Post 361: “Corporate Bifurcation With Consumers Buying Less Stuff While Governments Bail Out Governments”

Update

Hello everyone,

I hope you all had a nice Easter weekend.

A couple more podcast interviews for you.

I was on the Arete Podcast with Jake Boger. Arete is Greek for excellence and also excellence in moral virtue.  From their website: Arete Media is ultimately a confederation of content creators in various forms with the ultimate goal of helping ourselves and those around us expand our knowledge and skills in all forms. You can check them out at aretemedia.org.

Failcraft is a podcast about learning by failing.  Of course policymakers have inadvertently been failing us for many years and have yet to discover the learning bit.

And the link for the one-hour audio summary of my book from Lit in a Nutshell is now on our website: Here.

Summary

  • The construction of multifamily properties in the US has soared over the last few years.
    • Resulting in higher vacancy rates and lower rents.
  • European consumer products company Unilever got rid of its ice cream business last year.
    • Now they’re bidding adieu to the rest of their food business.
  • US confectionery company Mondelez has been rapidly increasing its prices to offset higher commodity costs.
    • Volume has been down four quarters in a row.
  • Netflix continues to hit it out of the park in terms of sales growth.
    • In the last six months members watched 96 billion hours of content.
  • Nike returns to negative growth.
    • And its share price continues to plummet.
  • Tesla sales are up a bit from last year but down from two years ago..
    • But the big news is that they will start mass production of their cybercab.
  • Canada’s Federal and Provincial government (taxpayers) bail out Ontario’s municipal governments.
    • This shouldn’t go down well in provinces with low new home development charges.
  • In Financial Ructions
    • US jobs were stronger than expected.
      • As was the quality of those jobs.
  • Book Review: False Dawn by George Selgin
    • First, we see that the NRA (National Recovery Act) served to delay the recovery.
      • PM: Not for the first time, the government would have been better off doing nothing.
    • Second, most of the benefits of well-intended policies to help homeowners instead went to lenders.
      • And that cheap credit is “dangerously habit-forming.”
        • PM: I’ll say.

News

US Vacancy Rates

There were a large number of multifamily properties built over the last few years, US Census Bureau:

  • 2017: 358,000
  • 2018: 345,000
  • 2019: 352,000
  • 2020: 375,000
  • 2021: 371,000
  • 2022: 368,000
  • 2023: 450,000
  • 2024: 608,000
  • 2025: 483,000
    • The completion of multi-family units over the last three years has on average been around 46% higher than the pre-COVID average.

As a result, vacancy rates are rising.

Vacancy rates, FRED:

  • 2019: 6.4%
  • 2022 (recent low): 5.6%
  • 2025: 7.2%

This vacancy rate is in line with the long-term average going back to 1956: 7.3%

  • The lowest on record was 5.0% back in 1978 and 1981.
  • The high was in 2009: 11.1%
    • Rents fell 4.1% that year
      • Effective rents that include free months’ rents and other perks fell even more.

And asking rents are falling.

  • According to Realtor.com, asking rents in America are now at a four-year low.
  • And have declined for 30 straight months (one a year-over-year basis).
    • Median asking rent: $1,667
      • Down 5.1% from peak rents in 2022.
      • Up 14.2% from pre-COVID levels.
        • But inflation has been 28% since then.
    • So in real terms i.e. assuming wages adjusted with inflation, rents have fallen 14%.
    • Some of the largest declines from peak:
      • Austin, Texas: -18.2%
      • Birmingham, Alabama (higher GDP per capita than Canada):
        • -17.1%
      • Memphis, Tennessee: -16.1%
      • Phoenix, Arizona: -15.6%
      • Atlanta, Georgia: -15.2%

However, existing rents are still rising according to iPropertyManagement.

  • This measures rental rates for people who are renewing or rolling over their rental agreement.
    • 2025: +7.5%
    • 2026: +2.9%
  • So, if you want a better deal you have to move.
    • Or at least threaten to.

States: Return on Investment

WalletHub, looks at each US state to determine the return on investment (ROI) for the taxes paid.

Top five:

  1. New Hampshire
  2. Florida
  3. South Dakota
  4. Missouri
  5. Ohio

Bottom Five:

46. New York

47. North Dakota

  • PM: What’s going on with the Dakotas: One in the top five and one in the bottom?
    • See below.

48. Hawaii

49. California

50. New Mexico

States with the highest state income tax rates:

  1. California: 13.3%
  2. New York: 10.9%
  3. New Jersey: 10.8%
  4. Oregon: 9.9%
  5. Minnesota: 9.9%

States with no income tax:

  • Alaska
  • Florida
  • Nevada
  • South Dakota
    • Dakotas mystery solved, although rates are low in North Dakota.
  • Tennessee
  • Texas
  • Wyoming
  • New Hampshire

Unilever

Unilever owns a number of well-known brands such as:

  • Axe
  • Cif
  • Clear
  • Closeup
  • Dove
  • Hellmann’s
  • Knorr
  • Lux
  • Lifebuoy
  • Pepsodent
  • Pond’s
  • Sunlight
  • Vaseline
  • TRESemme

Last December they spun-off their ice cream brands into a new company called the Magnum Ice Cream Company.

  • Brands include:
    • Ben & Jerry’s
    • Cornetto
    • Magnum
    • Wall’s
    • Popsicle
    • Fudgsicle
    • Creamsicle
    • Breyers
    • Good Humor
    • Klondike

And now Unilever is jettisoning its food business (its slowest growing division) and combining it with that of McCormick.

We talked about McCormick in Post 288 (Nov 2024). It is a US company and is the world’s largest maker of spices.

  • They also make seasoning mixes, condiments and extracts and food colour.
  • It started in Baltimore in 1889.
  • Brands include:
    • McCormick
    • Cholula Hot Sauce
    • Lawry’s
    • Club House
    • Frank’s RedHot
    • French’s
      • 1904: Started in New York by the French brothers.
      • 1926: Sold to J & J Colman of the UK
      • 2017: Sold by Reckitt Benckiser to McCormick
    • Old Bay Seasoning
    • And many others.

In return for transferring the food business, Unilever shareholders will receive shares of McCormick worth $29.1 billion.

Unilever adjusted sales:

  • 3Q/2023: +6.6%
  • 4Q/2023: +5.2%
  • 1Q/2024: +4.7%
  • 2Q/2024: +4.8%
  • 3Q/2024: +3.6%
  • 4Q/2024: +4.0%
  • 1Q/2025: +2.9%
  • 2Q/2025: +3.1%
  • 3Q/2025: +4.0%
  • 4Q/2025: +4.2%
    • Beauty and Wellbeing: +4.7%
    • Personal Care: +5.1%
    • Home Care: +4.7%
    • Food: +2.3%

Share price performance:

  • 1yr: -13.0%
  • 5yr: -5.7%

Mondelez

Mondelez is a US confectionery business and was formed in 2012 in Chicago.

  • Mondelez comes from the French word monde meaning world and delez which is supposed to be a word play on delicious.
    • PM: I don’t know, bit of a stretch for me.
      • How about Mon Delight?
  • It used to be part of Kraft Foods Inc. until in 2012 the company was split in two:
    • The snacks business became Mondelez.
    • The grocery business became Kraft Foods Group
      • In 2015 it became Kraft Heinz.

They own brands such as:

  • Belvita
  • Cadbury
    • 1824: Founded in Birmingham, England.
    • 1969: Merged with Schweppes.
    • 2003: Acquired Adams chewing gum business:
      • Halls
      • Dentyne
      • Trident
    • 2008: Company splits into two: Cadbury and Schweppes.
      • Merger was Schwepped aside.
    • 2010: Cadbury was bought by Kraft Foods Inc.
  • Chips Ahoy
  • Clorets
  • Clif Bar
  • Halls
  • Lu
  • Milka
  • Oreo
  • Philadelphia (cream cheese)
  • Ritz
  • Sour Patch Kids
  • Tang
    • Toblerone
  • Trident (recently sold)
  • Triscuit
  • Wheat Thins

Adjusted sales:

  • 3Q/2024: +5.4%
  • 4Q/2024: +5.2%
  • 1Q/2025: +3.1%
  • 2Q/2025: +5.6%
  • 3Q/2025: +3.4%
  • 4Q/2025: +5.1%
    • North America: -0.5%

Price:

  • 4Q/2024: +5.1%
  • 1Q/2025: +6.6%
  • 2Q/2025: +7.1%
  • 3Q/2025: +8.0%
  • 4Q/2025: +9.9%

Volume/Mix:

  • 4Q/2024: +0.1%
  • 1Q/2025: -3.5%
  • 2Q/2025: -1.5%
  • 3Q/2025: -4.6%
  • 4Q/2025: -4.8%

So far at least, the much higher prices, while resulting in lower volumes, are not resulting in lower sales.

Share price performance:

  • 1yr: -11.8%
  • 5yr: -2.2%

Netflix

Beginnings:

  • 1998: Netflix.com is launched:
    • DVD sales and rentals
  • 1999: Subscription model launched:
    • Unlimited rentals
    • No due dates or late fees.
    • $15.99 per month
      • $30 in today’s money.
    • More in Post 288

They now have 325 million paid memberships.

  • In the last six months of the year, members watched 96 billion hours on Netflix.

Some highlights:

  • The final season of Stranger Things had 120 million views.
  • Other big viewings:
    • Sean Combs: The Reckoning: 54 million.The Perfect Neighbor: 50 million.
    • The Beast in Me: 48 million.
    • Emily in Paris (season 5): 41 million.
  • Coming up in 2026
    • Bridgerton Season 4
    • Little House on the Prairie
    • Will Ferrell’s golf series The Hawk.
      • He’s a washed-up pro golfer attempting to make a comeback.
    • Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders Season 3
    • Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man
    • And they are looking at increasing the number of NFL games they cover including a possible Thanksgiving Eve game.

When we last wrote about Netflix they were bidding for Warner Brothers.

  • They lost out on that bid to Paramount Skydance.

Quarterly adjusted sales results:

  • –        1Q/2024: +18%
  • –        2Q/2024: +22%
  • –        3Q/2024: +21%
  • –        4Q/2024: +19%
  • –        1Q/2025: +16%
  • –        2Q/2025: +17%
  • –        3Q/2025: +17%
  • –        4Q/2025: +17%

Share price performance:

  • 1yr: +13.7%
  • 5yrs: +77.7%

Nike

Adjusted sales by quarter:

  • –        1Q/2024: +2%
  • –        2Q/24: -1%
  • –        3Q24: 0%
  • –        4Q/24: 0%
  • –        1Q/25: -8%
  • –        2Q/25: -9%
  • –        3Q/2025: -7%
  • –        4Q/2025: -11%
  • –        1Q/2026: -1%
  • –        2Q/2026: 0%
  • –        3Q/2026: -3%
    • By Brand:
      • Nike: -2%
      • Converse: -37%
    • By Category:
      • Footwear: -1%
      • Apparel: -4%
      • Equipment: -6%
    • By Region:
      • North America: +3%
      • Europe, Middle East, Africa: -7%
      • Greater China: -10%
        • The sales decline here is expected to accelerate to -20%
    • They are facing stiff competition from cheaper alternatives.
      • China accounts for 14.7% of sales.
      • Asia Pacific/Latin America: -2%
  • Nike’s stock price fell 15% on this announcement which piles on the poor stock performance of the last five years.
    • 1yr: -31%
    • 5yrs: -66%
    • The share price has lost almost twelve years of gains and is back to where it was in 2014.

Tesla

Tesla Deliveries:

  • –        Car deliveries by quarter:
  • –        1Q/2023: 422,875
  • –        2Q/2023: 466,140
  • –        3Q/2023: 435,059
  • –        4Q/2023: 484,507
  • –        1Q/2024: 389,810
  • –        2Q/2024: 443,956
  • –        3Q/2024: 462,890
  • –        4Q/2024: 495,570
  • –        1Q/2025: 336,681
  • –        2Q/2025: 384,122
  • –        3Q/2025: 497,099
  • –        4Q/2025: 418,227
  • –        1Q/2026: 358,023
    • Up 6.3% from last year.
      • But down 8.2% from two years ago.

The company noted that:

  • They plan on starting mass production of their autonomous Cybercab.
    • They will be priced at under $30,000.
      • While not making much on their cars will make Tesla a lot more money as they will then go on Tesla’s robotaxi ride-share app.
        • Depending on vehicle utilisation rates, each car could earn a profit for Tesla of anywhere from $10,000 to $25,000 per year.
  • They are ending production of Model S and Model X
    • This leaves the company with three models:
      • Model 3
      • Model Y
      • Cybertruck

Tesla share price performance:

  • 1yr: +57%
  • 5yr: +62%

Government Bails out Government (with taxpayer dollars)

As you know, I have talked many times about how outrageously high new development fees and taxes have contributed to skyrocketing home prices in the Toronto area.

  • Those fees amounted to up to 30% of the cost of building a new home.
  • Back in the early 1990s, new development fees and taxes were 1-5% of the cost of building a new home.
  • But then the provincial government significantly cut back on the funds it was transferring to municipalities.
    • The idea was to amalgamate cities to cut costs and get them to be more responsible with their budgets.
      • Fail. According to ChatGPT and GROK, real per capita spending for the city of Toronto has grown anywhere from 20-50% since 1997.
  • However, it hardly made sense to cut back on transfers to cities in Ontario which were experiencing higher population growth than most other Canadian cities.
  • To help out municipalities i.e. to help them not be more responsible, the provincial government passed the Development Charges Act in 1997 which outlined the ridiculous growth pays for growth policy.
    • Note that apart from British Columbia, other provinces have very low development charges.
    • Growth is paid from general tax revenues.
  • Allowing municipalities to explode development charges higher is particularly pernicious.
    • These taxes are invisible to the homebuyer in that they are not itemised when the person buys the home.
      • Instead, the homebuyer sees them indirectly through ridiculously expensive homes and assume that’s a result of greedy homebuilders or “that’s just what home prices do.”
      • Note that there is talk about finally itemising these fees.
    • All taxation should be clear and above board and, most of all, fair.
    • Development charges don’t tick any of those boxes.
  • And higher home prices get so expensive that homebuilders stop building homes resulting in lower development charges for municipalities.
  • So now, the Federal and Provincial governments are bailing out municipal governments in Ontario by kicking in a combined $8.8 billion in infrastructure spending.
    • To receive the funding, cities must cut development charges by at least 50%.
  • But here’s the kicker, the funding is available for ten years, but municipalities only have to cut development charges over the next three years.
  • Fortunately, some of the funding will go to municipalities that did not charge development fees i.e. they’re not being punished for doing the responsible thing.
    • The Federal and Provincial governments are also rebating the 13% harmonised sales tax on new homes.
  • Of course, some are rightly pointing out the unfairness of growth in Ontario being funded with Federal taxes i.e. have taxpayers in provinces with very low development charges help fund cuts in ridiculous development charges in Ontario.
  • Proponents of this will always say that “growth pay for growth.”
    • It’s a ridiculous statement.
    • First of all, growth did not pay for growth in the past and so a significant percentage of current homeowners did not have to pay such high new development charges.
    • Second, existing homeowners also benefit from the new infrastructure investment.
    • Third, most infrastructure has a lifespan of decades with future generations benefiting.
      • Therefore, infrastructure should be funded with long-term debt with multiple generations helping to pay it off i.e. sharing the cost.
        • This is when debt is a good thing.
  • And renters are also harmed with rising new development charges.
    • As the prices of new buildings soar landlords increase their rents to compensate.
    • Also, higher home values result in higher property taxes.
      • So, yes, as a homeowner your home price goes up, but if you have no intention of selling your home you lose as what you pay to the government increases each year.
        • Again, why should your home going up in price (which it shouldn’t do) make it more expensive to run the municipal government.
  • Infrastructure should be paid out of general tax revenue where we all share the cost.
    • Saying growth pays for growth is like saying the sick pay for being sick.
      • No, we all contribute to healthcare which is similar to a public good and we share the cost for those who need to access it.
  • Note that in the US, the home of free market capitalism (but fading fast) new development charges are, appropriately, extremely low.
  • Ridiculous DCs in Ontario are a result of the provincial government cutting funding to municipalities and then changing the law allowing those municipalities to subsequently hose the next generation.
  • Also, why is it fair that a young couple who may have lived in the city for thirty years have to be the ones responsible for funding growing infrastructure just because they bought a new home.
    • Shouldn’t their parents be responsible for that?
      • Joking of course, but this is how absurd the whole growth pays for growth argument is.
  • Bottom line is that growing infrastructure should be paid for by a combination of:
    • Pooled resources
    • Long-term funding
    • Some user fees where appropriate, feasible and fair.
      • For instance, when the provincial government built the 407 toll road they could have charged fees for however many years it took to pay off the debt used to fund the construction.
        • And then reduce or eliminate the fees: cue laugher.
      • Instead, they made the outrageous decision to sell a 99-year lease to a private company to fill a one-time hole in the government’s budget.
  • Ok, enough about that.

Financial Ructions

Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…

US Jobs

Establishment Survey: +178,000

  • Household Survey: -64,000
  • ADP: 62,000

Establishment survey adjusted monthly jobs growth:

  • Jan/25: -48,000
  • Feb/25: +42,000
  • Mar/25: +67,000
  • Apr/25: +108,000
  • May/25: +13,000
  • Jun/25: -20,000
  • Jul/25: +64,000
  • Aug/25: -70,000
  • Sep/25: +76,000
  • Oct/25: -140,000
  • Nov/25: +41,000
  • Dec/25: +48,000
  • Jan/26: +160,000
  • Feb/26: -133,000
  • Mar/26: +178,000

Household Survey: -64,000

  • Private industry: +496,000
  • Government: -414,000
    • Government workers now make up the lowest percentage of total workers in over two years: 13.1%
      • And private industry makes up the most.
    • Full-time: +335,000
    • Part-time: -188,000

The number of multiple job holders fell by over half a million workers over the last year.

  • It’s the biggest drop since COVID.

Book Review: False Dawn

By: George Selgin | 2025

Chapter 10: The NRA, Coda: The Brookings Report

The Brookings Institution conducted a very extensive nonpartisan review of the NRA back in 1935.

  • And Selgin says that like most other studies it showed that the NRA delayed economic recovery.
  • Here are some of the report’s findings:
    • It condemns the NRA’s overall rationale.
      • Specifically, “Raising the prices of labor or goods…is not the way to get a larger volume purchased.”
        • PM: No kidding.
    • The NRA catered to two different groups
      • Organised labor and their desire for higher wages and shorter work weeks.
    • PM: The NRA embraced this fallacious high wage theory.
    • For this to work companies would need to be able and willing to pay the higher wages before demand for their products increased.
    • Critics of businesses claimed the higher wages could be paid by cutting dividends or reducing profitability.
      • But wages constitute a much larger share of the business than dividends do
      • And many companies had no profit.
      • Not to mention the impact that all of this would have on reducing investment which is the lifeblood of an economy.
        • PM: Something we’re unfortunately experiencing in here in Canada.
    • The NRA actually believed in the absurd circular reasoning that higher wages would result in more spending which would help fund the higher wages.
      • PM: With this sort of rationale, we could all be billionaires.
        • Industrialists wanting relief from antitrust laws.
      • Rather than admit that catering to both was likely to restrict the recovery, the NRA believed that this was just what was needed.
        • PM: Both lead to higher costs and higher prices.
    • Their procedures were not based on coherent economic theory.
  • Selgin points out that what was needed was not higher wage rates as real wages were still strong due to falling prices and real wages were higher than before the Great Depressionstarted.
    • Instead, it was more wage hours that were needed and the NRA achieved the exact opposite of this.
      • The higher real wages of those who were lucky enough to remain employed came at the expense of other workers.
    • The NRA served to increase the costs of farmers which countered any commodity price increases the AAA was successful in achieving.
  • One of the issues was that prices had fallen from pre-Depression levels but of course debt contracts don’t adjust accordingly.
    • And so it becomes increasingly difficult to pay off debt that was contracted in a higher price environment.
    • And NRA policies failed to help because “Debt charges are paid from income, not from prices.”
      • PM: During the 1921 Depression, the government did not intervene and allowed for liquidation and debt haircuts.
        • Painful, but short and followed by a strong recovery.
  • Selgin points out that any recovery in the 1930s was despite the NRA and only happened due to the gold flowing into the country and increasing the money supply.

Chapter 11: A New Deal for Housing

The Home Owners’ Loan Corporation (HOLC) was established in 1933.

  • And Selgin says it was not mortgage holders that benefited most from this but instead mortgage lenders.
    • “HOLC put less emphasis on achieving principal reductions for borrowers than on offering their lenders generous prices for their mortgages, which it did in part by appraising mortgaged properties very generously”
      • PM: Where have we seen this before?
        • Here in Canada, for years OSFI turned a blind eye to the banks’ blanket appraisals of condominiums.

There was a significant boom in new housing construction in the 1920s.

  • Just to put things into context, new homes were being built at twice the rate of the crazy housing boom of the early 2000s.
    • And this when the population was a third of what it was in the 2000s.
  • And Selgin cites White in noting one of the causes of the housing booms in both the 1920s and early 2000s i.e. “easy Federal Reserve policy”
  • One of the issues was the nature of many mortgages back then i.e. they were not long-term, amortised loans.
    • And were interest-only loans with terms of five years or less.
      • After five years, the whole principal was due.
    • Mortgages were not offered by banks back then and instead were offered by building and loan associations.
      • PM: Like the Bailey Bros. Building and Loan in It’s a Wonderful Life.
    • These mortgages were longer-term: 11-13 years.

The Great Depression experienced declining home price and declining wages.

  • Many people defaulted inflicting great harm on mortgage lenders.

The HOLC plan was to take over distressed mortgages.

  • And would have a term of 10-15 years.
  • It ultimately refinanced a million mortgages helping keep people in their homes.
    • But of these HOLC eventually foreclosed on 200,000 or 20% of the mortgages they refinanced.

Selgin notes that HOLC’s bailout of lenders was an attempt to spur recovery by boosting their capital.

The May 1933 Emergency Farm Mortgage Act helped refinance farm mortgages.

  • From 1931 to 1932 delinquency rates on farm mortgages doubled from 23% to 50%

The Farm Credit Act allowed for lower collateral requirements:

  • 75% loans rather than 50%.
  • And farm credit authorities based their appraisals on crop prices that were significantly higher than current market prices.
    • Resulting in many loans that were worth more than the farm.

While the New Deal’s farm programs clearly helped farmers and lenders, determining whether or not those benefits were worth the cost to others “is another matter.”

  • While the cost of these programs was significant it would have been considerably worse if not for World War II driving farm values higher.

Selgin notes that it’s still difficult to determine how farm mortgage programs contributed to economic recovery.

  • However, he does say that subsidizing mortgages had long-run consequences as those subsidies did not end once the emergency was over.
    • And in fact continued into the 1980s.
      • Resulting in a 30% decline in the value of farm assets in the 1980s.

Selgin finishes the chapter by saying “Cheap credit, like opioid, is good for killing pain. Alas, it is also dangerously habit-forming.”

  • PM: Correct, and cheap credit does not exist in a free-market economy with participants making risk/return assessments with their own skin in the game.
    • It’s only possible with government intervention.
      • Thus, the Great Financial Crisis.
        • And the precarious situation in which we now find ourselves following fifteen years of easy money care of the US Federal Reserve.

That’s It:

  • For Paulitical Economy® Post 361
  • Until next time:
    • Be free
    • And do no harm.

Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy® should not be considered investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information.  It is meant for general interest purposes only.  Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.