Update
Hello everyone,
There certainly is a lot going on these days. My goal with Paulitical Economy® is not to cover all of the major headlines as we are all inundated with those. But rather to give you bits of information and/or a different way of looking at things to help you have a better sense of the health of our economy.
I’ve been doing a lot of podcasts lately and have had encouraging feedback on my book. Also, my publisher has sorted out their distribution issues so the book should now arrive much faster.
Lit in a Nutshell did a 51min summary of my book and I thought they did a great job. You can listen to it on Spotify.
I also joined Candy Messer on her Biz Help For You show and we had a great discussion about what leads to business success.
Summary
- Carnival Corporation is charging record prices.
- And a look back.
- A look at what and who caused Canada’s housing affordability crisis.
- And how housing affordability crises around the world have contributed to lowering the globe’s fertility rate.
- Construction of rental properties in Canada is soaring.
- And rents are falling.
- But construction of single-family detached homes has slowed.
- And an increasing number of completed homes are vacant.
- Because people can’t afford them.
- And an increasing number of completed homes are vacant.
- Four of the largest economies in the world are states in the US
- Something Stupid.
- Our Canadian government outdoes itself.
- The bar was already very low.
- Our Canadian government outdoes itself.
- Inflation in America has levelled off but still above the 2% confiscation level.
- And a look at why the official numbers don’t reflect the true cost of health insurance increases.
- Job growth in Canada is very weak: household and payroll survey.
- In Financial Ructions:
- We look at foreign holders of US Treasuries.
- And how the basis trade makes the Cayman Islands the largest foreign holder.
- We look at foreign holders of US Treasuries.
- In Chapter Five of our book review of False Dawn by George Selgin:
- We look at the Reconstruction Finance Corporation that was established by the Hoover Adminstration.
- And how it was way ahead of Bernanke in terms of aiding and abetting the proliferation of zombie companies.
- We look at the Reconstruction Finance Corporation that was established by the Hoover Adminstration.
Quote:
What’s the definition of a financial genius?
A rising stock market.
News
Cruising
Carnival Corporation (cruise lines) is the world’s largest cruise line operator with 40-45% global market share.
- It competes with Royal Caribbean and Norwegian Cruise Lines.
Carnival Corporation brands:
- Carnival
- Princess
- Cunard
- Holland America
- Seabourn
- Costa
- P&O Cruises
My wife and I did a transatlantic crossing on their Cunard Queen Mary 2 for our 25th anniversary back in 2018. I highly recommend it. And make sure you go Southampton to New York rather than vice versa. Going west you gain an hour almost every day, which is helpful given how much we drank over that seven days. We were supposed to go in June, but three days before our trip our agent called to say she messed up our reservation and we weren’t booked. She made up for it with a free five-day trip to Vegas and we sailed two months later.
A look back:
- 1971: Carnival started by Ted Arison with a single ship: Mardi Gras
- It was a subsidiary of AITS (American International Travel Service).
- 1974: Arison buys Carnival from AITS for a buck.
- And assumes $5 million of AITS’s debt.
- 1980: After buying a number of ships it decided to build its first ship.
- 1984: Becomes the first cruise liner to advertise on TV and did so with Kathie Lee Gifford.
- Co-hosted Regis and Kathie Lee from 1985-2000.
- 1987: Carnival shares are listed on the stock market
- Over the last 39 years it has grown at an average of 4.8% per year.
- 1989: Acquires premium cruise line Holland America
- 1992: Buys 25% of ultra premium cruise line Seabourne Cruise Line
- By 1999 they had full ownership.
- 1997: Buys 50% of Italian cruise line Costa Cruises
- Fully owned by 2000
- 1998: Buys two thirds of Cunard (QE2)
- Fully owned by 1999
- 2003: Merged with P&O Princess Cruises
Sales growth by quarter:
- 1Q/2024: +22.0%
- 2Q/2024: +19.5%
- 3Q/2024: +15.2%
- 4Q/2024: +10.0%
- 1Q/2025: +7.5%
- 2Q/2025: +9.5%
- 3Q/2025: +3.2%
- 4Q/2025: +6.6%
- 36% of sales are on-board purchases.
The company cited that:
- They had customer deposits of $7.2 billion (highest ever for the last quarter of the year).
- They have achieved record booking volumes and have done so at historically high prices.
- Their Princess Cruises line launched a new modern ship called Star Princess.
- Tradition has it that when a ship is launched a celebrity godparent is chosen who names and christens the ship by smashing a bottle of champagne against its hull.
- It’s to help bring the ship good luck and protection from the seas.
- For this ship, the godparents were Camila and Matthew McConaughey.
- The celebration included a performance by Sheryl Crow.
- Note that the White Star Line did not follow this tradition and so no godparent for the Titanic.
- And none for its two sister ships Olympic and Britannic
- Britannic sank in 1916 after hitting a mine.
- Ship details:
- Accommodates 4,300 guests
- 1,500 balcony staterooms
- 30 restaurants and bars
- Accommodates 4,300 guests
- Tradition has it that when a ship is launched a celebrity godparent is chosen who names and christens the ship by smashing a bottle of champagne against its hull.
Housing Crisis
In a Globe and Mail article, Hanif Bayat discusses the causes of the housing affordability crises in major U.S. and Canadian cities.
- He starts with the year 2005.
- PM: Note that in 2005 house prices had already started soaring in the US due to monetary policy from 2001 that took interest rates down to 1% and kept them at crisis level for three years despite the fact that the economy was not in contraction.
- This policy heeded the advice of people like Paul Krugman and Paul McCully who recommended that the Fed create a wealth effect through housing.
- In other words, drive interest rates to the floor to make mortgage payments more affordable (temporarily) and increase demand for housing and push their prices higher.
- This policy heeded the advice of people like Paul Krugman and Paul McCully who recommended that the Fed create a wealth effect through housing.
- PM: And with the Bank of Canada (David Dodge) following suit, Canada’s house price had also increased significantly by 2005.
- PM: Note that in 2005 house prices had already started soaring in the US due to monetary policy from 2001 that took interest rates down to 1% and kept them at crisis level for three years despite the fact that the economy was not in contraction.
- 2005-2015:
- He notes that in Canada, monetary policy was a key factor in driving housing prices higher in this decade.
- Despite Canada not suffering nearly as much in the wake of the Great Financial Crisis, Mark Carney took interest rates to “near zero” and he and his successor, Stephen Poloz, kept them there for eight years.
- He notes that in Canada, monetary policy was a key factor in driving housing prices higher in this decade.
- The article does point out a few American cities where demand soared, but because of flexible zoning and land-use rules, more houses were built to accommodate the increased demand.
A Consequence of the Housing Crisis
Macro Musings is a monetary podcast that I listen to on a regular basis and I highly recommend it for those who are interested in this stuff.
- He recently had a guest on talking about the declining global fertility rate.
- The Quandary of Global Demographic Decline
- His guest was Jesus Fernandez-Villaverde
- Some notes:
- The world is below its replacement rate of 2.2 in terms of fertility rates.
- Current rate is 2.15-2.17
- US: 1.6
- Tunisia: 1.6
- Turkey: 1.5
- Jamaica: 1.4
- Iran: 1.4
- Chile: 1.0
- China: 0.9
- And fertility rates have been falling in many countries including:
- Mexico
- Turkey
- Barbados
- Vietnam
- Indonesia
- And fertility rates are even falling in Africa.
- Current rate is 2.15-2.17
- The world is below its replacement rate of 2.2 in terms of fertility rates.
- He says that there are three main reasons for declining global fertility rates:
- Number one is soaring housing prices around the world.
- This is the most important reason in the US.
- PM: And I would argue in most developed economies.
- This is the most important reason in the US.
- And he notes that this is due to a “very low R star.”
- PM: R star is what economists like to refer to as the neutral rate of interest.
- This is the rate of interest that encourages debt-fueled consumption to grow at a steady rate without causing inflation to grow faster than central banks’ 2% confiscation rate.
- Quite simply, he says that house prices are merely a reflection of the present discounted value of the flow of housing services one gets from the house.
- A very low interest rate results in a very high house price.
- He calls this a “very simple valuation effect.”
- And that housing all across the planet is more expensive and that this is resulting in people delaying getting married or into relationships.
- He points out that states in the US that have more affordable housing also have higher fertility rates and vice versa.
- PM: R star is what economists like to refer to as the neutral rate of interest.
- He notes that cultural differences are also contributing to lower fertility rates.
- And also what he calls an education weapons race.
- Parents want their kids to go to the best schools to ensure the best career.
- And having more than one or two kids is too much work and too costly to ensure they all go to the best schools.
- Parents want their kids to go to the best schools to ensure the best career.
- Number one is soaring housing prices around the world.
Yes, More Housing
According to Canada Housing and Mortgage Corporation (CMHC), in 2025 the construction of:
- Starts for rental housing were up and were almost twice the ten-year average.
- Record highs in:
- Calgary
- Edmonton
- Ottawa
- Halifax
- Montreal
- Toronto was second-highest on record.
- This is leading to higher vacancy rates and pressure on rents.
- They expect further easing on rents over the next three years.
- Rentals.ca show that national rents are down 2.8% at $2,030, which is the lowest in almost three years.
- Vancouver: -7.6%
- Toronto: -5.3%
- They also show that the rent-to-income ratio fell to 29%
- Lowest level in six years.
- And below the 30% benchmark.
- Meaning that no one should be spending more than 30% of their pre-tax income on rent.
- So if $2,030 per month is 29% of the average gross income, then gross income on average is $84,000 per year.
- Depending on the province, this amounts to around $58,000 after tax and so rent would be 42% of after-tax income.
- Record highs in:
- Ground-oriented construction fell:
- It fell the most in Toronto and Ottawa.
- The unsold inventory of condominiums once completed for 7 major CMAs (Census Metropolitan Area) hit a new record:
- 2019 (previous record): 4,424
- 2025: 6,134
- Up 39% from the previous record.
- The increase on a per capita basis would be lower but still high.
- Up 39% from the previous record.
- The number of vacant completed single-detached homes is the third highest over the last 25 years.
- And the only reason it’s not the highest is because builders drastically reduced the number of detached homes they built last year.
- “Ground-oriented starts remained well below historical averages…”
- And the only reason it’s not the highest is because builders drastically reduced the number of detached homes they built last year.
They claim that because the inventory of unsold homes is high that “today’s supply may not align well with buyers’ needs.”
- PM: No, this is not what’s going on.
- The needs of young Canadians are considerably higher than the current supply of homes for sale.
- What doesn’t align, is the price that homeowners are asking for their homes.
Lone Star State
The FT reports that ExxonMobil is moving its corporate domicile from New Jersey to Texas.
- Its main operating business is already in the Houston area.
ExxonMobil said that they expected “more reasonable, productive decisions” from Texas state officials.
This follows a long line of companies that have moved from states like Delaware and California to the Lone Star State.
- Texas is now in the top ten in global economies:
- USA
- China
- Germany
- California
- Japan
- India
- UK
- France
- Texas
- Italy
- Russia
- New York
- Canada
- South Korea
- Florida
Something Stupid
Just when you thought government couldn’t say anything stupider.
- Canada’s Housing Minister, Gregor Robertson, is now blaming the housing affordability crisis on the war in Iran.
- “Mr. Speaker, it is no surprise that Canadians are challenged with buying homes right now when there is a war in the Middle East.”
- You can’t make this stuff up.
- What else might be the cause of Canada’s youth suffering through the worst housing affordability crisis in our country’s history and one of the worst on the planet?
- How about the destruction of the Amazon rain forest.
- Maybe it’s global warming.
- I’m sure Trump must have something to do with it.
- Maybe it’s Canadian consumers who are to blame i.e. even though we have one of the world’s highest levels of household debt to GDP, maybe it’s still too low.
- Time to euthanize the rentier class who irresponsibly save their money.
- And of course we lost the hockey gold medal to the US; that surely must have sent home prices soaring.
- Perhaps it’s because I ate too many meat pies on our recent trip to New Zealand.
- This is absolutely astonishing stuff.
- Kind of like when Trudeau said that the government was taking on debt so Canadians wouldn’t have to.
- What a relief.
- Kind of like when Trudeau said that the government was taking on debt so Canadians wouldn’t have to.
- Obviously, these people can’t be that stupid.
- But it’s insulting that they think Canadians are.
- Governments of all stripes have an awful habit of denying responsibility for the consequences of their actions: good way to stay in power.
- But this government is taking it to a whole new level.
- What else might be the cause of Canada’s youth suffering through the worst housing affordability crisis in our country’s history and one of the worst on the planet?
- Finally, note that homes have become unaffordable in Canada on the watch of both parties; same as in the US.
- For the last twenty-five years it has been central banks driving up demand for housing by taking interest rates to unnaturally low levels.
- They think that driving asset prices higher is good for the economy because it encourages people to use those inflated asset levels as collateral for more loans to go out and spend.
- Kindling their treasured Keynesian animal spirits.
- This is all a really bad idea.
- They think that driving asset prices higher is good for the economy because it encourages people to use those inflated asset levels as collateral for more loans to go out and spend.
- It was only over the last 5-10 years that governments joined central banks in exacerbating the housing affordability crisis:
- Federal: irresponsible levels of immigration far in excess of the home building market’s ability to respond.
- Municipal: completely irresponsible increases in new development fees and taxes such that in some areas they amounted to close to a third of the cost of building a new home.
- For the last twenty-five years it has been central banks driving up demand for housing by taking interest rates to unnaturally low levels.
US Inflation
- Dec-2025: 2.9%
- Jan-2025: 3.0%
- Feb-2025: 2.8%
- Mar-2025: 2.4%
- Apr-2025: 2.3%
- May-2025: 2.4%
- Jun-2025: 2.7%
- Jul-2025: 2.7%
- Aug-2025: 2.9%
- Sep-2025: 3.0%
- Oct/Nov-2025: 2.7%
- Dec-2025: 2.7%
- Jan-2026: 2.4%
- Feb-2026: 2.4%
Core inflation (Less food and energy):
- Dec: 3.2%
- Jan: 3.3%
- Feb: 3.1%
- Mar: 2.8%
- Apr: 2.8%
- May: 2.8%
- Jun: 2.9%
- Jul: 3.1%
- Aug: 3.1%
- Sep: 3.0%
- Oct/Nov: 2.6%
- Dec: 2.6%
- Jan-2026: 2.5%
- Feb-2026: 2.5%
Moving Up:
- Coffee: +18.4%
- Home healthcare: +15.0%
- Beef and veal: +14.4%
- Jewelry: +11.2%
- Gold price?
- Women’s dresses: +8.7%
- Pet services: +7.3%
- In terms of salary potential, this field must be starting to compete with investment banking.
- Airline fares: +7.1%
- Expect this to spike higher in March due to higher fuel costs.
- Hospital services: +7.1%
- Dental services: +6.5%
- Watches: +6.4%
- Fish and seafood: +5.1%
- Food: +3.1%
- Full-service restaurants: +4.6%
Moving Down:
- Eggs: -42.1%
- Smartphones: -13.9%
- Sporting events: -6.9%
- Men’s suits: -6.1%
- But men’s underwear +4.5%
- Men working more at home in their underwear?
- But men’s underwear +4.5%
- Gasoline: -5.6%
- Expect a bump up in the March report
- TVs: -4.1%
- Health insurance: -3.6%
- Note that most people will not believe this number and they are right to question it.
- The change in health insurance costs are not measured by comparing the year-to-year change in the insurance premium people pay.
- Instead, it measures the increase in two things at the insurance company:
- Administrative costs
- Profit
- Also known as the retained earnings method which we have previously discussed.
- Instead, it measures the increase in two things at the insurance company:
- The rationale is that the rest of the insurance premium is used to pay for whatever healthcare services the insured person has received.
- And the cost of those services are already included in the CPI calculation.
- For instance, as we saw above:
- Home healthcare: +15.0%
- Hospital services: +7.1%
- So if you had insurance and didn’t have to pay out of pocket for hospital services then including the increase in both the services and the insurance cost would be double-counting.
- Of course, if you didn’t have to make any claims on your insurance then the decline of 3.6% for health insurance premiums drastically understates your out-of-pocket expenses.
- In other words, if you were lucky enough to get sick you effectively paid less.
- But note that this is a really bad way to report the true cost of health insurance premiums.
- If the government wanted to avoid double-counting they should report the true rise in cost of medical insurance and then make an adjustment afterward in terms of its impact on CPI.
- Used cars and trucks: -3.2%
- Hotels: -2.2%
Canada Jobs: Labour Force Survey
- – Feb 2025: 1,100
- – Mar 2025: -33,000
- – Apr 2025: 7,400 (Adjusted: -9,600)
- – May 2025: +8,800
- – Jun 2025: +83,000
- – Jul 2025: – 41,000
- – Aug 2025: -66,000
- – Sep 2025: +66,000
- – Oct 2025: +67,000
- – Nov 2025: +54,000
- – Dec 2025: +8,200
- – Jan 2026: -25,000
- – Feb 2026: -84,000
- o The number of full-time workers fell 108,000.
The employment rate: the percentage of those 15 years and older in the workforce.
- Feb 2020: 62.1%
- Nov 2024: 60.6%
- Dec 2024: 60.8%
- Jan 2025: 61.1%
- Feb 2025: 61.1%
- Mar 2025: 60.9%
- Apr 2025: 60.8%
- May 2025: 60.8%
- Jun 2025: 60.9%
- Jul 2025: 60.7%
- Aug 2025: 60.5%
- Sep 2025: 60.6%
- Oct 2025: 60.8%
- Nov 2025: 60.9%
- Dec 2025: 60.9%
- Jan 2026: 60.8%
- Feb 2026: 60.6%
Unemployment rate:
- – Feb 2025: 6.6%
- – Mar 2025: 6.7%
- – Apr 2025: 6.9%
- – May 2025: 7.0%
- – Jun 2025: 6.9%
- – Jul 2025: 6.9%
- – Aug 2025: 7.1%
- – Sep 2025: 7.1%
- – Oct 2025: 6.9%
- – Nov 2025: 6.5%
- – Dec 2025: 6.8%
- – Jan 2026: 6.5%
- – Feb 2026: 6.7%
Wage growth:
- – Jan 2025: +3.5%
- – Feb 2025: +3.8%
- – Mar 2025: +3.6%
- – Apr 2025: +3.4%
- – May 2025: +3.4%
- – Jun 2025: +3.2%
- – Jul 2025: +3.3%
- – Aug 2025: +3.2%
- – Sep 2025: +3.3%
- – Oct 2025: +3.5%
- – Nov 2025: +3.6%
- – Dec 2025: +3.4%
- – Jan 2026: +3.3%
- – Feb 2026: +3.3%
Canada Jobs: Payroll Survey
Payroll employment measures the number of employees receiving pay and benefits from their employer.
September report here.
The monthly change (revised) is below:
- – Apr 2025: +14,600
- – May 2025: +18,500
- – Jun 2025: -9,100
- – Jul 2025: +25,600
- – Aug 2025: +17,600
- – Sep 2025: -24,300
- – Oct 2025: +11,900
- – Nov 2025: -1,000
- – Dec 2025: -35,400
Financial Ructions
Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…
Foreign Holders of US Treasuries
From the US Treasury International Capital (TIC) report:
- Japan: $1,185.5 billion: +11.7%
- UK: $866 billion: +19.8%
- China: $683.5 billion: -9.9%
- Belgium (Euroclear): $477.3 billion:+27.4%
- Canada: 468.1 billion: +23.6%
Countries that reduced their holdings over the last twelve months:
- China
- Switzerland
- India
- Brazil
- Cayman Islands
- Note that the Cayman Islands is home to around 70% of global hedge funds.
- And this note from the Federal Reserve says that actual hedge fund holdings of US Treasuries in the Cayman Islands are significantly under-reported.
- This is due to the hedge fund basis trade with US Treasuries.
- Cayman Islands holdings of US Treasuries according to:
- Treasury Department: $421.2 billion
- Fed report: $1.8 trillion
- This would make the Cayman Islands by far the largest holder of US Treasuries.
- The extra $1.4 trillion of US Treasuries is not captured in the TIC data because hedge funds use repo to fund the Treasury purchases.
- When borrowing from the repo market collateral is required.
- So, the US Treasury holdings of hedge funds domiciled in the Cayman Islands are held in custody in the US.
- When borrowing from the repo market collateral is required.
- Much of the funding through repo is provided by money market funds.
- Also note that many of the hedge funds domiciled in the Cayman Islands are from the US.
Book Review: “False Dawn by George Selgin“
Chapter 5: The RFC, Part 1
The RFC or Reconstruction Finance Corporation was established by President Hoover and so “was not a New Deal innovation.”
- But FDR to full advantage of it “turning it into the largest New Deal agency of all.”
- It became America’s largest organization and the world’s biggest bank.
As a reminder, Hoover was the most interventionist President up to that time.
- Selgin tells us that on public works spending, Hoover had spent more than the previous nine administrations combined.
The RFC was set up to help small banks with Hoover saying that larger banks could take care of themselves.
- That all changed when the head of the RFC, Charles Dawes, resigned because he was Chairman the Central Republic Bank, based in Chicago.
- The RFC then decided to lend $90 million to this large bank.
- PM: Things never seem to change and when the going gets tough the rules are simply broken.
- Not only that but policymakers attempt to hide the fact that they have broken their own rules.
- For instance, the Hoover administration had been telling the public that most of the loans made by the RFC were going to small banks.
- But this was very misleading as most of those loans were for very small amounts.
- And Central Republic was not the only large bank to receive RFC loans and those loans were very large.
- So yes, most of the loans went to small banks but most of the money went to large banks.
- And not only that, but a lot of the loans to smaller banks were made so that they could repay loans to larger banks.
- PM: Just like the backdoor bailout of Goldman Sachs through AIG.
- The RFC then decided to lend $90 million to this large bank.
- Regardless, history shows that RFC’s loans were not politically motivated and were indeed made with the “desire to limit bank failures.”
- However, initially the RFC was not deemed a success due to:
- It’s strict collateral requirements.
- The stigma that came from receiving money from the RFC.
The RFC then shifted gears from providing loans to providing capital.
- This was an acknowledgement that the issues facing many banks was one of solvency rather than liquidity.
Note that railroads were also eligible for RFC loans.
- Primarily because their main investors were banks.
- Only a fifth of the money lent to railroads was used to maintain capital equipment.
- 80% went to repaying the railroads’ creditors.
- Railroads were suffering from new competition from “newer forms of transportation:
- Planes
- Cars
- Trucks
- Overall, RFC loans to railroads are deemed to have made the situation worse.
- The loans allowed railroad to delay the inevitable reorganization that needed to take place and allowed railroads to “stave off bankruptcy longer.”
- They blocked the essential creative destruction of capital markets
- PM: Sound familiar?
- The first zombies?
- Only a fifth of the money lent to railroads was used to maintain capital equipment.
- Selgin finishes the chapter by pointing to a study that showed that from 1929 to 1940, large railroads that declared bankruptcy ultimately spent considerably more on equipment and wages than those that were avoiding bankruptcy by taking RFC loans.
- The lesson is that “governments should allow distressed firms to go bankrupt, instead of providing bailouts that merely postpone the inevitable.”
- Selgin notes that this is a lesson many governments still haven’t learned.
- PM: I would argue that none have.
- Selgin notes that this is a lesson many governments still haven’t learned.
- The lesson is that “governments should allow distressed firms to go bankrupt, instead of providing bailouts that merely postpone the inevitable.”
That’s It:
- For Paulitical Economy® Post 358
- Until next time:
- Be free
- And do no harm.
Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy® should not be considered investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information. It is meant for general interest purposes only. Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.