates for global poverty.
HL:
- He proposes that the fear of theft is more likely to blame for global poverty.
- And the key perpetrator here has been the state.
- HL notes that if $10 had been invested 1,000 years ago and compounded at a mere 3%, it would now amount to wealth that is twice that of the planet.
- So, what went wrong?
- PM: Well part of the answer is that not all capital is constantly reinvested as the whole point of investing capital is to eventually consume it.
- But HL says that not nearly as much capital is reinvested because of fears that it will be expropriated.
- PM: We saw this in our recent book reviews with private investment drying up during the Great Depression because of hostile policy, first from Hoover and then Roosevelt.
JMK: Interest rates are high because people refuse to lend or refuse to lend on reasonable terms.
- People hoard money when they don’t think they can obtain reasonable rates.
HL:
- These are “Keynesian flashes (intuitions, hunches), unsupported by any real evidence.”
- It suggests that lenders are wealthy and hold all the cards.
- But HL rightly points out that “The vast majority of borrowing is done by wealthy people and firms…”
- Keynes proposed the liquidity theory for interest rates i.e. when people are worried about the economy they will hold on to their money and not lend it thus driving up interest rates.
- However, as Henry Hazlitt has pointed out “…the tendency of interest rates to rise during a boom and fall during a slump is itself a refutation of Keynes’s liquidity preference based theory of interest.”
JMK: The way to lower interest rates is to print money.
- Increase the supply of loanable funds for banks to lend.
HL:
- Yes, initially this will result in lower interest rates.
- However, once it enters the economy it will result in inflation.
- HL quotes economist Melchior Palyi: “Stripped of crypto-scientific semantics, the Keynesian’s medicine is inflation.”
- Higher inflation results in higher interest rates.
- HL says that “Knut Wicksell (1851-1926) initially developed this point. No one, including Keynes, has ever refuted it.”
- The stagflation of the 1970s demonstrated this i.e. high inflation leading to high interest rates.
- HL says that the 1990s does not support Keynes i.e. that lower inflation leads to lower interest rates.
- Inflation was lower due to massive productivity growth and offshoring labor to lower cost countries.
- If these two factors should have led to good deflation of 3% but instead we had inflation of 3%, then the real inflation number was 6%.
- Inflation was lower due to massive productivity growth and offshoring labor to lower cost countries.
- He also notes that government inflation numbers don’t include increases in asset prices/bubbles which often results from money being flooded into the economy e.g. Q.E.
- HL then quotes the great Ludwig von Mises (King of the Austrian school of economics):
- “The cyclical fluctuations of business are not an occurrence originating in the sphere of the unhampered market, but a product of government interference with business conditions designed to lower the rate of interest below the height at which the free market would have fixed it.”
JMK: Money injected into the economy is no different than traditional savings.
- New money injected into the system is “just as genuine as any other savings.”
HL:
- Savings is money that is earned and not spent.
- PM: This is one of Keynes’s most astonishing statements.
- I talk a lot about this sort of thing in my book and in the podcast interviews I’ve been doing.
- It’s crucial to distinguish between capital and money.
- Capital is what people create and is then the means of payment.
- That is, you created capital which then gave you the wherewithal to go out and purchase something.
- But you didn’t directly exchange your capital with someone else.
- You first exchanged your capital for money which is the medium of exchange.
- Once you have the money your capital is effectively stored up in the money.
- Governments printing money don’t produce any capital when they do so and so the new money has not capital stored up in it.
- The new money obtains capital (purchasing power) by extracting capital from the rest of the money already in existence.
- So the government can print money that has value only because it takes value from all of those currently holding cash.
- HL quotes Malcom Bryan who was president of the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta who in 1957 said:
If a [government] policy of active or permissive inflation is to be a fact…we should have the decnecy to say to the money saver, “Hold still, Little Fish! All we intend to do is gut you.”
PM: There is a lot wrong with Keynesian economics, but he did have his moments. Here are a few examples from his General Theory
- First on speculation:
JMK: Speculators may do no harm as bubbles on a steady stream of enterprise. But the position is serious when enterprise becomes the bubble on a whirlpool of speculation. When the capital development of a country becomes a by-product of the activities of a casino, the job is likely to be ill-done.
PM: particularly when supported by the state.
- Second on the hazards of investing for the long-term rather than speculating with the herd (I used the following quote years ago in one of my quarterly reports):
JMK: Finally it is the long-term investor, he who most promotes the public interest, who will in practice come in for most criticism, wherever investment funds are managed by committees or boards or banks. For it is in the essence of his behavior that he should be eccentric, unconventional and rash in the eyes of average opinion. If he is successful, that will only confirm the general belief in his rashness: and if in the short run he is unsuccessful, which is very likely, he will not receive much mercy. Worldly wisdom teaches that it is better for reputation to fail conventionally than to succeed unconventionally.
PM: Too bad he didn’t apply the long-term mindset to his economics.
- Third, although some accuse him of being a socialist, as much of what he recommended rhymed with socialism and he was big on state intervention, at other times he shows that he does not lean that way.
JMK: For my own part, I believe that there is social and psychological justification for significant inequalities of incomes and wealth, but not for such large disparities as exist today. There are valuable human activities which require the motive of money-making and the environment of private wealth-ownership for their full fruition.
PM: The large disparities are only possible with state intervention i.e. central banks deliberately driving asset prices higher or protecting bad businesses from failure.
And here’s one from Hayek for good measure:
The only remedy is to abandon the policy of credit expansion… To attempt to cure the evils by further inflation is to postpone the reckoning.
PM: He had warned in February 1929 that the reckless credit expansion would result in a downturn.
That’s It:
- For Paulitical Economy® Post 340
- Until next time:
- Be free
- And do no harm.
Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy® should not be considered as investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information. It is meant for general interest purposes only. Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.