Hello everyone,
Winter doesn’t seem to want to give up and we’re having light snow flurries up here in Toronto.
On Saturday we had raclette for dinner. Raclette cheese (Swiss and French) is melted and poured over small potatoes and baguettes. You can order a raclette grill on Amazon for less than $100. You should give it a try while we still have this cold weather.
I made a third appearance on Piggo’s Trading and will be making a fourth appearance in May. I really like these guys and their questions result in a discussion that is a bit different. Questions they asked:
- How will high oil prices be inflationary?
- How will Japan be impacted?
- What will happen to the US 10-Year Treasury yield if Kevin Warsh is the new Fed Chair?
- Is the 50-year mortgage a good idea?
- What are my thoughts on The Great Taking?
- How long will the war with Iran last?
- And how will that impact the prices of gold and silver?
- What will be the result of the oil supply shock?
I’ve been doing a lot of podcasts lately and will link to more of them in next week’s post.
Summary
- Homicides in the US are the lowest in 125 years.
- Canada’s economic decline has outpaced all other developed nations over the last ten years.
- And so has our happiness.
- I have a feeling we’re not in Kansas anymore.
- California has by far the highest gasoline prices in America.
- And Kansas the lowest.
- California has by far the highest gasoline prices in America.
- Delta’s passenger revenue miles go negative.
- And economy class revenue even more so.
- And a look back.
- If you’re thinking of buying a new car you might want to hire a professional haggler.
- The ratio of stock market wealth to housing wealth in Canada is at a 23-year high.
- And a look at wealth disparity.
- Darden restaurants continues to grow its top line.
- Sales at Bloomingdale’s accelerate and stagnate at Macy’s: Special K.
- General Mills has grown its volume in only one of the past eighteen quarters.
- Inflation in Canada ticked down last month.
- But food prices are getting out of control.
- Amazon is testing 30-minute delivery service.
- In Financial Ructions:
- Longer-term interest rates around the world are gapping higher.
- And so did wholesale inflation in the US.
- In our Book Review of False Dawn
- We see that any recovery that did happen in the 1930s was in large part due to Hitler.
- And that rather than allow commodity prices to fall to reflect the supply/demand dynamics, the government introduced the Agricultural Adjustment Administration (AAA) which served to raise food prices.
- Not helpful when people are starving.
News
US Homicides
According to the WSJ, homicides in the US are at a 125 year low.
- Homicide rate (approximate) per 100,000 people:
- 2019: 11
- 2022: 16
- 2025: 9
- Reasons given for the decline in homicides:
- Tougher policing
- Less alcohol consumption
- More people spending time alone
- Some cities with the steepest declines in homicide rate since 2020:
- Baltimore: -59%
- St. Louis: -43%
- New Orleans: -39%
- Only three cities saw an increase in the rate of homicide:
- Honolulu
- El Paso
- Austin
Unhappiness Index
A report by The Hub looks at Canada’s declining economic prosperity relative to other developed nations.
Growth in GDP per capita from 2014 to 2024:
- Ireland: 82%
- USA: 20%
- Spain: 17%
- Italy: 14%
- Switzerland: 9%
- Japan: 8%
- Australia: 7.5%
- UK: 7.4%
- Germany: 5.5%
- Canada: 3.2%
Canada’s GDP per capita is now lower than the OECD average (and Alabama) for the first time in recorded history.
Numerous studies show that GDP per capita has a high correlation with well-being.
- PM: All of these people who say that wealth doesn’t matter in terms of happiness should perhaps ask all of those happy people who are struggling to pay their bills and can’t afford to start a family.
The report says that studies have also shown that higher GDP per capita also correlates with less wealth inequality.
- PM: I would argue that it depends on what’s driving GDP per capita.
- If it’s savings and investment resulting in the creation of more capital that we can all freely exchange with each other via an honest medium of exchange (hard money), then yes, this leads to lower wealth inequality and a fairer distribution of wealth.
- But if GDP is being driven higher by debt-fueled consumption and/or a central bank driven fake wealth effect via abnormally low interest rates and printing trillions of dollars to drive stock markets higher, then wealth inequality will widen, which is what’s happened in America.
- Wealth held by the top 1%
- 1990: 22.8%
- 2024: 30.4%
- Wealth held by the bottom 50%
- 1990: 3.5%
- 2024: 2.5%
- Equities and Mutual Funds held by:
- Top 10%: 87%
- Bottom 50%: 1%
- Wealth held by the top 1%
- Within the bottom 50% most wealth is held in the form of housing that has been artificially driven higher causing a housing affordability crisis and benefiting the older cohort.
- Percentage of wealth by age in America:
- 55 and over:
- 1989: 56.0%
- 2025: 73.7%
- 54 and younger:
- 1989: 31.9%
- 2025: 26.3%
- Note that part of the increase in wealth held by the 55+ crowd is due to an ageing population.
- But it’s also due to home ownership declining for younger people due to unaffordability.
- 55 and over:
- The average age of the first-time homebuyer in America is now 40 years of age.
And back to the Hub report.
- They cite a Bank of Canada report that says 40% of potential top 1% income earners in Canada have emigrated to the US:
- This share has doubled since 2005.
- We saw in a previous post how there has been a significant shift in Canadians starting new businesses in the US rather than in Canada.
- And Canada’s GDP performance is even worse than it appears as government spending increased as a percentage of GDP:
- 2014: 38%
- 2024: 45%
- Much of the increase was a result of rising deficits
- Obligations of the next generation.
- And remember that the vast majority of government spending is consumption rather than investment.
- This leads to less stuff being produced over time.
- Much of the increase was a result of rising deficits
- Food bank visits have doubled since 2019.
- Healthcare wait time between doctor referral and treatment:
- 1993: 9.3 weeks
- 2025: 28.6 weeks
- More than a fifth of Canadian employees now work for the government.
- PM: As a reminder, while necessary, government doesn’t produce any capital of its own.
- All capital that it spends it first obtains from the private sector.
- PM: As a reminder, while necessary, government doesn’t produce any capital of its own.
- Issues that have resulted in less investment in Canada:
- Tax system (to support the irresponsible levels of government spending)
- Regulatory burden
- Protected sectors that are sheltered from competition and thus disincentivized to invest.
- But hey, as defenders of the last ten years of government policy point out, there’s more to life than GDP e.g. happiness.
Happiness Index
The latest World Happiness Report was just published.
1. Finland
2. Iceland
3. Denmark
4. Costa Rica
5. Sweden
6. Norway
7. Netherlands
8. Israel
9. Luxembourg
10. Switzerland
17. Germany
23. USA
25. Canada (see below)
29. UK
35. France (PM: But we keep hearing that there’s more to life than GDP per capita)
38. Italy
41. Spain
61. Japan (PM: But we keep hearing that over 200% debt to GDP doesn’t matter)
Since 2012, Canada suffered the largest decline in happiness of any developed nation.
- Canada’s ranking by year:
- 2014: 5
- 2015: 6
- 2016: 7
- 2017: 7
- 2018: 9
- 2019: 11
- 2020: 14
- 2021: 15
- 2022: 13
- 2023: 15
- 2024: 18
- 2025: 25
But of course, averages tend to shroud what is going on underneath.
- Canada’s ranking for younger people is 71.
- This is what happens when one part of society is benefitting at the expense of another.
Gasoline Cost By State
Cost per gallon: AAA
- Most Expensive:
- California: $5.51
- Hawaii: $4.94
- Washington: $4.89
- Nevada: $4.58
- Oregon: $4.47
- Least Expensive:
- Kansas: $3.13
- 43% cheaper than in California.
- North Dakota: $3.18
- Oklahoma: $3.22
- Arkansas: $3.22
- Missouri: $3.23
- Kansas: $3.13
- Other states:
- Florida: $3.72
- Illinois: $3.71
- New York: $3.60
- Texas: $3.38
Delta Airlines
Delta Airlines
- 1925: Founded as Huff Daland Dusters (crop dusters) in Macon, Georgia (84 miles southeast of Atlanta).
- A few months later they moved to Monroe, Louisiana (around 300 miles northwest of New Orleans)
- 1928: Renamed Delta as it served the Mississippi Delta region
- 1929: Operates its first passenger service: a flight from Dallas to Jackson, Mississippi.
- 1940: “Stewardesses” were added to flight crews.
- 1941: Head office moved to Atlanta.
- 1955: Pioneered the hub and spoke system where rather than direct flights to so many cities, flights would instead go to a “hub” city and then connect there for your final destination.
- 1965: Delta becomes the first airline to operate the Douglas DC-9.
- 1970: Service begins with the Boeing 747.
- 1972: Merged with Northeast Airlines
- 1972: A Delta Douglas DC-8 was hijacked while on route from Detroit to Miami.
- The plane eventually landed in Algeria.
- No one was killed or injured.
- The plane eventually landed in Algeria.
- 1978: Jimmy Carter deregulates the airline industry.
- Delta begins international service, challenging Pan Am and TWA.
- One study estimates that post deregulation, domestic fares fell 40% in real terms from 1980 to 2005.
- Delta begins international service, challenging Pan Am and TWA.
- 1980: Two hijackings
- 1982: Delta purchases its first Boing 767
- 1983: Two more hijackings
- 1987: Merged with Western Airlines (based in Los Angeles) to become America’s fourth largest carrier.
- 1990: Starts operating the McDonnell Douglas MD-11.
- 1991: Buys most of Pan Am’s trans-Atlantic routes.
- As we noted in a previous post, United Airlines bought the rest of Pan Am’s business.
- 2005: Filed for bankruptcy protection and restructured its business
- 2008: Acquired Northwest Airlines
- 2013: Acquires a 49% stake in Virgin Atlantic.
Note that Delta is one of three US airlines to make the top 25 globally in terms of safety at number 23.
- Air Canada is 22.
- Top Five:
- Etihad
- Cathay Pacific
- Qantas
- Qatar
- Emirates
- Top Five:
Passenger revenue growth by quarter:
- 1Q/2023: +51%
- 2Q/2023: +21%
- 3Q/2023: +14%
- 4Q/2023: +12%
- 1Q/2024: +7%
- 2Q/2024: +5%
- 3Q/2024: +3% (adjusted for CrowdStrike outage)
- 4Q/2024: +5%
- 1Q/2025: +3%
- 2Q/2025: 0%
- 3Q/2025: +3%
- 4Q/2025: +1%
Special K economy:
- Economy Class:
- 4Q/2025: +2%
- 1Q/2025: -1%
- 2Q/2025: -5%
- 3Q/2025: -4%
- 4Q/2025: -7%
- Business Class:
- 4Q/2025: +8%
- 1Q/2025: +7%
- 2Q/2025: +5%
- 3Q/2025: +9%
- 4Q/2025: +9%
- Domestic: 0%
- Atlantic: +4%
- Revenue passenger miles are the number of miles paying passengers have flown.
- 4Q/2024: +5%
- 1Q/2025: +3%
- 2Q/2025: +2%
- 3Q/2025: +2%
- 4Q/2025: -1%
Won’t Haggle?
An article in the WSJ talks about a professional haggler who will help you get a better price when you purchase a new car.
- A former car salesperson, Tomi Mikula, started his own firm called delivrd.
- He charges $1,000 to negotiate on your behalf.
- He also livestreams a lot of his conversations and has 600,000 social media subscribers.
PM: You can watch him negotiate here.
- I could never do this.
- Delivrd is now a team of five negotiators and they make $200,000 per month.
PM: Python fans will remember the haggling scene from Life of Brian here.
Wealth Distribution in Canada
According to Statscan
- Wealth held in Canada by:
- Top 20% of households: 65.5%.
- Average wealth: $3.5 million
- Bottom 40% of households: 3.1%
- Average wealth: $82,100
- Top 20% of households: 65.5%.
- The ratio of financial assets (stock market) to nonfinancial assets (homes): 120.7%
- Highest in 23 years.
- PM: Twenty years ago was when the commodity boom was sending the Canadian stock market through the roof.
- The peak ratio was in the third quarter of 2000.
- This is when Nortel was reaching its peak price.
- As a reminder, Nortel stock was up around 290% in 1999.
- This is when Nortel was reaching its peak price.
- Highest in 23 years.
- Household debt to disposable income by decade:
- 1990s: 99.9%
- 2000s: 130.6%
- 2010s: 173.0%
- 2020s: 181.0%
- PM: In case you were wondering, this is not a good trend.
Darden Restaurants
Darden is America’s largest chain of casual dining restaurants with 2,182 stores and owns:
- Olive Garden
- LongHorn Steakhouse
- Yard House
- Ruth’s Chris Steak House
- Cheddar’s Scratch Kitchen
- Capital Grille
- Seasons 52
- Eddie V’s
- Bahama Breeze
- The Capital Burger
Results:
- Same store sales by quarter:
- 3Q/2023: +11.7%
- 4Q/2023: +4.0%
- 1Q2024: +5.0%
- 2Q/2024: +2.8%
- 3Q/2024: -1.0%
- 4Q/2024: -1.6%
- 1Q/2025: -1.1%
- 2Q/2025: +2.4%
- 3Q/2025: +0.7%
- 4Q/2025: +4.6%
- 1Q/2026: +4.7%
- 2Q/2026: +4.3%
- 3Q/2026: +4.2%
- Olive Garden: +3.2%
- Longhorn Steakhouse: +7.2%
- Fine Dining: 2.1%
- They mentioned strong sales of their smaller portion meals at Olive Garden.
Macy’s
Macy’s Inc owns:
- Macy’s departments stores
- Bloomingdales
- Bluemercury
Macy’s started off as a dry goods store in New York City in 1858.
Like many department stores, Macy’s had been suffering from declining sales.
- They started revamping the business in early 2024.
- The turnaround plan seems to be working.
Macy’s comparable store sales by division:
- Macy’s:
- 1Q/2024: -0.4%
- 2Q/2024: -3.6%
- 3Q2024: -2.2%
- 4Q/2024: -0.9%
- 1Q/2025: -2.1%
- 2Q/2025: +1.2%
- 3Q/2025: +2.0%
- 4Q/2025: +0.4%
- Bloomingdales:
- 1Q/2024: +0.3%
- 2Q/2024: -1.4%
- 3Q2024: +3.2%
- 4Q/2024: +6.5%
- 1Q/2025: +3.8%
- 2Q/2025: +5.7%
- 3Q/2025: +9.0%
- 4Q/2025: +9.9%
- Again, we see the K-shaped phenomenon with luxury outselling mid-tier.
General Mills
General Mills started off as a flour mill in Minneapolis in 1866.
It has the following brands:
- Cheerios
- Haagen-Dazs ice cream (Nestle owns the rights in the US)
- Betty Crocker
- Bisquick
- Cocoa Puffs
- Green Giant
- Old El Paso
- Pillsbury
- Used to own Yoplait but sold it in 2025.
- And many more
Growth has slowed significantly, and I would suspect it’s due in large part to big price increases in previous years:
Adjusted sales by quarter:
- 3Q/2023: +16%
- 4Q/2023: +5%
- 1Q/2024: +4%
- 2Q/2024: -2%
- 3Q/2024: -1%
- 4Q/2024: -6%
- 1Q/2025: -1%
- 2Q2025: +1%
- 3Q/2025: -5%
- 4Q/2025: -3%
- 1Q/2026: -3%
- 2Q/2026: -1%
- 3Q/2026: -3%
- Price: -1%
- Volume: -2%
- North American Retail: -4%
- North American Pet: -3%
- North American Food Service: -3%
- International: +1%
Volume by quarter:
- – 1Q/2022: +1%
- – 2Q/2022: 0%
- – 3Q/2022: -4%
- – 4Q/2022: -2%
- – 1Q/2023: -5%
- – 2Q/2023: -6%
- – 3Q/2023: 0%
- – 4Q/2023: -6%
- – 1Q/2024: -2%
- – 2Q/2024: -4%
- – 3Q/2024: -2%
- – 4Q/2024: -2%
- – 1Q/2025: 0%
- – 2Q2025: +2%
- – 3Q/2025: -4%
- – 4Q/2025: 0%
- – 1Q/2026: -1%
- – 2Q/2026: 0%
- – 3Q/2026: -2%
They expect a “continued challenging consumer backdrop.”
a. And expect fiscal 2026 sales to be essentially flat.
This is quite a change from a few years ago:
b. From my post in December 2022:
i. General Mills net sales growth in North America were up 11%:
1. Price: 19%
2. Volume: -8%
Over the last year its share price is down 35%.
- And down 59% from its peak in May of 2023.
- Note that from Dec 2019 to its peak in 2023 when it was taking all of those price increases its share price soared 70%
- But the way the math works, if you grow 70% and then fall 59% you are losing money:
c. Example: Original investment of $100
i. Increases 70% to $170
ii. Loses 59% to $68
1. Down 32% from the original investment.
Canada Inflation
Consumer Price Index (Dec, Jan, Feb adjusted for GST holiday):
- Sep: +1.6%
- Oct: +2.0%
- Nov: +1.9%
- Dec: +2.3%
- Jan: +2.7%
- Feb: +3.0%
- Mar: +2.3%
- Apr: +1.7%
- 2.3% adjusting for the impact of the elimination of the carbon tax.
- May: +1.7%
- 2.3% adjusted?
- Jun: +1.9%
- 2.5% adjusted?
- Jul: +1.7%
- Aug: +1.9%
- Sep: +2.4%
- Oct: +2.2%
- Nov: +2.2%
- Dec: +2.4%
- Jan-26: +2.3%
- Feb-26: +1.8% (+1.9% adjusted)
Inflation excluding gasoline:
- – Jan: +1.7%
- – Feb: +2.6%
- – Mar: +2.5%
- – Apr: +2.9%
- – May: +2.7%
- – Jun: +2.7%
- – Jul: +2.5%
- – Aug: +2.4%
- – Sep: +2.6%
- – Oct: +2.6%
- – Nov: +2.6%
- – Dec: +3.0%
- – Jan-26: +3.0%
- – Feb-26: +2.4%
Rising:
- Car insurance: +8.2%
- Food at restaurants: +7.8%
- Food: +5.4%
- Booze: +3.5%
Falling:
- Gas: -14.2%
The Bank of Canada’s favourite measures of core inflation:
CPI-Trimmed Mean: excludes the top and bottom 20% price changes
- – Dec-24: 2.5%
- – Jan-25: 2.7%
- – Feb-25: 2.9%
- – Mar-25: 2.8%
- – Apr-25: 3.1%
- – May-25: 3.0%
- – Jun-25: 3.0%
- – Jul-25: 3.1%
- – Aug-25: 3.0%
- – Sep-25: 3.1%
- – Oct-25: 3.0%
- – Nov-25: 2.8%
- – Dec-25: 2.8%
- – Jan-26: 2.4%
- – Feb-26: 2.3%
CPI-Weighted Median: focuses on the middle value
- Dec-24: 2.5%
- Jan-25: 2.5%
- Feb-25: 2.8%
- Mar-25: 2.8%
- Apr-25: 3.1%
- May-25: 3.0%
- Jun-25: 3.0%
- Jul-25: 3.1%
- Aug-25: 3.2%
- Sep-25: 3.2%
- Oct-25: 2.9%
- Nov-25: 2.8%
- Dec-25: 2.6%
- Jan-26: 2.5%
- Feb-26: 2.3%
Amazon
The WSJ reports that Amazon is upping its delivery options.
- One-hour delivery is now available in hundreds of locations.
- Cost:
- Prime members: $9.99
- Nonprime members: $19.99
- Cost:
- Three-hour deliver is now in over 2,000 locations.
- Cost:
- Prime members: $4.99
- Nonprime members: $14.99
- Cost:
- And they’re even testing 30-minute delivery.
- Meanwhile, Walmart is increasing its drone delivery service.
Financial Ructions
Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…
Of Interest
Global uncertainty is blowing out longer-term interest rates.
US 10-Year Yield (benchmark for 30-year mortgages):
- Oct 2019: 1.92%
- Oct 2023 (Peak): 4.85%
- Sep 2024 (recent low): 3.65%
- Apr 2026: 4.39%
Canada 5-Year Yield (benchmark for 5-year mortgages):
- Oct 2019: 1.69%
- Oct 2023 (Peak): 4.32%
- Apr 2025 (recent low): 2.51%
- Apr 2026: 3.20%
UK 10-Year Yield
- Oct 2019: 0.83% (joke)
- Apr 2026: 5.01%
- Highest since 2008
France 10-Year Yield
- Oct 2019: 0.12% (bigger joke)
- Apr 2026: 3.75%
- Highest since 2008.
German 10-Year Yield
- Oct 2019: -0.19% (bigger, stupider joke)
- Apr 2026: 3.04%
- Highest since 2011.
Japan 10-Year Yield
- Oct 2019: -0.03% (you know)
- Apr 2026: 2.28%
- Apart from a brief spike earlier this year, it’s the highest level since 1998.
Wholesale Price Inflation
The Producer Price Index or PPI measures the change in price that producers receive for their goods. You can think of it like a wholesale price that eventually gets passed on to consumers through retail prices.
- Over the last 15 years the correlation between the two has exceeded 92%.
Note that the previous month’s PPI numbers get revised for up to four months after the original reports due to late filers etc.
PPI for final demand
- – Jan/25: 3.8%
- – Feb/25: 3.4%
- – Mar/25: 3.2%
- – Apr/25: 2.4%
- – May/25: 2.7%
- – Jun/25: 2.4%
- – Jul/25: 3.2%
- – Aug/25: 2.7%
- – Sep/25: 3.0%
- – Oct/25: 2.8%
- – Nov/25: 3.0%
- – Dec/25: 3.0%
- – Jan/25: 2.9%
- – Feb/25: 3.4%
For core PPI, three months were revised higher and more recently two revised lower.
Core PPI (less food and energy):
- – Jan/25: 3.5%
- – Feb/25: 3.6%
- – Mar/25: 3.5%
- – Apr/25: 2.7%
- – May/25: 2.7%
- – Jun/25: 2.6%
- – Jul/25: 2.9%
- – Aug/25: 3.0%
- – Sep/25: 3.0%
- – Oct/25: 3.5%
- – Nov/25: 3.6%
- – Dec/25: 3.4%
- – Jan/25: 3.4%
- – Feb/25: 3.5%
Note that producer prices do trickle down into consumer prices, but PPI only includes prices received by domestic companies.
- So, if import prices are rising, they don’t directly impact PPI but have an indirect impact if those imported products are used in the production process by domestic companies.
- So, it’s hard to know how much of the increase is from tariffs or just general inflation.
- Imported goods that go into the production process impact prices with a delay.
- One study on the 2019 tariffs calculated that half the impact happened in the first 3-4 months.
- The full impact was felt within 9-12 months.
- One study on the 2019 tariffs calculated that half the impact happened in the first 3-4 months.
- Imported goods that go into the production process impact prices with a delay.
Book Review: “False Dawn“
By: George Selgin | 2025
Chapter 7: FDR and Gold
Americans were no longer allowed to hold gold and anyone violating this could face 10 years in prison, a fine of up to $10,000 ($251,000 in today’s money), or both.
– People were allowed to hold $100 of gold coins: $2,513 in today’s money.
This, along with limits on gold exports and deposit insurance, served to restore peoples’ faith in American banks.
It should be noted that FDR was not an inflationist, despite wanting commodity prices to rise to their pre-Depression levels.
– And he attempted to raise prices through an increase in the price of gold rather than an increase in the money supply.
Next, FDR started buying gold and depreciating the dollar at arbitrarily set prices.
– Keynes famously called this a gold standard on the booze and said it was “undignified.”
This did little to raise prices and the dollar was finally officially devalued in January 1934.
– The price of gold was now $35 an ounce vs. the previous $20.67.
Once devaluation was official, gold started flowing into the U.S.
– A more competitive dollar grew exports with gold coming the other way.
– And more gold mining was taking place to take advantage of the now higher price for gold.
– And inflows of foreign capital were enormous.
o In large part this was due to fears about the rise of Hitler in Germany.
§ And Frank Steindl said that “Without Adolf Hitler to spawn a capital flight to the United States, virtually no U.S. recovery would have occurred before 1941.”
Chapter 8: The AAA
Now that the banking crisis was behind them and the dollar had been devalued, FDR now focused on his New Deal recovery programs.
– The National Recovery Act (NRA) was meant to:
o Increase manufacturers’ revenues by reducing competition.
o Raise workers’ wages and give them more purchasing power.
– The Agricultural Adjustment Administration (AAA) was meant to boost commodity prices by reducing farmers’ output.
Most agree that the NRA hampered economic recovery, while there is more debate surrounding the AAA.
Farmers made up 22% of employment in the US.
– During World War I, with European farms out of commission there was high demand for commodities from the US and prices soared.
– These high prices along with government policies encouraged farmers to overexpand in farmland and equipment.
– Post-war there was a collapse in commodity prices with many farmers unable to repay the debt they took on to expand production.
– Farm foreclosures per 1,000 acres:
o 1913-1920: 3.2
o 1926: 17.4
o 1933: 38.8
– The answer of course was to lower production, but naturally farmers weren’t too keen on this idea and instead pushed for higher prices.
– To his credit, Herbert Hoover pushed back on this demand for higher prices.
o PM: And the great Benjamin M Anderson was also against the higher price policy.
But then came FDR and the AAA.
– It operated by giving farmers direct benefits and reducing output.
o The direct benefits were funded by taxing food processors, so food prices went up.
§ PM: Just what you need when people are lining up at soup kitchens.
– And by reducing output, farmers let go workers.
o One study estimated that the AAA added 2 million farm workers to the ranks of the unemployed.
– The program tended to benefit larger farms.
o 22% of the benefits went to 1% of the farmers.
§ These farmers were much better off than the consumers who were taxed to foot the bill.
– But even with all this, for the most part, commodity prices never got back to their pre-World War I levels.
Subsidies to farmers continue to this day.
– During COVID, farmers made more money than in any year since 2013.
That’s It:
- For Paulitical Economy® Post 359
- Until next time:
- Be free
- And do no harm.
Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy® should not be considered investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information. It is meant for general interest purposes only. Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.