Update
Hello everyone,
I hope you had a nice weekend: It continues here in Canada as we celebrate Victoria Day. It’s our gardening weekend with the holiday Monday being recovery day: sore back and knees. Our daughter works in a retirement home and today she’s doing a concert of Vera Lynn (The Forces Sweetheart) songs. I always used to play Vera Lynn’s Hits of the Blitz on Sundays so our girls grew up with that music: Full play list here with many of her classics.
You may recall that I was a guest on the WS Podcast a while back. Woj subsequently reviewed my book and I thought he did a great job. You can listen to it here.
Summary
- Father’s Day trumps Mother’s Day.
- Don’t shoot the messenger.
- Comparing Uber with Lyft.
- I’ve started using Lyft more often.
- Canada’s youth are suffering from bad government policy.
- While the country’s baby boomers benefit.
- A look at cash.
- Most people still carry it but unfortunately its relevance is declining.
- This is a really bad thing.
- Most people still carry it but unfortunately its relevance is declining.
- An Op-Ed from former Starbucks CEO Howard Schultz.
- Pointing out how the anti-business government policies in the state of Washington are driving jobs to other states.
- Headline inflation in the U.S. is the highest since 2023 as the war in Iran takes its toll.
- Core inflation that excludes energy is also rising.
- Financial Ructions:
- Bond yields are soaring from what are still relatively low levels.
- This will eventually matter.
- Wholesale inflation in the U.S. soared to 6.0%
- This will eventually matter.
- Bond yields are soaring from what are still relatively low levels.
- Book Review: False Dawn by George Selgin
- Although government spending plummeted after World War II the economy soared.
- Despite the warning from Keynesian economists.
- Official unemployment numbers would have been higher if it included all of the women who lost their jobs with men returning home after the war.
- But many of the women who left the workforce had no intention of staying there once the war ended.
- Private investment is the source of economic prosperity.
- In particular, net private fixed investment is what matters.
- Although government spending plummeted after World War II the economy soared.
News
Mom’s Get Short Shrift
According to MyVoucherCodes in the UK, the average spent on a gift for:
- Mother’s Day: £39.75
- Father’s Day: £54.38 (US$73, CA$100)
- 37% more for Dads
Uber vs. Lyft
Earlier this year I reported on Uber’s upfront pricing model which determines a rider’s propensity to pay.
- That is, if you are more likely to accept a higher charge that’s exactly what they’ll do.
- See below.
- While down in Florida I started using Lyft and the price differences are significant.
- I’m testing it up here in Canada and there are savings to be had.
- For a Comfort ride mid-morning from my house to:
- The airport:
- Uber: $52.88
- Lyft: $43.69
- The Rogers Centre
- Uber: $52.09
- Lyft: $45.56
- The airport:
- I’m not sure how Uber’s algo works but they may already be offering me lower prices as I keep refusing their rides.
- And many drivers work for both Uber and Lyft.
- One Lyft driver told me he prefers Lyft as it’s cheaper for the passenger, yet he gets paid the same amount of money per ride.
- Remember that Uber also uses their algo to assess drivers’ propensity to accept a lower payout.
- And as the Lyft fare is cheaper people tend to leave better tips so he can make more than when driving for Uber.
- A report (here) from Len Sherman of Columbia Business School says that much of Uber’s success in turning from a loss to a profit has come at the expense of riders (higher fares) and drivers (smaller cut of the fare).
- Some highlights
- Between 2018 and 2022 fares rose three times faster than inflation.
- Driver base pay rates were cut.
- In 2022 Uber changes how it calculates fares.
- It used to be based on:
- Trip duration
- Trip distance.
- It was changed to something called upfront pricing.
- Algorithms determine:
- What is the maximum a rider might pay for a trip
- What is the minimum pay a driver might accept.
- The report shows Uber’s take of fares rising from 32% in 2022 to 42% at the end of 2024: much higher than what I calculated above.
- Previously, the information of trip time, distance and surge pricing (higher prices when there is more demand) accounted for 98% of the fare and driver pay.
- But after Uber changed the pricing model, time, distance and surge pricing only explain 77% of the price.
- With the rest being your willingness to pay.
- Some highlights
- Various studies have shown that there can be a 50-100% difference in the fare charged for two people booking the exact same trip at the exact same time.
- And this difference is based on the “willingness to pay.”
- PM: This certainly helps to explain why Uber has become so expensive over the last few years.
- Thanks to A.Y. for putting me onto this.
- And this difference is based on the “willingness to pay.”
Special K Canada
In a Globe and Mail opinion piece, John Turley-Ewart looks at Canada’s lost generation:
- Percentage of those aged 25-39 years old who owned a detached home.
- Toronto:
- 1991: 33%
- 2021: 19%
- Vancouver:
- 1991: 36%
- 2021: 12%
- He notes that the numbers have likely deteriorated even further over the last five years.
- Toronto:
- Percentage of 25-39 year-olds who were married and had children:
- Millennials: 26.6%
- Gen-Xers: 34.5%
- Baby Boomers: 46.6%
- PM: Note that the propensity to have kids later in life impacts this.
- But I would bet most of this is due to housing affordability.
- PM: Note that the propensity to have kids later in life impacts this.
- Percentage of 25-39 year olds who lived with their parents:
- Millennials: 16.3%
- Gen-Xers: 12.2%
- Baby Boomers: 8.2%
- According to RBC, Canadians under the age of 35 are the only cohort to suffer a decline in real incomes from 2020 to 2025.
Cash
UK:
- Percentage of Britains who said that they had used cash at least once in the previous two weeks: Daily Mirror
- 2024: 73%
- 2025: 69%
- 2026: 61%
- Percentage of Britains who prefer to use cash:
- 2025: 17%
- 2026: 13%
- Cash preference by age:
- 55 years and over: 16%
- 35-44 years: 9%
- Fully cashless: 10%
US:
- According to Clearlypayments:
- Percentage of transactions made with cash:
- 2012: 31%
- 2019: 26%
- 2025: 16-18%.
- Percentage of transactions made with cash:
- Transactions (approximate) by method:
- Credit cards: 34%
- Debit cards: 29%
- Mobile wallets: 13%
- Cash: 17%
- Other (ACH, checks etc.): <5%
- Debit cards have replaced cash for everyday spending.
- Credit cards used for larger purchases.
- Percentage of Americans that still carry cash: 82-85%.
- Median amount: $40-60.
- PM: I always like to have cash on me.
- Even back in 2003 fewer people were carrying cash.
- That was the year we had a massive power outage here in Ontario.
- POS systems were not working so credit and debit cards were of no use.
- PM to the rescue with his cash:
- PM: I always like to have cash on me.
- Some restaurants stayed open: gas stoves/ovens.
- We had lamb and Greek wine until busses started running again.
- Median amount: $40-60.
- 5% of adult Americans don’t have a bank account.
PM: It’s really important that we don’t do away with cash.
- As I write in my book Capital Offence: Why Some Benefit at Your Expense, if policymakers are successful at eliminating cash, not only will create significant privacy concerns, but it will be even easier for them to take your capital from you.
- As I discuss regularly in my podcast interviews, there’s a big difference between money and capital.
- Money temporarily stores capital.
- If you aren’t able to hold your money in cash form then policymakers could decide to extract the capital from your money by taking interest rates deep into negative territory.
- Never mind that negative interest rates is an abomination for the wealth generating capacity of an economy.
- As I discuss regularly in my podcast interviews, there’s a big difference between money and capital.
Governments Hostile To Business
In a WSJ opinion piece, former Starbucks CEO Howard Schultz (HS) laments the path chosen by government officials in Seattle and the state of Washington.
As a reminder, Starbucks is based in Seattle, Washington.
- They have over 40,000 stores around the world.
- It started in 1971 and their first store was in the Pike Place Market.
- See Post 302 for a look back.
In the opinion piece HS says that:
- After spending four decades in Washington state he has moved to Florida.
- And that much of the decision to leave was based on “family choices and my stage of life.”
- PM: Much, meaning not all.
He felt it was his responsibility to speak up about what was going with government in his former home town.
- Washington used to be a very friendly business operating environment and for businesses start-ups.
- That has changed.
- Washington state punches well above its weight in terms of large successful businesses:
- Starbucks
- Amazon
- Costco
- Microsoft
- The influx of capital and investment led to worldclass businesses and higher wages.
- This all worked because risk-taking was rewarded.
- HS lists a number of problems that didn’t exist before:
- Chronic Homelessness
- Disorder in core business districts
- Persistent budget deficits
- Declining public school outcomes
- A slowing technology hiring cycle.
- One of the main issues is that the Mayor of Seattle, Katie Wilson, has cast business as the enemy rather than a partner.
- And for those who don’t agree with her more socialist policies she recommends that they leave the state.
- PM: Just what they need, fewer workers from whom they can collect taxes.
- And for those who don’t agree with her more socialist policies she recommends that they leave the state.
- What’s needed in government is reform and performance management.
- PM: Good luck with that.
- He rightly points out that the government seems to be relying on a very popular theory of late i.e. that prosperity can be obtained through redistribution rather than growth.
- Starbucks has announced that it will shift hundreds of corporate jobs from Seattle to Tennessee.
- Cities don’t collapse overnight but steadily deteriorate and in Seattle’s case it’s due to:
- Declining public safety.
- Fiscal irresponsibility.
- Higher downtown vacancies reduce foot traffic.
- The whole thing slowly spirals downwards.
- Entrepreneurs take risks others won’t and do so with their own skin in the game.
- And pay the consequences of failure.
- There are no such consequences for government actors when they fail.
- Instead, the consequences fall on the public.
- There are no such consequences for government actors when they fail.
- And pay the consequences of failure.
- Prosperity is driven by economic growth and job creation.
PM: I highly recommend reading Howard Schultz’s book Onward: How Starbucks Fought for Its Life without Losing Its Soul.
- I reviewed it many years ago and may make it my next book review for Paulitical Economy.
US Inflation
- Dec-2025: 2.9%
- Jan-2025: 3.0%
- Feb-2025: 2.8%
- Mar-2025: 2.4%
- Apr-2025: 2.3%
- May-2025: 2.4%
- Jun-2025: 2.7%
- Jul-2025: 2.7%
- Aug-2025: 2.9%
- Sep-2025: 3.0%
- Oct/Nov-2025: 2.7%
- Dec-2025: 2.7%
- Jan-2026: 2.4%
- Feb-2026: 2.4%
- Mar-2026: 3.3%
- Apr-2026: 3.8%
- Highest since 2023.
Core inflation (Less food and energy):
- Dec: 3.2%
- Jan: 3.3%
- Feb: 3.1%
- Mar: 2.8%
- Apr: 2.8%
- May: 2.8%
- Jun: 2.9%
- Jul: 3.1%
- Aug: 3.1%
- Sep: 3.0%
- Oct/Nov: 2.6%
- Dec: 2.6%
- Jan-2026: 2.5%
- Feb-2026: 2.5%
- Mar-2026: 2.6%
- Apr-2026: 2.8%
Moving Up:
- Gas: +28.4%
- Airline fares: +20.7%
- Note that I read an article about falling air fares in Europe.
- Higher jet fuel is being offset by much lower demand for flights.
- Prices for some routes have been cut 10%.
- And summer holiday parks bookings in the UK are up 30% from last year according to holiday park chain Haven.
- Higher jet fuel is being offset by much lower demand for flights.
- Note that I read an article about falling air fares in Europe.
- Coffee: +18.5%
- Tariffs accounted for 2-5% of this increase (GROK)
- Weather driven supply shortages in Brazil are the main cause.
- Jewelry: +16.1%
- Beef and veal: +14.8%
- Watches: +8.8%
- Fresh fruits and vegetables: +6.5%
- Fresh vegetables: +11.5%
- Tomatoes: +39.7%
- Poor weather and supply shortages
- Tariffs on Mexican tomatoes.
- Higher input costs: fuel
- Dental services: +6.7%
- Fish and seafood: +6.2%
- Apparel: +4.2%
- Food: +3.2%
- Tomatoes: +39.7%
- Fresh vegetables: +11.5%
Moving Down:
- Eggs: -39.2%
- Smartphones: -12.4%
- Admission to sporting events: -10.0%
- I guess this doesn’t include the World Cup: prices are very high.
- Men’s suits: -7.1%
- Used cars and trucks: -2.7%
Financial Ructions
Note: ‘Financial Ructions’ is optional-to-read for those who are interested in taking a bit of a deeper dive…
Of Interest
Over the last ten days the yield on the Japanese Government 10-Year bond has soared 27 basis points and are much higher than pre-COVID rates.
- 2019: -0.17%
- 2026: +2.74%
- Highest since 1996.
Meanwhile, the 30-Year bond yield rose 39 basis points.
- 2019: +0.36%
- 2026: +4.10%
And as a reminder, Japan has one of the highest debt to GDP numbers in the world.
One of these days, massive debt and rising interest rates will matter.
Wholesale Price Inflation
The Producer Price Index or PPI measures the change in price that producers receive for their goods. You can think of it like a wholesale price that eventually gets passed on to consumers through retail prices.
- Over the last 15 years the correlation between the two has exceeded 92%.
Note that the previous month’s PPI numbers get revised for up to four months after the original reports due to late filers etc.
PPI for final demand
- Jan/25: 3.8%
- Feb/25: 3.4%
- Mar/25: 3.2%
- Apr/25: 2.4%
- May/25: 2.7%
- Jun/25: 2.4%
- Jul/25: 3.2%
- Aug/25: 2.7%
- Sep/25: 3.0%
- Oct/25: 2.8%
- Nov/25: 3.0%
- Dec/25: 3.0%
- Jan/26: 2.9%
- Feb/26: 3.4%
- Mar/26: 4.3%
- Apr/26: 6.0%
- Largest increase since Dec 2022
Core PPI (less food and energy):
- Jan/25: 3.5%
- Feb/25: 3.6%
- Mar/25: 3.5%
- Apr/25: 2.7%
- May/25: 2.7%
- Jun/25: 2.6%
- Jul/25: 2.9%
- Aug/25: 3.0%
- Sep/25: 3.0%
- Oct/25: 3.5%
- Nov/25: 3.6%
- Dec/25: 3.4%
- Jan/26: 3.5%
- Feb/26: 3.6%
- Mar/26: 3.7%
- Apr/26: 4.4%
Book Review: “False Dawn“
By George Selgin | 2025
Chapter 22: The Phantom Depression
Fears of a new Great Depression occurring after World War II ended were considered a “worst case scenario.”
- That is, a new economic debacle would occur in the worst-case scenario of government not drastically increasing spending in order to off-set the decline in military spending.
- With 8 million men and women returning home, unemployment would rise to at least 12%
- This was the view of Keynesian economist Alvin Hansen.
- However, the worst-case scenario is exactly what happened: government did not increase spending to offset the decline in spending on war materiel.
Most war control measures were eliminated after the war.
Government spending as a percentage of GDP fell from 32% to 16%.
- The fiscal deficit became a fiscal surplus.
Despite this, unemployment did not soar as the Keynesians had predicted.
- Unemployment ranged between 3.5-4.0% until 1949.
GS rightly points out the employment is “not an end in itself.”
- The point of employment is to contribute to the production of goods and services.
According to official GDP data, the fall in GDP from 1945 to 1946 was the largest on record.
- But as we’ve seen in previous book reviews, inflation during the war was significantly understated due to price controls and significantly overstated after the war.
- And the biggest issue is including the production of war materiel in GDP.
- PM: Yes, government “spending” fell after the war but little or any of that spending contributed to consumer welfare.
- Just like employment is not an end in itself, likewise rising GDP.
- The government can at any time increase spending and boost GDP.
- But if that spending is to build bridges to nowhere it not only does not contribute to the economic welfare of its citizens but detracts from the productive capacity of the economy.
- The government can at any time increase spending and boost GDP.
- Just like employment is not an end in itself, likewise rising GDP.
Chapter 23: The Fate of Rosie the Riveter
There are some who claim that the real unemployment rate after the war was significantly higher than the official statistics.
- Millions of women entered the workforce during the war to help manufacture munitions or replace the male workers who had gone overseas.
- When the men returned home, many women lost their jobs but weren’t considered unemployed.
However, while GS acknowledges the unfairness of many women losing their jobs when the men returned home, many other women voluntarily left the workforce.
- During the war the government went to “extraordinary lengths” to coax more women into the labor force.
- Many single women were already working and in order to attract married women into the workforce the government offered them “extraordinarily high pay.”
- The government also appealed to their patriotism to get them working.
- Most of these women only intended to work for the duration of the war.
- Many single women were already working and in order to attract married women into the workforce the government offered them “extraordinarily high pay.”
Chapter 24: Happy Days
The post-war prosperity was a result of a boom in private spending off-setting the decline in government spending.
- And it was not a result of government relief payments acting as economic stabilizers.
- A study by Alisdair McKay and Ricardo Reis demonstrates no benefits from stabilizers on “aggregate demand management.”
- And in fact make “output and employment more volatile than they would have been otherwise.”
During the war, consumer spending on durable goods plummeted simply because those goods were not available for purchase.
- Consumption as a percentage of income fell.
- The savings rate soared.
- 1929: 5%
- 1944: 30%
However, after the war, people did not spend their savings.
- Consumption soared because they simply started saving less of their income.
- But they still saved and the savings rate was higher than in the 1920s and remained elevated until the 1980s.
Both savings and spending remained buoyant despite severe cutbacks in government spending.
- The source of this prosperity was business. Gross private domestic investment:
- 1945: $10.6 billion
- 1946: $30.6 billion
- 1947: $34.0 billion
- 1948: $46.0 billion
- Private investment as a percentage of GNP:
- 1920s: 16%
- 1945: 5%
- 1946: 14.7%
- 1947: 14.7%
- 1948: 17.9%
GS notes that net private investment went into negative territory at the beginning of the Great Depression.
- Depreciation exceeded capital expenditures.
Specifically, GS notes that it’s net fixed private investment that is “an especially reliable indicator of both the progress of economic recovery and investment’s contribution to it.”
- This figure had been negative for much of the 1930s and early 1940s.
- After the war it soared and was almost four times higher than during the late 1920s.
GS notes that business cycles are primarily about private investment.
- “Self-sustaining” recoveries are only possible through private investment.
- And while fiscal or monetary policy can provide the means of paying for goods, they can’t “deliver the goods.”
- PM: Note that fiscal and monetary policy can only provide the means by first obtaining it from the private sector.
That’s It:
- For Paulitical Economy® Post 367
- Until next time:
- Be free
- And do no harm.
Disclaimer: Note that Paulitical Economy® should not be considered investment advice, and I have not verified all of the sources of information. It is meant for general interest purposes only. Please consult an advisor if you plan on putting any of your hard-earned capital to work during these turbulent times.